• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

My Little Pony FiM Community |OT| We will love and tolerate the SHIT outta you!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Pancakes

hot, steaming, as melted butter slips into the cracks, drizzled with sticky sweet syrup OH GOD
Oh Twilight....

(Click for full size)
 
Pandaman said:
Is the pic good? Yes. Is it worth posting? Yes. Is it appropriate for GAF? No.
This. Is the content suggestive? Yes. Is it downright pornographic? I don't think so; I've seen worse posted inline inside other threads. There's implication there, but we don't see anything we don't normally see on the show
(horn, mouth, drool)
. It's "just intended for ponies that love each other very much to enjoy"
so don't look at it, CMC!
. Besides, we had two warnings AND a spoiler tag AND it wasn't directly linked to, requiring a select-and-rightclick or copy/paste to access. Seriously, I think there was enough warning given for something Milk obviously felt was potentially borderline. Let's not be ridiculous about it.

Appropriate for GAF? Probably not. But a huge deal? I don't think so.

ahoyhoy said:
http://images.yuku.com/image/gif/98135f117fabfa7c95597149c5039093ff879f7.gif
Did the pic just make you lose the contest? :D

Captain Fish said:
I just found a great comic by Siansaar.
He made up 'evil' OCs then set them upon the main 6. It ended up being a really touching series.
This is amazing. Thank you so much for sharing.

AdawgDaFAB said:
This should get a few laughs, its a shoop based on the silhouette:
Add this to the "cannot unsee" list:
JCGJU.jpg
 

Myke Greywolf

Ambassador of Goodwill
Nocturnowl said:
Hmm, unstable.... contains stable.....collapse, the unstable stable will collapse! how appropriate.
I have to say i'm enjoying the decent into madness around here, the true test of love and toleration is right here.
My Litttle Pony FiM Community |OT2| Welcome to NeoGAF's tolerance clinic
 
D

Deleted member 10571

Unconfirmed Member
Nishastra said:
Hooray! I can unsee it :p

Usually these kind of things are quite annoying, but I can still see Applejack in the silhouette :p
I'm with you Nish :) Absolutely no problem to "unsee" it.
 

tiff

Banned
Adelor Lyon said:
This. Is the content suggestive? Yes. Is it downright pornographic? I don't think so; I've seen worse posted inline inside other threads. There's implication there, but we don't see anything we don't normally see on the show
(horn, mouth, drool)
. It's "just intended for ponies that love each other very much to enjoy"
so don't look at it, CMC!
. Besides, we had two warnings AND a spoiler tag AND it wasn't directly linked to, requiring a select-and-rightclick or copy/paste to access. Seriously, I think there was enough warning given for something Milk obviously felt was potentially borderline. Let's not be ridiculous about it.

Appropriate for GAF? Probably not. But a huge deal? I don't think so.
Basically. But this thread isn't about friendship and tolerance anymore.
 

Neki

Member
tiff said:
Basically. But this thread isn't about friendship and tolerance anymore.
What does one accomplish by drawing something like that? It's certainly not enriching or inspiring fan art, like many of you preach to me that human ponies are.
 
That picture screams friendship to me.

Seriously though, I think the thread is fine how it is now. Even though we have a pony vx human pony war every few days, the fact that no one has left the thread because of it means we're still very much friendship and tolerance. Sure, some of us could probably stand to turn down the hateful language a bit whenever human ponies are mentioned, but aside from that I think we're good.

Besides, without new episodes, we all knew this was going to happen. It beats the thread being dead.
 
We get a pony Sora similar to cub Sora in The Lion King world. Sora can be a unicorn pony.

Googled and saw there's a shadow pony but not based on FiM:
tumblr_ll22veW3Yj1qano2so1_400.jpg


Maybe mini-games based on the series, like flying to help guide Rainbow Dash make a sonic rainboom. Or maybe a magic show-off versus the great Trixie. Or maybe help Rarity stitch the gala dresses.

Lots of bosses to be had too.
- Night Mare Moon
- Manticore
- Dragon
- Parasprites (like those bee things in Mulan world in KH2)
- Zecora (maybe)
 

CHEEZMO™

Obsidian fan
Ultimoo said:
What does one accomplish by drawing something like that? It's certainly not enriching or inspiring fan art, like many of you preach to me that human ponies are.
I didn't see any humans in that picture.
 

Nishastra

Banned
tiff said:
Basically. But this thread isn't about friendship and tolerance anymore.
It's always the same problem. Just because someone wants whatever their thing is to be tolerated doesn't mean they'll tolerate anyone else's.

Seems like a universal human problem. Let's all become ponies.
 

CHEEZMO™

Obsidian fan
Ultimoo said:
I never said there were any humans in that picture.
Then what's going on here?
Ultimoo said:
What does one accomplish by drawing something like that? It's certainly not enriching or inspiring fan art, like many of you preach to me that human ponies are.
 

Neki

Member
CHEEZMO™ said:
Then what's going on here?
I'm saying that people justify human pony fan art because some say that it's enriching or inspiring or creative, but that picture posted doesn't have any redeeming qualities.
 

