Glad i put utley on my do not draft list. It sounds like he's done.
I think he is likely done. It sounds as if this is just a degenerative condition, and there's no real surgery option. I think he could come back in May sometime, maybe with Ryan Howard. I don't ever seeing him being an elite level second baseman again, one of key reasons the Phillies were an elite team for the past few years. We can probably navigate the NL with a replacement level 2B like Galvis (who might actually have a better defensive range than Chase), but there is one less bat for a clutch hit come playoff time.