Seeing as I've been woefully inept at remaining current, I instead decided to postpone my plans to watch this until there was a decent of material to work through. Now's that time, and here are my impressions to go along with it!
---------------------------------
Full of bluster and bombast, there is definitely much that I find enjoyable about the show. Though, having only watched it recently, I find myself removed from the zeitgeist knowing that this was a show that (initially) carried a great deal of hype, but not quite knowing whether that managed to persist. Now, having watched the first 12 episodes that form the first half of this tale I find myself satisfied with what Ive seen, if not entirely besotted.
The, shall we say, more lurid aspects of the presentation certainly rankle with me. Theres no hiding away from the fact that the fanservice is pervasive. Which is a curiousity unto itself, seeing as it is such a core aspect of Kill la Kills identity - for better or worse. Flagrant and excessive, even as a narrative crutch, I don't accept it as a conceit that empowers females, no. So long as each of these cuts is permeated by the pervasive leeriness that has been present from the very first episode, it will continue to detract.
Stylistically, it's clearly something that is considered, and in that regard, I can respect the clarity of vision. The narrative - from the action, all the way down to the comedy, is almost exclusively dictated by what (and how much) skin is on show. Traditionally portrayed as a particular character quirk, this mentality instead seems to permeate the entire world view of Kill la Kill. It's not so much if a individual character is overtly sexual or not, but rather how they react to it. The dichotomy of which is relatively one-note within the show. It only ever seems able to flitter between arousal and embarrassment.
The seriousness by which it treats all this is akin to a child opening a thesaurus and seeing how many different ways they can describe the female anatomy, giggling all the while. Theres no nuance, no subtly, but that admittedly isn't the intent of Kill la Kill. But if what you're left with carries some boorish undertones, is really all that admirable?
The style of the show is something which I (obviously) feel conflicted about, and this extends to the animation itself. The ramshackle nature of its presentation is quite charming, but the tendency to lean on the use of sporadic character movement does become a bit too much on times. It veers a later too much into feeling like it's a shortcut (because it is), which begins to pull the curtain back a little more than I'd like. Dont let me conflate things, because this show does have the ability to look really good it just seems content to only occasionally remind us of that fact.
A lot of these aspects are supplementary to the overall experience, or at least to a degree that they don't necessarily supplant the more positive aspects. Which I guess brings me to my biggest problem the characters. Its not so much the characterization of the cast that I have a problem with, more that they don't really have any to speak of. Even in a show that is ostensibly about the action, you still want that human element to be tangible.
An antagonist should be a foil. Basically something for our protagonist to clash against, but here we have an individual, Satsuki, who is largely ambivalent to the whole affair. The conflict exists as individuals who are on opposing sides, not necessarily a clash of personality, nor ideals (at least, mutually). It very much feels like a situation that exists within the context of being a show. It feels like an obligation - something that each protracted showdown between her and Ryuuko just exacerbates. The conceit of their conflict (and by extension, the whole narrative), ultimately, just doesn't feel all that substantive.
Even as a satellite character, its difficult to accept Satsukis position. Yes, a lot of her appeal (at least within the narrative) lies within her sheer force of will and by extension, her power. But thats conveyed as a simple means to an end, and many of her subordinates mention how its much more to do with her indomitable personality. The problem being that we aren't ever really privy to any of these aforementioned traits, and so what we are left with is a pretty bland and one-note character. Largely existing as an aloof bystander, I suspect this is a ploy to delay the eventual gratification of knowing exactly what her true role in all of this is. Though, its becoming extremely detrimental - particularly as she acts as the centre that all this hinges on. She just isnt an engaging presence
at all. Perfection is boring, and heres the proof.
Conversely, Mako is the spasmodic heart of the show, exhibiting all the energy and whimsy that the audience is all too happy to share in. I'm pleased that they seem aware of this, as her presence only seems to grow with each episode.
If I ever needed a reassuring reminder as to why I shouldnt even entertain the prospect of not finishing the show, itd be the music. The true joy of Kill la Kill is hearing that crescendo, whenever an enemy is toppled. Its such a satisfying feeling, that I would be perfectly content if the remaining episodes were simply an attempt in trying to replicate those moments, ad-nauseum.
In light of all this, it'd be only right to assume that I don't really like Kill la Kill? No, on the contrary, I do like it - quite a bit in fact. I just think that it could so much more, so hopefully it becomes more capable of scaling those heights, and with greater frequency.