• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Metro: Redux |OT| Once more into the Metro, with feeling!

D

Dictator93

Member
BTW, PC users, maldo etc... I figured out the GPU PhysX was indeed not working in the game. THe advanced PhysX option would delegate those PhsX to the CPU (the extra debris, etc...). It is pretty easy to test this right now just by unloading a magazine at the wall with GPU physX enabled and multi-card. One card, if GPU physX is on, should show higher utilization the more you shoot the wall. Currently the original and LL do this, but redux does not.

Changing the physX packages in the game to a more recent group (from the game daylight), I was able to enable the GPU physX and have the indicator show in game.

Problem with this? On my rig, in Tri-SLI this causes pretty big stutter as soon as the physX objects come on the field. Changing the PhysX usage in NVCP to CPU... fixes this completely. The FX also look the EXACT SAME.
Strange... huh?
 
T

Traumnovelle

Member
I'm loving Metro 2033 so far, but am really bummed that with the Russian V.O. option, the english subtitles are only provided for main characters and not average npc chatter. It would probably difficult, but I'd really like 4A to patch that in for all dialogue.
 
S

SymbiantXenos

Member
Anyone else's metro disk (ps4) sound like it's being eaten by the ps4 on start up sometimes?. Every other disk that goes into the ps4 is fine. Just metro has this issue for some reason.

Also no marks or scratches on the metro disk at all.
 
F

Faith

Member
TheTrain said:
Dat gun model

ihnCQSH31Ek2w.png


Dunno if this is considered a spoiler or not, so click to view!
Click to expand...
Is that from 2033?

I just left the metro in 2033. I hope it gets better. It wasn't boring but I liked Last Light more from the beginning.
 
H

HiiiLife

Member
A few hours in and I just got past the part where you
use the flamethrower for the first time outside D6. For me the game started picking up right where the whole Reds vs Nazi thing began.
Def enjoying my time now as compared to the beginning of the game.
 
R

RoboPlato

I'd be in the dick
Wow, the Last Light Dead City chapter was fantastic. I've heard some people say that LL was lacking in atmosphere compared to 2033 but that chapter was exceptional from an atmospheric standpoint.
 
H

HiiiLife

Member
Also, my main complaint is the gunplay in 2033. I dunno why but it doesn't feel very responsive and satisfying. Maybe its just the PS4.
 
R

RoboPlato

I'd be in the dick
HiiiLife said:
Also, my main complaint is the gunplay. I dunno why but it doesn't feel very responsive and satisfying. Maybe its just the PS4.
Click to expand...

It feels a lot better in Last Light. Enemies in 2033 don't react to shots as well and seem to have a more health. Redux carried over some of the combat improvements but LL still plays better.
 
D

dark10x

Digital Foundry pixel pusher
HiiiLife said:
Also, my main complaint is the gunplay in 2033. I dunno why but it doesn't feel very responsive and satisfying. Maybe its just the PS4.
Click to expand...
Oh no. If anything it feels better. The original 2033 felt absolutely awful to me. Never finished the game in its original form due to this.
 
H

HiiiLife

Member
RoboPlato said:
It feels a lot better in Last Light. Enemies in 2033 don't react to shots as well and seem to have a more health.
Click to expand...

I'm really eager to try it out. 2033 really picked up a few chapters in. The Library.. *shudders*

BTW thus game really does an awkward job teaching the player what's what. The wristwatch is used to detect if radiation is nearby?
 
R

RoboPlato

I'd be in the dick
HiiiLife said:
I'm really eager to try it out. 2033 really picked up a few chapters in. The Library.. *shudders*

BTW thus game really does an awkward job teaching the player what's what. The wristwatch is used to detect if radiation is nearby?
Click to expand...

That was my same reaction to 2033. First few chapters were kind of dull but it really picked up about a third of the way through. Last Light has been awesome the whole way through, except for one chapter in a swamp.
 
H

HiiiLife

Member
dark10x said:
Oh no. If anything it feels better. The original 2033 felt absolutely awful to me. Never finished the game in its original form due to this.
Click to expand...

I played it on the 360. Let's just say I don't think I finished the first chapter. Haha. Glad I came back around for the remaster.

RoboPlato said:
That was my same reaction to 2033. First few chapters were kind of dull but it really picked up about a third of the way through. Last Light has been awesome the whole way through, except for one chapter in a swamp.
Click to expand...

Can't wait to find out what weapons the developers came up with. When I found out they put a shotgun in made out of bicycle parts I fell in love.
 