CHEEZMO™

Obsidian fan
Ultimoo said:
I'm saying that people justify human pony fan art because some say that it's enriching or inspiring or creative, but that picture posted doesn't have any redeeming qualities.
Which picture?
 

Nishastra

Banned
Ultimoo said:
I'm saying that people justify human pony fan art because some say that it's enriching or inspiring or creative, but that picture posted doesn't have any redeeming qualities.
Who said anything like that? And who said the picture in question isn't creative?

This isn't what anything is about. A lot of things posted in here are just amusing. Some of them are just nice pictures. They're not going to inspire someone to go create world peace, they're not going to lead someone to live a better life.

They're entertaining, one way or another. If you don't find them entertaining, that's too bad, but it doesn't mean that they're not to anyone else.


Now, mind you, I think we should avoid going down the road of the picture in question just because it might kill this thread (one way or another), but...
 

Neki

Member
This isn't what anything is about. A lot of things posted in here are just amusing. Some of them are just nice pictures. They're not going to inspire someone to go create world peace, they're not going to lead someone to live a better life.
I'm not asking for world peace, I'm asking the pictures to be tasteful. And when I say inspiring, I mean it will make other people besides MLP fans apperciate MLP, which I don't think that picture would. I certainly don't find that picture nice or humourous to say the least.

"People justify X by saying it is A and B. Z is neither A or B"

X=/=Z, Ultimoo.

Tell me why you think it's a good picture then.
 

Nishastra

Banned
Ultimoo said:
I'm not asking for world peace, I'm asking the pictures to be tasteful. And when I say inspiring, I mean it will make other people besides MLP fans apperciate MLP, which I don't think that picture would. I certainly don't find that picture nice or humourous to say the least.
Thus my next line:
They're entertaining, one way or another. If you don't find them entertaining, that's too bad, but it doesn't mean that they're not to anyone else.

They don't have no worth just because you don't like them. And whether someone who's not into the show would appreciate it would depend very much on them :p

Again, like I said, that picture is not a good idea for this thread (as much for this very conversation's existence as for some kind of looming threat of being locked), but I'm responding as much to the general disdain for "human pony" pictures from some as to that.

tiff said:
I think it's funny. Why are we arguing about this?
Dunno. It's something to do while waiting for the next set of Steam daily sales. Also I'm defragmenting and can't play New Vegas right now.
 

Narag

Member
Nishastra said:
Dunno. It's something to do while waiting for the next set of Steam daily sales. Also I'm defragmenting and can't play New Vegas right now.

I woke up at 8 am and had nothing to do until the next set of sales so I went back to bed for 4 hours. :(
 

Nishastra

Banned
Narag said:
I woke up at 8 am and had nothing to do until the next set of sales so I went back to bed for 4 hours. :(
I wish defragmenting didn't take so long. Damn terabyte drives. This'd go a lot faster if I was punching people's heads off with my enormous metal fist.
 

Neki

Member
Jintor said:
It's a valid conclusion to draw from the first post, considering your known stance on the issue.
Fair, but I'm telling you that's not what my post said, I've already explained it. If you take it any other way besides the way I've explained, then you're putting words into my mouth.

Apparently you guys need me to explain this, again, and in point form so you can actually understand it.

Point 1: some of you like human ponies
Point 2: I've asked why
Point 3: I've gotten responses ranging from many different things, like how fan art is good, brings out creativeness and humour and happiness
Point 4: I don't agree necessarily, but I can see your logic.
Point 5: I see this picture, and some of you are okay with it
Point 6: Based on the responses I get from why you like human ponies, I see that said picture is neither of the above, I can't see the logic in why this picture is liked
Point 7: I ask why you think this picture is tasteful and appropriate.

Seriously guys, seriously.
 

Neki

Member
CHEEZMO™ said:
I like sausages.

I also like cake.

Sausages aren't cake.

If you don't find the picture appropriate, feel free to ignore my question. It is aimed at someone who does.
 

Nishastra

Banned
Ultimoo said:
Point 7: I ask why you think this picture is tasteful and appropriate.
It's not, but that doesn't mean I don't like it. I like a lot of things that aren't "tasteful" and certainly not appropriate for GAF :p

CHEEZMO™ said:
I like sausages.

I also like cake.

Sausages aren't cake.
Uuugh, now I'm thinking of some kind of cake that has sausage in it.
 

CHEEZMO™

Obsidian fan
Ultimoo said:
If you don't find the picture appropriate, feel free to ignore my question. It is aimed at someone who does. Once again, stop trying to argue with me if you don't understand what I'm asking.
Do you realise what it is you're asking and where you're going with this?

Apples and oranges / swings and roundabouts.
 
FTH said:
you gotta shaaaaarrrre

you gotta caaaaaarrrre
Now this certainly is appropriate for the situation.
I've actually lost track of which picture everyone is on about here, you see how confusing you all have made this?!
 

tiff

Banned
Ultimoo said:
Yes, so is it fair to ask that we keep it out of the thread then?
If things that weren't tasteful and GAF-appropriate were kept out of every thread then GAF would be boring as hell.

Things are already hard enough with icecream gone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom