We need power and Gardner is one of the few Yankees that has trade value. He's also a bit redundant with Ellsbury on the roster.
Gardner would be the Braves best position player outside of Freeman. His base running value was the highest this past season since 2011, and he put up back to back 3.2 fwar seasons. That's a decline? What the hell are you talking about?
Stick to your disgusting two-teaming ways.
back to back 3.2 WAR seasons....care to take a look at his WAR from 2010/2011? That, my friend, is a decline. Also convenient that you just zeroed in on his base running value and ignored everything else. Typical Yankee! If Brett Gardner is so god-damnned awesome, why the fuck do Yankees fans all want to see the guy get traded?
Yes, DECLINE. DECLINE DECLINE DECLINE. He'll be 32 years old in 2015, and his main asset is speed. Guess what tool is guaranteed to decline as baseball players get older? Add to that he's owed 52 million dollars over the next 4 years. No thank you. This ain't fantasy baseball.
If you lot want J-Up then just sign him to a 25m aav contract next season when he's a free agent. Brett Gardner is useless to the Braves, given the organization's goals.