Nizz

Nizz

Member
HiiiLife said:
Also, my main complaint is the gunplay in 2033. I dunno why but it doesn't feel very responsive and satisfying. Maybe its just the PS4.
Click to expand...
Do you think part of the lack of responsiveness is due to the controls/sensitivity? I think I'm close to the library section people have mentioned and while the game (2033) has gotten better and I'm into it the controls still feel sluggish.

I don't know if it still feels that way in LL or is it just in 2033. I won't know until I finish 2033 first.
 
H

HiiiLife

Member
Nizz said:
Do you think part of the lack of responsiveness is due to the controls/sensitivity? I think I'm close to the library section people have mentioned and while the game (2033) has gotten better and I'm into it the controls still feel sluggish.

I don't know if it still feels that way in LL or is it just in 2033. I won't know until I finish 2033 first.
Click to expand...

I don't think so. My sensitivity is all the way up and it still feels sluggish.
 
M

misho8723

Banned
RoboPlato said:
Wow, the Last Light Dead City chapter was fantastic. I've heard some people say that LL was lacking in atmosphere compared to 2033 but that chapter was exceptional from an atmospheric standpoint.
Click to expand...

Well in LL there are some scary, tension or atmospheric missions just like in 2033 - levels like Torchlight, Echoes, Regina, Sundown, Undercity, Khan or by you mentioned Dead City.. or the DLC missions like Spider Lair, Khan - great stuff - and in my opinion the best mission with the best atmosphere = Kshatriya
 
C

Carbonox

Member
It takes until achievement hunting to really get a grasp on how the stealth mechanics work. To be fair my first run through Metro 2033 involved pure shootbang (did Spartan mode). Looking forward to Survival mode where I can actually put the stealth tactics to consistent use. The Front Line mission in particular is so much more satisfying when you go through the entire thing without being seen.
 
Nizz

Nizz

Member
HiiiLife said:
I don't think so. My sensitivity is all the way up and it still feels sluggish.
Click to expand...
Same here, I have sensitivity maxed in 2033 (both the overall sensitivity and the ADS sensitivity) and it still feels slow. I'm worried it'll be the same deal with Last Light.

If they could somehow patch in a new range of sensitivity more in line with something like say, Battlefield 4, I would be super happy. This is on PS4 just in case anyone's wondering.
 
M

MaLDo

Member
Dictator93 said:
BTW, PC users, maldo etc... I figured out the GPU PhysX was indeed not working in the game. THe advanced PhysX option would delegate those PhsX to the CPU (the extra debris, etc...). It is pretty easy to test this right now just by unloading a magazine at the wall with GPU physX enabled and multi-card. One card, if GPU physX is on, should show higher utilization the more you shoot the wall. Currently the original and LL do this, but redux does not.

Changing the physX packages in the game to a more recent group (from the game daylight), I was able to enable the GPU physX and have the indicator show in game.

Problem with this? On my rig, in Tri-SLI this causes pretty big stutter as soon as the physX objects come on the field. Changing the PhysX usage in NVCP to CPU... fixes this completely. The FX also look the EXACT SAME.
Strange... huh?
Click to expand...

Yeah, I can't talk details but the patch is ready since last friday. Anyway, I think the performance discrepancies will continue after the patch with the new library (which is basically the same as using the library from another game).
 
T

the_batman

Banned
Nizz said:
Same here, I have sensitivity maxed in 2033 (both the overall sensitivity and the ADS sensitivity) and it still feels slow. I'm worried it'll be the same deal with Last Light.

If they could somehow patch in a new range of sensitivity more in line with something like say, Battlefield 4, I would be super happy. This is on PS4 just in case anyone's wondering.
Click to expand...

even though the sensitivity is a bit low it's fine to me because of the rock solid 60fps. not every game has to be the same.
 
M

MaLDo

Member
Lord Error said:
It's almost impossible not to make mistakes/omissions when doing these things. I actually remember you making mistakes as well, in some of the proclamations you made. These things almost need a body of peer reviewers where people correct each other as each knows or notices a different thing. But it'd probably take way too much time to do that for a timely article.
Click to expand...

What do you mean? I am a player who puts opinions in a forum. If I was wrong about something a year ago (do you have a link?), is it justified today that a technical article is short on content? No one paid me to write articles so I can't deal your argument.

Everyone can be wrong about something sometimes. But if you do a technical analysis of three versions of a game, it is logical to dig a bit more in the details. A close-up of the hands / weapons / enemies to talk about tessellation. How the added in every asset tessellation broke a few things. For example, in the Dictator93 shots

metro_2014_09_01_16_3d4s0m.png


metro_2014_09_01_16_382sgb.png
Click to expand...

If you look at the floor, there are a few assets that have disappeared under the new inflated geometry.

metro_2014_09_01_16_2b4s5j.png


metro_2014_09_01_16_2bbsaf.png
Click to expand...

Another example from Dictator93. Rounding the weapon side, that metal part has disappeared but the base texture shows the dark zone the artist put to obscure the contour of the missing piece. The are more examples as the band of cloth a npc is bearing in the head or the jacket fabric on the artyom arm that pass through the watch bracelet.

What about shadows? What are the real differences between the versions? Screenshots about every difference? The lod object? Why not search for a similar config across platforms to compare the performance in a more apples to apples vs. Everything can be analyzed in depth. And even if you put a limit somewhere, the actual article is far away from that because sums it up in one line.

And then there's more apart from the graphic bits. How 4A could prepare a 1.4 GB patch in one day that open the more visible differences between platforms? Was it really a day 1 patch? I think is not. Why someone with actual and public access to developers can't dig a bit more?
 
D

Dictator93

Member
RoboPlato said:
That was my same reaction to 2033. First few chapters were kind of dull but it really picked up about a third of the way through. Last Light has been awesome the whole way through, except for one chapter in a swamp.
Click to expand...

I enjoy the swamp area because it is the most "free roam" in LL i think.

MaLDo said:
Yeah, I can't talk details but the patch is ready since last friday. Anyway, I think the performance discrepancies will continue after the patch with the new library (which is basically the same as using the library from another game).
Click to expand...

Good news and bad news at the same time. I am not sure what to think!
Aren't they testing the viability of mGPU configs anywhere? Like Nvidia?
 
D

Dictator93

Member
MaLDo said:
And then there's more apart from the graphic bits. How 4A could prepare a 1.4 GB patch in one day that open the more visible differences between platforms? Was it really a day 1 patch? I think is not. Why someone with actual and public access to developers can't dig a bit more?
Click to expand...

Being part of the "press" they have distinct advantages when getting time with the devs. They should use this time well and write well concerning the topics at hand. All the things you point out above are obvious things (shadows, how is tesselation done, what is its performance, what does PGU physX look like, comparison shots between lods and obvious breaking points), I would expect them in any Tweak Guides article from 2003. Yet they are missing here.

Imagine an interview with the devs that questioned the nature of that Day 1 patch, or that questioned the way tesselation is implemented sometimes in game, or asked more specifically about their AI routines.

While it is nice to hear the usual questions about ESRAM, PS4 GPGPU, whatever... these things are obvious now and just feed boring console wars. These interviews should be awesome times to hear about cool engine designs...

EDIT: LOL double post
 
M

mickcenary

Member
I just started getting stuck into Last Light again since last gen and boy, for all the praise certain FP animations get - they're superb, don't get me wrong - there's some seriously vomit-in-the-mouth stuff going on as well.

The biggest offender by far is how the hands/gun return to their neutral position when you halt your movement without any easing transition animation. They just snap back as if a whole bunch of frames have been skipped. It looks abysmal. Additionally, some of the ADS animations are just super janky. The way the revolver snaps to is very messy.

I dunno. I really don't remember it being this obvious, but this is stuff that really sticks in my craw. It's not just a one-off sketchy NPC animation; this is with you every second. I can't recall an FPS in the last 5 years that simultaneously excelled and failed at FP animation so blatantly.
 
D

Dictator93

Member
mickcenary said:
I just started getting stuck into Last Light again since last gen and boy, for all the praise certain FP animations get - they're superb, don't get me wrong - there's some seriously vomit-in-the-mouth stuff going on as well.

The biggest offender by far is how the hands/gun return to their neutral position when you halt your movement without any easing transition animation. They just snap back as if a whole bunch of frames have been skipped. It looks abysmal. Additionally, some of the ADS animations are just super janky. The way the revolver snaps to is very messy.

I dunno. I really don't remember it being this obvious, but this is stuff that really sticks in my craw. It's not just a one-off sketchy NPC animation; this is with you every second. I can't recall an FPS in the last 5 years that simultaneously excelled and failed at FP animation so blatantly.
Click to expand...

I think that jank you are seeing there is due to the spartan mode survior mode differences. In survivor the animations are much more purposeful and slow... can you show what you mean by the FP weapon stopping from moving?
 
M

mickcenary

Member
Dictator93 said:
I think that jank you are seeing there is due to the spartan mode survior mode differences. In survivor the animations are much more purposeful and slow... can you show what you mean by the FP weapon stopping from moving?
Click to expand...

