Gimme a legit fave five shity gimmick matches.
Gimmick matches that are horrible ideas, but that have, somehow, managed to produce entertaining bouts.
1. Coal Miner's Glove match. It's just the stupidist idea, that somehow a coal miner's glove will help in a fight in any way, and yet maanged to give some great matches over in Pacific Northwest Wrestling with Dutch Savage and Mid-South with several guys.
Dibiase vs. Jim Duggan has the best of it all being a Tuxedo Match with a Coal Miner's Glove on a pole, and the loser leaves town. It's on the Best of Mid-South DVD.
2. Musical Chairs. Okay as far as I know there has only been one and it was on Raw created by Eugene, but I loved it thanks to the cast of characters. I bet it could still work today in DDT (the last chair would somehow win the match), or WWE to further insult Miz and Dolph and Ryder to cement them as the new Job Squad if that angle ever takes off.
3. Swamping Gimmick matches. Rarely happens but two competitors are forced to dress like the other, use the move set/war chest of the other, and will be disqualified if they act like themselves too many times in a match. Hawai'i Wrestling in the 70s did it a couple of times, Osaka Pro might have done it but I can't recall, and I'm not sure who else might have. It's hilarious when done right and I could see either Chikara or Championship Wrestling From Hollywood doing well with it.
4. Buried Alive. You win by throwing someone into a hole and then throw dirt on them. Just ridiculous, and yet we have a few classics across the world on this match type.
5. WEE-LC. Not because they used Minis to wrestle, I honestly believe Mascarita Dorada to be one of the best wrestlers to come out of Mexico and love the AAA and CMLL Mini-Estrella divisions, but this was a WWE match involving mminis so how the hell could it possibly be good?
Yet somehow, despite Vince style humour of mini-parodies everywhere, it was a straight up match where 3MB played no more the bigger fools than they usually did and it was the best "extreme" match of the night.
Honorary Mention. Silent Match, where the first wrestler that makes a loud noises will lose the match. So no talking, no screaming, no saying "I Quit", no tapping, etc.