She isn't really "cursed" anymore anyways. She embraces being a werewolf. As such, she's most likely happy to planeswalk as either or. It's probably more prudent to do it as a wolf anyway, given there are no guarantees of human dominance, but danger is a sure thing.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Magic: the Gathering - Oath o/t Gatewatch |OT| Look again, the mana is now diamonds!
- Thread starter SigmasonicX
- Start date
- Status
She isn't really "cursed" anymore anyways. She embraces being a werewolf. As such, she's most likely happy to planeswalk as either or. It's probably more prudent to do it as a wolf anyway, given there are no guarantees of human dominance, but danger is a sure thing.
It seems overhyped. Four counters is probably too much and since it's a creature there's some easy disruption out there. It might work in Standard and as a tool against certain decks, but it's not the be-all-end-all. There's just too much competition at the 2CC spot in most formats.
Could be a great card, but clearly no Goyf.
I'm inclined to agree with the feeling that it's overhyped. I've been wrong about that CMC in that color before (*cough* mini Jace *cough) but I've been wrong about that CMC in general (I still have a pile of Skylashers from when I was, well, greener). I won't be buying in at this price -- I think we have the right idea on this one. I'll pick it up for funsies when it drops to a much lower price.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Yup Reflector Mage is going to make people playing that sad.
Without fetches I assume Reflector Mage is not going to be as widespread as it is today.
I'm doing a proxy of the entire set before it releases. Doing 2 copies of each and sleeving each one.
The leaks kind if fueled the idea with so many Commons already.
I have everything done shown so far and only cost was sleeves bought with store credit that I can obviously reuse.
For limited obviously. Lots of play testing will be happening.
The leaks kind if fueled the idea with so many Commons already.
I have everything done shown so far and only cost was sleeves bought with store credit that I can obviously reuse.
For limited obviously. Lots of play testing will be happening.
You really think Relfector Mage is going to disappear because fetches do? I would imagine the amount of 4-Color Good Stuff decks we see now will decrease for sure, so in sheer numbers, maybe you're right. But I think Reflector Mage will still find a comfortable place in the regularly played cards group of the next standard configuration.
A Serious Man
Member
4C good stuff decks won't decrease after rotation, they'll cease to exist altogether. 3C decks are going to take a huge hit too. Standard will be a completely different beast, we really don't know what will be good or not.
Wonder what dual lands we'll get in SoI, if any. Obviously could just reprint the Innistrad enemy color buddy lands, (Isolated Chapel et al) since they play real well with the battle lands. But would those play too well? That'd get us back to Standard mana bases similar to RTR/Innistrad which made 3 colors pretty convenient to play.
The U/W flash deck was just a value tempo deck.
I could easily see a future U/W tempo deck playing Reflector Mage t3, bouncing something. Opponent plays another creature. You counter it with Ojutai's Command or whatever. T5 Ojutai. T6 attack with Avacyn backup.
Edit: Great now I look silly after you edited.
I could easily see a future U/W tempo deck playing Reflector Mage t3, bouncing something. Opponent plays another creature. You counter it with Ojutai's Command or whatever. T5 Ojutai. T6 attack with Avacyn backup.
Edit: Great now I look silly after you edited.
Familienoberhauptvogel
Banned
Except she's in danger to be murdered in more places as a werewolf than a human
I'm pretty sure UWR will still be a deck. It still has two manlands to work with and Ojutai's Command + Dragonmaster Outcast is still insane value.
Familienoberhauptvogel
Banned
it could also run Eerie Influence + GDD
charlequin
Banned
She's not really cursed? That's the whole point? We already did the cursed-PW thing with Garruk anyway. I'm honestly perplexed here.
I agree with all of this completely, although if I wanted to look for something that would still be good after existing archetypes and manabases are blown up, an efficient two-color creature with a crushing tempo ETBT ability would be one decent place to start.
There's still gonna be a dual land cycle in every block, the two-block paradigm isn't gonna change that -- they have to replace the ones we'd get from the core set.
So is that last colorless flip card on the Rare sheet a Land or a Colorless card? It's not an artifact based on how the pattern looks on the C/U checklist
https://www.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/comments/49isty/soi_the_first_letter_of_the_colorless_mythic_is_m/
I'm fairly convinced that this is Markov Manor after reading this thread. After seeing the art for Declaration in Stone, it has good reason to flip too.
Familienoberhauptvogel
Banned
she is still cursed she just came to terms with it and has control over it but she was still bitten and remains cursed. My point is that if she's just another human walker when not a DFC she's really just another of a dozen.
I guess that's what I meant by "decrease" haha But I agree, and I'm excited to see how it will change.
Joe Molotov
Member
Remembrance
Member
ETB tapped and investigate?
charlequin
Banned
Yes, that point is bizarre and makes no sense.
