But the notion that Gawker Mediathe company, encompassing seven web sites, that Thiel is attempting to permanently silenceis best understood as a platform for spewing hatred, or for bullying, is at odds with our own experience. And we cant help but conclude it is at odds with a lot of other peoples experience. If our lengthy published record of news, essays, investigations, satire, and criticism is not journalism, as the refrain goes, then why has so much of it been cited, amplified, and followed by our more respectable establishment peers? If we aim for nothing but cruelty, or nothing but clicks, why have our writers drawn so many of the finest (or most well-remunerated) writers in the rest of the business to engage with our work?
Journalism is as journalism does. Anyone moved to dismiss the million-plus stories that we have published over the years as nothing more than gutter journalism ought to account for the by-no-means-comprehensive sampling of posts below, which we have arranged along with examples of the contemporaneous reaction to, praise for, and impact of the work. There are countless other posts that could join them. This is what Peter Thiel is trying to destroy.