Last part of my Zürich Film Festival short reviews:
Lady Macbeth
2016, William Oldroyd
So here we have a period drama on a laughably meagre budget (less than $1m iirc) featuring like 2-3 separate sets that look as scarce as can be and a cast of largely unknown actors. It has no right being this good. And yet it is. Florence Pugh as Katherine is basically sold to "Lord" Alexander something something, the son of Boris something something, to provide him an heir. Sadly, Alexander appears to have a hard time getting into the mood for Katherine and would rather make her stand naked with her back facing him and rub one out. His father is similarly disappointed with her neglecting her "duties as a wife". All of this leads to her becoming so sexually frustrated and deprived of love that she looks for it somewhere else and finds it in Sebastian, a servant. Of course this does not go unnoticed and Katherine ends up poisoning Boris and kills Alexander in self-defense when he finds out about the affair. Up to this point the movie features some very impressive cinematography and a very compelling character arc supported by excellent acting. You can tell that Oldroyd has a background in theatre, even though this is his first film, because the aesthetics are on point. And then Teddy, presumably Alexander's illegitimate son and now legitimate heir, shows up and all my enthusiasm left my body. Whereas everything before felt like a natural trajectory for both Katherine and the plot, Teddy's appearance did not. All the buildup in tension and energy from the deaths of Boris and Alexander was brought back down to a crawl and it's telegraphed from a mile away that the only way for the story to go is for Teddy to die. And then they kill him and the resolution to that felt like such utter bullshit because it relied on another unnatural plot contrivance (the servant Anna, who knows everything, going mute and practically insane). The first two thirds of the movie made a virtue out of its restraint and it's inexplicable to me why they completely throw it out of the window by the end. Even more devastating is what this means for Katherine's character. Birch's script appears deceptively intelligent in the beginning. Katherine gets increasingly reckless and ruthless but it's all justified in the treatment she receives by Alexander and Boris. Her desperate devotion to Sebastian almost makes you feel pity for her because you can tell it comes from a place of pain and loneliness. For most of the running time Lady Macbeth is strongly feminist and critical of the patriarchal structures of the time. The murder of Teddy, however, in the way it's set up and executed, makes Katherine appear like a hysteric lunatic, a depiction of women so prevalent during the time Lady Macbeth is set in, that it makes me wonder how they could miss the irony of it. My initial reaction when I was sitting in the cinema was that the movie was utter trash. After some long contemplation I don't feel as negative about it anymore, despite my issues with it. At first I Didn't like it now I Don't know.
Hell or High Water
2016, David Mackenzie
Basically a western set in modern Texas starring Chris Pine and Ben Foster as two heisting brothers followed by racist cop Jeff Bridges and his half-native-half-Mexican partner Gil Birmingham. They go from town to town, robbing small banks with little risk to pay back the mortgage for a farm their late mother left them. It almost went overboard in depicting these Texan ghosttowns and how shit the bank crisis has been for the region. Almost. Very entertaining if sombre drama that had a few spots of levity thanks to Ben Foster. I grew tired of Jeff Bridges' racist tirades and I don't think it needed that sniper scene close to the end. The scene between Pine and Bridges on the farm was tense as hell though and had me at the edge of my seat. Liked it.
Magnificent 7
2016, Antoine Fuqua
Saw HoHW after this, which diminished my opinion. Denzel was cool as usual. Crisp Rat was Crisp Rat. I liked the diverse cast. Otherwise it was a very by the numbers Hollywood movie that brought little new to the table. Liked it.