Yeah, I am confident that is accurate, it's perfectly situated in the story to be a flip card and this is the last chance they'd have to print it as a land pre-destruction anyway.
Im thinking it's the M10 allied ones- the cycle rotating out is allied. They also play well/tricky with the BFZ lands, in that they don't enable consistent 3 color decks
Not every deck can stretch its mana base to play Reflector Mage. Maybe Burn or Aggro will dominate. Maybe Green will be the go-to color that all other colors will bow to. Either way, it will still be around, no doubt about that. It's too good to go away.
Those would actually be pretty good methinks. Probably a bit better than temples.
Problem is that they'd broke Shape Anew. Nothing particularly stupid but, 3U for Blighsteel every time is sorta dumb.
Is she? Remember, she's intelligent as a wolf. Is a wolf person any more limely to be murdered for being a wolf person than a cat persom is for being a cat persin? Or a bird person for being a bird person.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
They should bring back filter lands.
No reason or anything. I guess they would be good with people wanting to play Eldrazi decks since they tap for C but mostly just because why not
No reason or anything. I guess they would be good with people wanting to play Eldrazi decks since they tap for C but mostly just because why not
If I had to guess I would say a bird person is pretty likely to be murdered by a cat person
I'd wager the dragons, the gorgon, and the demon are gonna have a lot more trouble in the "not getting attacked on sight on every new world" aspect of planeswalking.
I would love if they did. They're a bit too pricey these days. I'd also love if they brought back and completed the Fastlands cycle. Blackcleave Cliffs is like $30 now, which is absurd.
Also in wolf form she'd have supernatural strength so that probably helps with the not getting ganked.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I can only guess that if you were left with just the lands we have now, the correct answer to what lands you play probably involves playing Evolving Wilds in constructed.
A Serious Man
Member
It really all depends on if it's possible to make the mana work. We're losing fetches and the tri-lands and the BfZ duals are about to get a lot slower than they already are. We've yet to see what kind of mana SoI will provide but it doesn't look like the set will be big on multicolor mechanics.
And Ojutai's Command is pretty damn sweet with Madness around. Securing a playset while it's only a couple bucks might not be a bad idea.
Giant Panda
Member
I would guess that werewolves are seen as inherently more threatening, especially on planes that don't have werewolves.
This bears highlighting. I think they're knocking the flavor out of the park with SoI, and I like that it's going to have its own identity mechanically as well, despite transform returning. OG Innistrad had the multicolor flashback cards which gave it more of a gold feeling than this appears it's going to have.
WanderingWind
Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
Good. Down with gold. Bring back "3 color deck? Lol, good luck in Christmas land n00b" standard.
Cosmo Clock 21
Banned
Would sit down and have some tea with
People were playing Lightning Angel when she was legal and the only dual lands you had at that time were tapped allied lands and painlands.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
There's likely to be a bunch of effects that let you fuck with graveyards to get people off of Delirium, though.
charlequin
Banned
Agreed on both points. The filterlands are a pretty fair set of duals -- I think the hybrid symbols are the biggest thing keeping them back. And the Scars fastlands are underappreciated and could really use a finished set. (I've actually been wondering for a while if they'd print the enemy set of those here the way they printed the enemy checklands in the first Innistrad.)
The set's gonna have gold cards (necessary to support all those two-color tribes, as well as for the inevitable limited archetypes) but yeah, doesn't seem like it's going to be a strong theme at all, probably notably less so than BFZ.
Mindwrack Demon's non-duel deck art is metal as fuck.
Holy Fuck, why can't all Magic card art be this sick?! That is goddamn fantastic.
A Serious Man
Member
We'll see if those mana bases can be consistent and fast enough to be tier 1. There is no doubt it's going to be more difficult moving forward.
The duel deck art is downright embarrassing in comparison.Mindwrack Demon's non-duel deck art is metal as fuck.
charlequin
Banned
Matt Stewart is usually good, but this is even a step up, IMO.
Also: another illustration on the Emrakul-evidence pile.
Infinite Stars
Member
If I had to venture a guess, Enemy colors are going to be huge on Innistrad. There's a huge upside without the Fetches to just run 4x Painlands and 4x Manlands vs 4x Santa and 4x Discount Duals.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
The real issue is that the incentives to go 3 color are far less when you're in a "normal" standard where there aren't 3-colored cards and everything good has double-single color requirements. Cards like Drana, or Undergrowth Champ, etc. don't see play because playing 1GG is actually harder than WBG when you can pull up on-demand duals.
We know maybe 10% of the cards in SOI so far, but the most generically OP cards in the enviornment are what, Gideon and Avacyn?
In bird speak we refer to this as a dick move
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked