Anyone who knows me knows I'm a big Spider-Man fan. Apart from stuff like thomas the tank engine, spider-man is the first fictional character I remember consciously liking. I've read the comics, watched the tv shows, played the games, seen the previous films, I know my Spider-Man, and nothing makes me more annoyed than a bad portryal of one of my favourite fictional characters, like Spider-Man 3 and the soulless amazing spider-man films.
So I was somewhere between nervous and excited when seeing Spider-Man Homecoming. I was pretty sure Marvel wouldn't mess it up to the extent of amazing spider-man 2 of course, but how would it fare next to the excellent two Sam Raimi Spider-Man films? How would Tom Holland's Spider-Man do in a whole film, as opposed to his excellent scene stealing cameo in civil war?
I'm ecstatic then (and not really surprised) that Spider-Man Homecoming isn't just a fantastic film, the best MCU film to date, one of the best films I've seen all year, it is the spider-man film far as I'm concerned. It doesn't invaldiate the Raimi films per se, because Marvel and Jon Watts as director went for a completely different look, tone, and feel with Homecoming than Raimi did, but this is the definitive Spider-Man film, the first one if you will.
How? Well for one, apart from The Kingpin and Loki, Michael Keaton as The Vulture is best villain the MCU has had to date, appropiately threatening, doesn't drop off in threat or scale in the third act, but also with enough humanity and understandable motivations that it feels like a fully rounded character, as opposed to say, a drone army.
Tom Holland is a perfect Peter Parker for this role, if not exactly the original (outdated) 1960s Parker. He's naive and optimistic about being a superhero and wanting to swing into action, and brings the weight and emotional heft neccesary to convey how it feels to screw up on a big scale because hey, teenage superhero. He also plays a great teenager with super powers in the Parker role, desperately wanting to find a place for himself in the world, yet having no idea what that might be.
The supporting cast of teenagers is excellent if begging to be a little more fleshed out, which I'm sure they'll do in the next film. I didn't know Zendaya as a sarcastic hipster MJ was a thing I wanted till I saw it, but now I want even more of it. Peter's best friend Ned (stolen from Miles Morales story in the comics technically I know) is excellent, and never overdone, and I can't wait to see more of him.
RDJ's Tony Stark isn't in the film very much, and it's definitely the right decision, as this is definitely Spider-Man/Peter Parker's story through and through.
The film is on a small scale with relatively small, very well done action, and it portrays inexperienced Spider-Man at the beginning of his webslinging fighting career very well, which lends to the action scene. Tom Holland also portrays the stress and pain of fighting very well, and gives the action a whole lot of gravitas. The film is also extremely self contained incidentally, more so than any other MCU film since Iron Man or maybe Ant-Man, and wisely restrains itself from setting up anything except its own corner of the world and characters.
And it looks great. I thought so anyway. Great looking spider-suit, great looking vulture, realistic dressing teenagers (very diverse too, unlike Raimi's shtick) great looking action scenes.
So yeah, its the definitive spider-man film far as I'm concerned. Loved it.