Why skip a gen and compare with 360 instead of X1?From a post in that other thread: if those potential Greenberg quoted numbers are correct, they've sold about 8 million units in the last 14 months assuming they've gone from 14.87M to 21.87M?
![]()
VGChartz was not accurate. What you're seeing is updated data that they corrected after other (more reliable) sources shared significantly different data.
They were advertising more than 20 million at the start of December 2022.
If Xbox is now at 21 million, does this mean that Microsoft has sold only 1 million units in the last 7 months? That's obviously incorrect.
Question is how many of those people stuck around?58M+ for the Xbox One is actually a good number considering all the stuff that happened last gen with Xbox. IMO both the One S and especially the X were solid consoles (got the latter and still have it for some backwards compatible games).
In what world started the Xbox One well? It was a desaster from the beginning, because it was much to expensive and Kinect and the promo sucked. PS4 had a 10 million lead pretty fast.The Xbox one sales started of well, and a lot of that is probably good faith from the 360 generation.
If you look at the NPD sales data early on it wasn't doing that bad actually, maybe not as good as ps4 but it wasn't that bad. It's as the generation progressed is really when it really struggled.In what world started the Xbox One well? It was a desaster from the beginning, because it was much to expensive and Kinect and the promo sucked. PS4 had a 10 million lead pretty fast.
You can't be doing well if the competitor humiliates you from the beginning. They even added Fifa and later removed Kinect, didn't help. The whole last gen was a desaster for Xbox from start to finish.If you look at the NPD sales data early on it wasn't doing that bad actually, maybe not as good as ps4 but it wasn't that bad. It's as the generation progressed is really when it really struggled.
VGChartz is mostly guesses, and they are even terrible at that.Guess they work with estimates and extrapolation and have to update and correct it frequently. My VGCartz numbers were from early May.
He is right actually. Xbox One started really well. For reference, launch aligned Xbox One performed well than how Series X|S are performing right now. XOne had sold more consoles.In what world started the Xbox One well? It was a desaster from the beginning, because it was much to expensive and Kinect and the promo sucked. PS4 had a 10 million lead pretty fast.
Easy to to achieve when the PS4 was sold out for many months. Both fucked up with with launch games and i think Sonys first really big AAA came mid 2016 and by that time it was already over and out with like 45 millions to 20 millions and didn't get much worse afterwards. It was constanly bad. The 399 vs 499 + the bad promos with the tvtvtv shit + how to trade games broke Xbox's neck.He is right actually. Xbox One started really well. For reference, launch aligned Xbox One performed well than how Series X|S are performing right now. XOne had sold more consoles.
Even 2 years later, One was performing very well.
![]()
The launch, as bad as it looks in hindsight, was not a big issue. The sales dropped later when the games dried up.
In Brazil, Xbox One was sold way cheaper in comparison with PS4, but didn't take too long to both be basically the same price, and then no games in the stores58 million for Xbox one is pretty good for that piece of shit.
I think it's to do with how the sales over time ended up on 360 vs xb1 generation. 360 had a slow start with yields/shortages and rrod. It didn't really ramp up until 3rd year and then Kinect gave it a boost for several years. Not a lot less than Xbo but prob the only way to say they were "doing better than before".Why skip a gen and compare with 360 instead of X1?
Wouldn't it make more sense to compare a gen with the previous one?
I guess when you dream, you should dream big. Id like to see your yearly breakdown for how the Series, which has already started to decline this early in the gen, and has fallen behind a system that sold 58M, reaches 65M.I think series will reach 65 to 70 Mill when all Is said and done.
I always said 70 million would be good for them this time.
Maybe if they were sold at full price. However, if you remember, MS constantly had fire sales for the One. In fact, consumers got so used to it that sales would plummet on months there were no discounts, as they waited for that inevitable $50-$100 off the retail price.58M+ for the Xbox One is actually a good number considering all the stuff that happened last gen with Xbox. IMO both the One S and especially the X were solid consoles (got the latter and still have it for some backwards compatible games).
Because 360 sales started slower than the xbox one but took off later, so to make it look like it is a big improvement he pulled the 360 numbers. Tracking behind or close to the Xbox One would have been a bad look.Why skip a gen and compare with 360 instead of X1?
Wouldn't it make more sense to compare a gen with the previous one?
Do they think costumers or shareholders are that dumb that they won't question it then?Because 360 sales started slower than the xbox one but took off later, so to make it look like it is a big improvement he pulled the 360 numbers. Tracking behind or close to the Xbox One would have been a bad look.
They do, they often play with their data to put whatever spin on it they like.Do they think costumers or shareholders are that dumb that they won't question it then?
Maybe if they were sold at full price. However, if you remember, MS constantly had fire sales for the One. In fact, consumers got so used to it that sales would plummet on months there were no discounts, as they waited for that inevitable $50-$100 off the retail price.
I distinctly remember Microsoft making PR statements every few months in 2014 on how Xbox One was outperforming Xbox 360 launch aligned.He is right actually. Xbox One started really well. For reference, launch aligned Xbox One performed well than how Series X|S are performing right now. XOne had sold more consoles.
Even 2 years later, One was performing very well.
![]()
The launch, as bad as it looks in hindsight, was not a big issue. The sales dropped later when the games dried up.
Unless specified as sell-through, most of the time companies give sales numbers they are speaking shipped.Is that "sales" or the infamous ms "shipped" figure?
Yeah, the 50 million figure, for the console in itself, seems very high in hindsight.
As you can see Kinect was the best thing to happen to Xbox sales wise. Series S with a cheap Kinect bundle would easily take over the holidaysI think it's to do with how the sales over time ended up on 360 vs xb1 generation. 360 had a slow start with yields/shortages and rrod. It didn't really ramp up until 3rd year and then Kinect gave it a boost for several years. Not a lot less than Xbo but prob the only way to say they were "doing better than before".
