Mass Effect 3 SPOILER THREAD: LOTS OF SPECULATION FROM EVERYONE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Km6NE.jpg
 
Wasn't Miranda in TIM's room in ME2? Why did she forget where his homebase was?

I think Liara also went there in one of the comics. They just decided not to mention any of that, I guess.

That's the kind of plot hole I'm okay with. Trying to find his base is much more interesting than just being told.
 
Strip poker with Tali, and you can have my 1600 Bioware points.
 
I just beat the game last night. I am now catching up with the ending explanations/theories. I didn't quite understand what was going on at the time, I didn't even notice The Illusive Man was showed with the Blue choice and Anderson was the red. I chose green not fully understanding and regret that now

Why? I consider Synthesis to be the "right" ending.

However, everyone wants Shepard to live, so I'm seeing most people side with the Renegade/Destroy option.

In the end, the problem with the ending isn't the content or the three choices; it's the brevity of the 3 minute cutscene after the choice is made. It felt super rushed for me.
 
Why? I consider Synthesis to be the "right" ending.

However, everyone wants Shepard to live, so I'm seeing most people side with the Renegade/Destroy option.

In the end, the problem with the ending isn't the content or the three choices; it's the brevity of the 3 minute cutscene after the choice is made. It felt super rushed for me.
Both the synthesis option and the controlling reapers option means that the reapers won. You've been indoctrinated.
 
He got baby reapers parts from the collector base I blew up. So moving a sun should be little challenge

Charred human/reaper heart is delicious.

I had an argument with a coworker yesterday about when the Illusive Man became indoctrinated. Was it pre-ME2, during ME2, or between ME2 and ME3? I thought he was already sleeping with the enemy in ME2.


If you choose paragon in ME2, it becomes blue!

(He picks giant stars because they help him hide)

It also keeps him wicked tan.


Both the synthesis option and the controlling reapers option means that the reapers won. You've been indoctrinated.
Hackett even warns you to keep mindful of the enemy and remember to destroy them as they hope to destroy you. Synthesis is weaksauce.
 
I think you see James and Garrus there at least one time. Or was it James and Kaidan? I forgot.

Someone told me in one of earlier cycles of this thread that was James and Kaidan. Since the latter never survived a single playthrough of ME1 for me, I didn't see it. Still way underused in any case.
 
If you choose paragon in ME2, it becomes blue!

(He picks giant stars because they help him hide)

I don't know, it looks the same to me. Maybe it's my ignorance of astronomy.

they dont change colour, the blue and red stars are separate bases.
So based on being Renegade or Paragon, he'd decide to change bases? That's odd.
 
Why? I consider Synthesis to be the "right" ending.

However, everyone wants Shepard to live, so I'm seeing most people side with the Renegade/Destroy option.

In the end, the problem with the ending isn't the content or the three choices; it's the brevity of the 3 minute cutscene after the choice is made. It felt super rushed for me.

People don't advocate the Destroy ending because they want Shepard to live. They advocate it because fuck the Reapers, fuck the God Child, let all of those genocidal abominations burn. Millions of years of horrors inflicted on the Galaxy. Anything less than their complete and utter destruction is an injustice.
 
People don't advocate the Destroy ending because they want Shepard to live. They advocate it because fuck the Reapers, fuck the God Child, let all of those genocidal abominations burn. Millions of years of horrors inflicted on the Galaxy. Anything less than their complete and utter destruction is an injustice.

I did not want to destroy my new Geth friends :(
 
Why? I consider Synthesis to be the "right" ending.

However, everyone wants Shepard to live, so I'm seeing most people side with the Renegade/Destroy option.

In the end, the problem with the ending isn't the content or the three choices; it's the brevity of the 3 minute cutscene after the choice is made. It felt super rushed for me.
Synthesis is not right. Its probably the stupidest of the three choices. What gives you the right to play God? Why should you believe anything Catalyst says? How the fuck does everything, even plants, turn into cyborgs?
 
Synthesis is not right. Its probably the stupidest of the three choices. What gives you the right to play God? Why should you believe anything Catalyst says? How the fuck does everything, even plants, turn into cyborgs?

Imagine one day, you wake up and your skin is glowing green, your computer suddenly has intestines and your house is screaming in pain
 
Someone told me in one of earlier cycles of this thread that was James and Kaidan. Since the latter never survived a single playthrough of ME1 for me, I didn't see it. Still way underused in any case.

yup, it was kaidan and james. Kaidan lost everything..lol

which is funny cuz james kept losing to random ppl in the beginning but his luck change as time went on
 
People do realize that if they do make a new ending, it'll probably suck, right?

I doubt they'll give it a proper budget and they probably won't have access to most of the VA that they'd need for a proper ending (because of money and scheduling).

On top of that it'll be written by writers who probably are resenting their fans right now, and will probably have to go through Mac Walters and Casey Hudson because they're in charge.
 
Why do people dislike the indoctrination theory. It makes sense.

It gives Bioware way more credit then they are due. Also they are the delusions of a rabid fan base.

Seriously you guys arguing about the color of the star are putting way too much thought into it. Bioware thought it would be neat so they did it. The reason both Miranda and Liara don't know where the base as is because they probably never flew their themselves so they never had the coordinates to give.
 
People do realize that if they do make a new ending, it'll probably suck, right?

I doubt they'll give it a proper budget and they probably won't have access to most of the VA that they'd need for a proper ending (because of money and scheduling).

On top of that it'll be written by writers who probably are resenting their fans right now, and will probably have to go through Mac Walters and Casey Hudson because they're in charge.

Guess we are at the point where most would accept a Dragon Age style Powerpoint Presentation.
 
Seeing as two of the defining plot threads throughout the series, the genophage and the geth/quarian war, are about allowing species the freedom to choose their destiny for themselves, the singularity path makes even less sense.

I can see how the writers thought it would sound like a beautifully elegant and post-modern sci-fi ending, but personally I found it abhorrent. A machine giving Shephard the right to irrevocably change all species forever without their consent. Isn't that what we were fighting against?
 
Synthesis is not right. Its probably the stupidest of the three choices. What gives you the right to play God? Why should you believe anything Catalyst says? How the fuck does everything, even plants, turn into cyborgs?

And committing genocide by destroying all synthetics, including the Geth and EDI, is any better? You're no better than the Reapers there -- and you're playing God, just the same.
 
I just heard someone clearly lay it out what the theory is.

But it gives the kid a purpose, explains why the destroy option is red

Does shepard only live in the destroy ending, just a quick question?

It also means that Shepard accomplishes nothing. The main plot goes unresolved. This theory just provides an out for Bioware to create the true ending.
 
It gives Bioware way more credit then they are due. Also they are the delusions of a rabid fan base.

Seriously you guys arguing about the color of the star are putting way too much thought into it. Bioware thought it would be neat so they did it. The reason both Miranda and Liara don't know where the base as is because they probably never flew their themselves so they never had the coordinates to give.

After 5 years, they provide us a jumbled mess of an ending...there has to be something we are missing...right?

Kaidan plays there at least once.

Renagade shepard should have been able to walk in and see half his crew playing a game and no one invited him
 
Huh, interesting. I didn't know the dialogue you say or get as Sheploo is a bit different from if you play as custom Shep. Sounds more detailed and complete.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom