• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

My Hero Academia S2 |OT| This is Going to Stain my Hero Record. No Manga Spoilers!!!

P

Poodlestrike

Banned
NEO0MJ said:
The true power of One for All.



I feel it's strange that there are already what, eight people who inherited that power in a seemingly short time? Something's off about that.
Click to expand...

It's not that short a time. All for One first appeared... a while ago, right? I want to say somewhere in the century+ range.

caliph95 said:
I thought it was the injuries he suffered since it is making him weaker before the transfer and he keeps coughing blood
Click to expand...

TheGreatLugia said:
I want to say that in an Episode 3 monologue All Might mentioned retiring after One For All gets fully transferred, so I'm not sure if the transfer process is fatal on its own.

If All Might and his mentor also fought against the All For One user together, that makes it sound like All Might's mentor was still able to fight after One For All was almost or fully transferred to All Might.

I could be wrong, but so far I've had the impression that All Might is more at risk from his injuries than from transferring One For All, though it could be a combination of both.
Click to expand...

The injuries are undoubtedly a huge factor (and the reason he was dying to begin with, dude would've been on a clock even if he wasn't giving up OfA), but the apparitions Deku saw fighting mind control guy left me with the impression that more than just musclepower got transferred.

SalvaPot said:
8 Generations, but they could pass it any time. If we assume most OfA were active between 10 and 20 years, that is 80 years at least and 160 at most.
Click to expand...

10-20 feels generous, honestly. IIRC the OfA holders have only actually been capable of going toe to toe with AfO recently, I'd imagine the first few gens got crushed pretty rapidly.
 
N

NSESN

Member
I don't think Jiro's insecurity was played for laughs, at least it was not the impression I got in the manga.
About Mineta, he is terrible, but I disagree with people saying that he doesn't deserve to be in. He has one the coolest quirks imo, and if Horikoshi focused more on him using his quirk for heroing instead of his pervert antics he would be way better. I think Midnight a way worse character than him.
 
R

RedHoodedOwl

Member
NSESN said:
I don't think Jiro's insecurity was played for laughs, at least it was not the impression I got in the manga.
About Mineta, he is terrible, but I disagree with people saying that he doesn't deserve to be in. He has one the coolest quirks imo, and if Horikoshi focused more on him using his quirk for heroing instead of his pervert antics he would be way better. I think Midnight a way worse character than him.
Click to expand...

Midnight is trash.
 
J

Jintor

Member
NSESN said:
I don't think Jiro's insecurity was played for laughs, at least it was not the impression I got in the manga.
Click to expand...

it was a classic post-joke 'ironic beat'... don't really see how it wasn't... i mean, yes it highlights jirou's insecurity as well, but it was mainly just 1) perv gets hurt 2) girls are disgusted 3) person who hurt perv secretly like 'but he didn't perv on me'
 
A

Aaronrules380

Member
Poodlestrike said:
It's not that short a time. All for One first appeared... a while ago, right? I want to say somewhere in the century+ range.





The injuries are undoubtedly a huge factor (and the reason he was dying to begin with, dude would've been on a clock even if he wasn't giving up OfA), but the apparitions Deku saw fighting mind control guy left me with the impression that more than just musclepower got transferred.



10-20 feels generous, honestly. IIRC the OfA holders have only actually been capable of going toe to toe with AfO recently, I'd imagine the first few gens got crushed pretty rapidly.
Click to expand...
That's only if you assume he was aware or cared about them right away. They probably kept a low profile in the early generations
 
M

Meffer

Member
LotusHD said:
hK8sd99.png
Click to expand...

It's great because you know he spent countless hours in front of the mirror just to get that face just right.
 
N

Neoxon

Junior Member
You guys think we'll finish the All for One arc before the end of the season, or will the remainder of the episodes be mainly for the final exams?
 
P

Poodlestrike

Banned
Aaronrules380 said:
That's only if you assume he was aware or cared about them right away. They probably kept a low profile in the early generations
Click to expand...