From this post: https://www.neogaf.com/threads/xbox...4-2022-ps5-7-1-million.1658328/post-268134013
![]()
58 million down from 84 million (Xbox 360) …… and only 21 million nearly half a gen in? They may not even cross 50 million this gen….
That thread seemed to show Xbox series at ~18.5 million at end of 2022. To be at 21+ million in June 2023 seems pretty slow to be honest.
Xbox one situation went through a almost generation long drought of good games and negativity. The Xbox one sales started of well, and a lot of that is probably good faith from the 360 generation.
Series S with a cheap Kinect bundle would easily take over the holidays
False Just Dance still sell boatloads every holiday & Series S is in the price range to be perfect for the just dance crowdNext year is half a gen in.
I don't think they were at 18.5 sold through which these numbers are apparently. I know the source though they were but it's likely the truth is that 18.5 was probably shipped.
Actually Xbox One was praised for games early on. if anything this makes my skepticism of Phil lying about him saving the Xbox One when it was doing it's best performance-wise. Then a few years later he has a private email exchange contemplating shutting down Xbox and making it a mobile gaming company during a turn around?
Kinect is dead, it has no mindshare now for this to work. They would have to make a new version of Kinect and market it under a different brand with new features. But what new features can you add to controllerless waggle that will have everyone run to Walmart and push old lady's over racing toward the shelves?
Quoting VGChartz was the highlight of Greenberg's twittard career.From a post in that other thread: if those potential Greenberg quoted numbers are correct, they've sold about 8 million units in the last 14 months assuming they've gone from 14.87M to 21.87M?
![]()
21m+ for the Xbox Series is similar to what the Xbone was doing launch aligned, with a better strategy from the former than the latter.
Not too good in my eyes, but legs will be key.
Halo MCC sand BC. While the former was disappointing for a while, it's now my most played MP game.Really surprised that Xbox One sold more than 58 million consoles with such a lackluster, barren, and dire first-party situation.
that's an awful number, going on 3rd year and a mere 21 million.That's a pretty good number.
Also XBO sold much higher than I would have expected as well.
360 Kinect was lightning in a bottle. Misleading MS marketing also helped. Once people realized it's actual capabilities, that was that. A Kinect v3 would be pretty likely to flop imo.As you can see Kinect was the best thing to happen to Xbox sales wise. Series S with a cheap Kinect bundle would easily take over the holidays
360 Kinect was lightning in a bottle. Misleading MS marketing also helped. Once people realized it's actual capabilities, that was that. A Kinect v3 would be pretty likely to flop imo.
My guess is 75% S, 25% X. The S has always been available and never been scalped (in the UK).21/22 does not sound unrealistic.
More interested in S and X splits than total sales. Such an unprecedented move for launching a console. Results could be interesting.
Pretty good numbers for the console side, knowing that MS fully supports PC at the same time.
No; Xbox Series has been tracking worst than XBO this year, closer to OG Xbox levels. OG Xbox did 6.2 million in its third year, FWIW.
I've seen some people (mainly Welfare) say these numbers are from March but...the presentation was fairly recent, correct? I would expect MS used the most recent numbers, so at least from the start of June and maybe post-Diablo IV since that game had a nice bump for Xbox in certain markets (at least momentarily) thanks to the bundle.
Which IMO is a more realistic time frame for where these numbers are coming from. Would make 18 million, even 18.5 million sold-through for EOY '22 realistic. Maybe even closer to 19 million EOY '22 if OG Xbox's 6.2 million for its Year 3 was more loaded in the back-half.
The only surprise here IMO would be XBO numbers. The 58 million estimate was out there before, but I guess this officially confirms it.
I did not realize this....No; Xbox Series has been tracking worst than XBO this year, closer to OG Xbox levels. OG Xbox did 6.2 million in its third year, FWIW.
I've seen some people (mainly Welfare) say these numbers are from March but...the presentation was fairly recent, correct? I would expect MS used the most recent numbers, so at least from the start of June and maybe post-Diablo IV since that game had a nice bump for Xbox in certain markets (at least momentarily) thanks to the bundle.
Which IMO is a more realistic time frame for where these numbers are coming from. Would make 18 million, even 18.5 million sold-through for EOY '22 realistic. Maybe even closer to 19 million EOY '22 if OG Xbox's 6.2 million for its Year 3 was more loaded in the back-half.
The only surprise here IMO would be XBO numbers. The 58 million estimate was out there before, but I guess this officially confirms it.
Same.For some reason I thought og xbox was like 20 odd million lifetime.:/
That's what the article said but yeah if it wasn't intended then someone is getting fired. Microsoft don't like giving out hardware numbers when they are far behind the competition but maybe with this court case going on then they want to depict themselves as underdogs.How is putting numbers on a slide at a festival "accidental"?
The Xbox One number is going to be adjusted up to 58 million and it is almost one million per year short but at least the Series S/X are spot on. However we shouldn't even have to estimate though because Sony have shown quarterly sales since 2007 and Nintendo have shown quarterly sales since 2001. Still i am really surprised that Xbox One hit 58 million, historically that is pretty good and only 4 million short of the NES.I think it's to do with how the sales over time ended up on 360 vs xb1 generation. 360 had a slow start with yields/shortages and rrod. It didn't really ramp up until 3rd year and then Kinect gave it a boost for several years. Not a lot less than Xbo but prob the only way to say they were "doing better than before".
From this post: https://www.neogaf.com/threads/xbox...4-2022-ps5-7-1-million.1658328/post-268134013
![]()