no disagreement on Niese and no i'm not going to argue it's a balanced trade in the abstract. i like Walker and I'm glad he's doing well.
Walker had 16 HRs all of last year with a career high of 23 in 14. it's nice that he's hit 9 home runs in a month but it's silly to think that anyone expected that to happen & that it should have factored into trade decisions.
every Pirate fan knew 2015 was Walker's last season in Pittsburgh back last spring.
i like the infield we have now. but any pirate fan who thinks we should've just kept him and that doing so would have resulted in more wins at this point in 2016 is just not paying attention. Buc's don't need more offense. was a better pitcher available for trade based on Walker's stats from 2015 & overall cost? i dunno, but it doesn't seem like it.
I'm not mad that we traded Neil Walker, I'm mad that we got hosed in a trade. We currently have David Freese at 3B. Why not go into the season with Josh Harrison at 3B and Neil Walker at 2B? Mercer has been anything but consistent over his career, so there very well could have been room for Neil once Kang came back from his injury. Worst case scenario you have a 2B who has averaged 3.1 WAR over the last four seasons to trade to a desperate team before the deadline. Anything is better than giving him away in a straight up trade for Niese. Pitching is definitely our biggest issue, and that was obvious going into the off-season. Since we refuse to spend money, and let everyone walk for peanuts in the off season - you'd think they'd do a little more than give away a legitimately good 2B for someone who should be a back of the rotation guy or depth.