Pixar's usually really good at tugging those emotional strings - and at just the right moments, too. But here, the characters I should be caring about were wooden and one-dimensional. They lacked any charm and just played our their character archetypes. For the rest, it's as if they knew the story was boring, so they tried their best to liven it up with kooky other-characters that you'd imagine your uncool older relative thinks up when they want to entertain the teens. Not edgy enough? Well, lets amp it up 20 notches, they have to like it, right?
Nothing felt earned. And the tone was all over the place. Also, thank you Brokeback Mountain for forever etching that style of music in my mind so that it's associated with forbidden gay relationships.