The man's whole thing was being the power-obsessed absolute ruler of the criminal underworld, I can't imagine he'd have been super casual about something like this.
 
C

caliph95

Member
Poodlestrike said:
The man's whole thing was being the power-obsessed absolute ruler of the criminal underworld, I can't imagine he'd have been super casual about something like this.
Click to expand...
I mean he was also the most powerful guy in Japan, the first few generations at least were probably beneath his notice
 
C

ChubbyHuggs

Member
I don't think the first few even got killed by AFO. It's already shown that you don't have to die to have your (spirit, essence, ????) transferred over with the power. And if it's a collective of all the previous users power they probably weren't even strong enough to be noticed.

Meffer said:
The rest of the season will cover the final exams.
Click to expand...
The field training?
 
H

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
I always wondered if All For One was allowing One For All to transfer to user to user so he could eventually take it for himself once it had become suitably powerful.
 
N

NSESN

Member
I am almost wishing that the next season is only 13 episodes so Bones will have time to make all episodes have the quality of the stain fight.
 
L

Laiza

Member
HStallion said:
I always wondered if All For One was allowing One For All to transfer to user to user so he could eventually take it for himself once it had become suitably powerful.
Click to expand...
I suspect that that's going to be the case as well. I also suspect the fact that One for All has a desire component to it (it won't transfer unless the user wills it) will also play into that.

Makes me wonder, though... is it possible for One for All to be distributed across a large population by the will of the user? Obviously, it'd require distribution of their DNA for consumption, but from my understanding there's not really anything stopping a OfA user from just... making a bunch of OfA copies everywhere.
 
S

SalvaPot

Member
Poodlestrike said:
It's not that short a time. All for One first appeared... a while ago, right? I want to say somewhere in the century+ range.





The injuries are undoubtedly a huge factor (and the reason he was dying to begin with, dude would've been on a clock even if he wasn't giving up OfA), but the apparitions Deku saw fighting mind control guy left me with the impression that more than just musclepower got transferred.



10-20 feels generous, honestly. IIRC the OfA holders have only actually been capable of going toe to toe with AfO recently, I'd imagine the first few gens got crushed pretty rapidly.
Click to expand...

All Might had the power for several years, after all, Gran Torino is an elder and All Might got it while/after his school years, since he was trained by GT while he was still fairly young. And I want to think most users of OfA could handle themselves at least a decade, since we know that to inherit it you don't have to be quirkless, Toshinori and Deku just happened to be.
 
N

NSESN

Member
Laiza said:
Makes me wonder, though... is it possible for One for All to be distributed across a large population by the will of the user? Obviously, it'd require distribution of their DNA for consumption, but from my understanding there's not really anything stopping a OfA user from just... making a bunch of OfA copies everywhere.
Click to expand...

I think it is said in the first season but I will use spoilers just in case
No, because once it is passed the user start losing power, iirc All Might said something about his time in buff form shrinking after he passed the power to Deku.
 
Wheeljack539

Wheeljack539

Member
SalvaPot said:
All Might had the power for several years, after all, Gran Torino is an elder and All Might got it while/after his school years, since he was trained by GT while he was still fairly young. And I want to think most users of OfA could handle themselves at least a decade, since we know that to inherit it you don't have to be quirkless, Toshinori and Deku just happened to be.
Click to expand...

All Might had to have OfA for at the very least a decade or so from the bit when a young Izuku watched the video of All Might's debut in which by that point in the past was already an old video.
 
S

SalvaPot

Member
Wheeljack539 said:
All Might had to have OfA for at the very least a decade or so from the bit when a young Izuku watched the video of All Might's debut in which by that point in the past was already an old video.
Click to expand...

Well, for the internet an old video is a week old =P

But yeah, Deku was a toddler, and the video was already old by then.
 
W

WrenchNinja

Member
Caught up to episode 18. Man what a great season so far. This show is definitely up there as far as Tournament arcs are concerned. I really like Shoto's arc in the show, it's very familiar but there's one thing I really appreciate in that he never really disparages Izuku. Him showing up for the save against Stain when Izuku and Iida needed help made me want to cheer.
 
C

Chase17

Member
How does one determine they want to pass on a quirk when they don't know that they have the ability to pass a quirk on. Also I guess this means Deku went from quirckless to double quirk.
*waits for the revelation that Deku had a quirck all along that he just hadn't discovered yet* /s
 
S

SalvaPot

Member
Chase17 said:
How does one determine they want to pass on a quirk when they don't know that they have the ability to pass a quirk on. Also I guess this means Deku went from quirckless to double quirk.
*waits for the revelation that Deku had a quirck all along that he just hadn't discovered yet* /s
Click to expand...

Deku is confirmed quirkless because he doesn't have the mutation in his toe. At least the doctor said it was the most common feature in quirkless people.

But its totally possible that the OTHER quirks from any of the previous AfO may have mixed with it and are now dormant in Deku.
 
V

VariantX

Member
SalvaPot said:
Deku is confirmed quirkless because he doesn't have the mutation in his toe. At least the doctor said it was the most common feature in quirkless people.

But its totally possible that the OTHER quirks from any of the previous AfO may have mixed with it and are now dormant in Deku.
Click to expand...

Thats true. There was zero stipulation that those who receive the power had to be quirkless to begin with.
 
N

NEO0MJ

Member
Poodlestrike said:
It's not that short a time. All for One first appeared... a while ago, right? I want to say somewhere in the century+ range.
Click to expand...

In my head it's only been around 100 years since quirks showed up and since it seemed that the younger brother was a young adult when he received OFA that means that a new holder of the power came almost every ten years, but all might had it since he was at least in high school so that's why I find it strange.
 
S

Seesaw15

Member
NEO0MJ said:
In my head it's only been around 100 years since quirks showed up and since it seemed that the younger brother was a young adult when he received OFA that means that a new holder of the power came almost every ten years, but all might had it since he was at least in high school so that's why I find it strange.
Click to expand...

Ehh, 8 people over a 100 year period doesn't seem that strange. We know All Might's around 45 years old and has been active for at least 25 years. Since AfO's little brother was noble but weak he probably had OfA for a short period of time before he transferred it. That leaves us with 6 OfA users over about 70 years. Since it's a quirk that stockpiles power it makes since that the first couple of users were pretty weak and thus transferred it quickly once they knew they couldn't beat AfO.
 
S

SalvaPot

Member
Seesaw15 said:
Ehh, 8 people over a 100 year period doesn't seem that strange. We know All Might's around 45 years old and has been active for at least 25 years. Since AfO's little brother was noble but weak he probably had OfA for a short period of time before he transferred it. That leaves us with 6 OfA users over about 70 years. Since it's a quirk that stockpiles power it makes since that the first couple of users were pretty weak and thus transferred it quickly once they knew they couldn't beat AfO.
Click to expand...

The quirk does stock power, and by stock power I think it means actual training and hard work. I don't think they transferred it quickly, but did when they felt they couldn't add more to it or found a suitable successor after properly training him to inherit it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

House of the Dragon S2 |OT| Blood for Blood, Fire to Fire (no book discussion)
6 7 8 9 10
458
22K
EverydayBeast replied
Eiyuden Chronicle: Hundred Heroes | Review Thread
Analysis Review 2 3
143
12K
BadBurger replied
Rose Tint my GAF (aka, Why do we thrive on Negativity?)
2
67
3K
NotMyProblemAnymoreCunt replied
Deadlock |OT|
|OT| Community 2
86
6K
Donald mac Ronald replied
Path of Exile 2 Early Access |OT| An Exile like ARPG.
|OT| 56 57 58 59 60
3K
75K
Rentahamster replied
Top Bottom