Oh, wow. That's a thing? I guess I'm starting over on Spartan. Kind of poor that they've implemented that in such a way, but I guess I take back some of the vitriol.

Not really sure how I'd show you, mang; and I'd have to have another look to verify, but basically, the position of the weapon/hands when you're stationary... Once you start moving and the hands/weapon bob accordingly, it returns to the static stationary position without a natural cessation in the bobbing once you stop moving again. It just snaps back in a single, jarring frame.
 
M

misho8723

Banned
Fuck.. the mission Trolley Combat is way more difficult than in the original 2033.. last week when I played the original, i didn't die once on Ranger difficulty, but now in Redux, I did already like 30x times
 
O

Omni

Member
Just bought this game on Xbone. The first game is at 60% downloaded so I'm gonna start playing

Is it better to choose Survival or Spartan? I've never played these before
 
B

backflip10019

Member
randomrosso said:
Just bought this game on Xbone. The first game is at 60% downloaded so I'm gonna start playing

Is it better to choose Survival or Spartan? I've never played these before
Click to expand...

Spartan is more run-and-gun style with more ammo and Survival focuses on ammo scarcity and resource management. I know my personal style of play is more run-and-gun focused, so I played my first time through on Spartan.
 
J

Joeki11a

Banned
I impulse bought this and kinda regret it...

Starter with 2033 and I am at chapter 6 maybe and it has been a boring linear affair.
I wish It was more outside those parts were interesting, story isnt all that either just the atmosphere is cool.

Previewed Last Light for 3 hours and looks to be more of the same, I will probably sell this next week for Destiny.
 
R

RoboPlato

I'd be in the dick
Man, I just hit a bad glitch on PS4. Every time I try to load my save at a checkpoint (Last Light spoiler)
when the flamethrower Red is approaching the rangers at D6
the game crashes as soon as it hits 100% :(
 
S

Summer Haze

Banned
I chose survival on 2033 and I have tons of ammo and resources. I'm playing on hard...or whatever the difficulty mode above normal is called. I thought I would have a lot less ammo than what I have.
 
W

WeAreStarStuff

Member
Beat 2033 yesterday evening on my PS4. Went into this redux pretty much blind, and I must say I was pleasantly surprised. I really enjoyed the game besides the last few minutes. Looking forward to trying out Last Light when I have the time.
 
B

backflip10019

Member
Lukas Japonicus said:
I chose survival on 2033 and I have tons of ammo and resources. I'm playing on hard...or whatever the difficulty mode above normal is called. I thought I would have a lot less ammo than what I have.
Click to expand...

Have you made it up to the
librarians
(monster spoiler) yet? They ate up quite a lot of my ammo, even in Spartan mode.
 
F

FlyinJ

Douchebag. Yes, me.
Do the NPCs refer to you as "Spartan" or "Survivor" depending on what difficulty you are playing on?

I could have sworn I chose "Survivor", but this NPC I'm with keeps calling me "Spartan"...
 
D

DrM

Redmond's Baby
backflip10019 said:
Umm... what is this? I must've made the game much harder than it needed to be...
Click to expand...

Stare directly into their eyes (not too close or not too far) and they will go their own business. But do not turn too fast on them.

Also, I found them much much creepier in the novel :p
 
JohnnyFootball

JohnnyFootball

GerAlt-Right. Ciriously.
randomrosso said:
Just bought this game on Xbone. The first game is at 60% downloaded so I'm gonna start playing

Is it better to choose Survival or Spartan? I've never played these before
Click to expand...

There is really very little difference between the two at least on normal.

The only noticeable difference was the slower reload times. I sure couldn't tell that ammo was more scarce though.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

PS VR2: Frenzies revealed, new Metro Awakening gameplay details, Wanderer: The Fragments of Fate in-depth look
News Platform
4
571
willothedog replied
'Metro: Last Light' Is Now Free on Steam, But Only for a Week (until 25 May)
3
735
killatopak replied
Digital Foundry: Best Graphics on Nintendo Switch: The 'Impossible Ports' Third Party Collection!
22
1K
kevboard replied
Metro Series Creator Dmitry Glukhovsky is handed an 8-year prison term for discrediting Russia’s army
Social Drama 2
54
5K
ZVWQP-9B8TM-VH9CT replied
Cyberpunk 2077 Patch 2.1 will add 19 Metro Station, among other cut features
News 2 3
137
11K
moon knight replied
Top Bottom