• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

My Little Pony FiM Community |OT2| I just don't know what went wrong!

Status
Not open for further replies.

McNum

Member
I might retire Luna when XCOM launches. Or find some way to combine it.

Just realized... Six man squad, the ability to customize, including color choice, and rename your troops... I have a bad idea. Team Harmony versus the aliens!
 
CHEEZMO™;41160152 said:
Snyt has a pone avatar now?

The assimilation continues.

Yeah, I know. I watch the show, frequent this thread (mostly as a lurker) and now I have a pony avatar. The next step is probably buying toys, and that's one step I won't take. Not because there's anything wrong with toys, but I've never seen the appeal of figurines (anime, games etc.) and have never really wanted one except for one really really awesome Metroid statue.

I'm also a bit hesitant to call myself a brony, even if I am one per definition, because of the vocal crazy minority (y'know, the kind of people that'd buy that Lyra plushie) that has given bronies a bad rep on the internet. I prefer to just say I'm a fan of the show to avoid a bit of that image many people unfortunately have.
 

$200

Banned
S1 rankings

---

S2 rankings

Family Appreciation Day: (0*1+0*2+0*3+0*4+5*5)/5 - 5.00
Hearts and Hooves Day: (0*1+0*2+0*3+1*4+5*5)/6 - 4.83
The Return of Harmony Part 2: (0*1+0*2+0*3+2*4+8*5)/10 - 4.80
It's About Time: (0*1+0*2+0*3+2*4+4*5)/6 - 4.67
The Last Roundup: (0*1+0*2+0*3+4*4+5*5)/9 - 4.56
A Friend in Deed: (0*1+0*2+0*3+3*4+3*5)/6 - 4.50
Luna Eclipsed: (0*1+0*2+0*3+4*4+3*5)/7 - 4.43
The Return of Harmony Part 1: (0*1+0*2+0*3+7*4+5*5)/12 - 4.42
Sweet and Elite: (0*1+0*2+2*3+3*4+5*5)/10 - 4.30
Hearth's Warming Eve: (0*1+0*2+1*3+4*4+1*5)/6 - 4.00
Read It and Weep: (0*1+0*2+3*3+8*4+2*5)/13 - 3.92
May the Best Pet Win!: (0*1+0*2+4*3+2*4+3*5)/9 - 3.89
Putting Your Hoof Down: (0*1+0*2+2*3+2*4+1*5)/5 - 3.80
Lesson Zero: (1*1+1*2+0*3+2*4+3*5)/7 - 3.71
Secret of My Excess: (0*1+2*2+2*3+4*4+2*5)/10 - 3.60
The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000: (0*1+0*2+6*3+5*4+1*5)/12 - 3.58
Sisterhooves Social: (1*1+2*2+0*3+3*4+1*5)/7 - 3.14
Baby Cakes: (1*1+1*2+4*3+3*4+0*5)/9 - 3.00
The Mysterious Mare Do Well: (0*1+4*2+1*3+3*4+0*5)/8 - 2.88
The Cutie Pox: (0*1+2*2+4*3+1*4+0*5)/7 - 2.86

Personally I think they should be lower on the list.

6a0.jpg
 

brian577

Banned
Personally I think they should be lower on the list.



Oh Fluttershy fans, your almost bad as the Rainbow Dash fans, give your favorite character some development and it's immediately a bad episode.
Too many fans hold her up as an unblemished embodiment of virgin purity than anything. And a big reason Fluttershy fans hate PYHD is because it has the audacity to make Fluttershy look bad. The writers can't developer her character in any direction that will please the rabid Fluttershy fans.
 

LuffyZoro

Member
Oh Fluttershy fans, your almost bad as the Rainbow Dash fans, give your favorite character some development and it's immediately a bad episode.
Too many fans hold her up as an unblemished embodiment of virgin purity than anything. And a big reason Fluttershy fans hate PYHD is because it has the audacity to make Fluttershy look bad. The writers can't developer her character in any direction that will please the rabid Fluttershy fans.

You got it all wrong. $200 hates Fluttershy with a passion. I like her, and rated the episode a 4.
 

Razek

Banned
S1 rankings

---

S2 rankings

Family Appreciation Day: (0*1+0*2+0*3+0*4+5*5)/5 - 5.00
Hearts and Hooves Day: (0*1+0*2+0*3+1*4+5*5)/6 - 4.83
The Return of Harmony Part 2: (0*1+0*2+0*3+2*4+8*5)/10 - 4.80
It's About Time: (0*1+0*2+0*3+2*4+4*5)/6 - 4.67
The Last Roundup: (0*1+0*2+0*3+4*4+5*5)/9 - 4.56
A Friend in Deed: (0*1+0*2+0*3+3*4+3*5)/6 - 4.50
Luna Eclipsed: (0*1+0*2+0*3+4*4+3*5)/7 - 4.43
The Return of Harmony Part 1: (0*1+0*2+0*3+7*4+5*5)/12 - 4.42
Sweet and Elite: (0*1+0*2+2*3+3*4+5*5)/10 - 4.30
Hearth's Warming Eve: (0*1+0*2+1*3+4*4+1*5)/6 - 4.00
Read It and Weep: (0*1+0*2+3*3+8*4+2*5)/13 - 3.92
May the Best Pet Win!: (0*1+0*2+4*3+2*4+3*5)/9 - 3.89
Putting Your Hoof Down: (0*1+0*2+2*3+2*4+1*5)/5 - 3.80
Lesson Zero: (1*1+1*2+0*3+2*4+3*5)/7 - 3.71
Secret of My Excess: (0*1+2*2+2*3+4*4+2*5)/10 - 3.60
The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000: (0*1+0*2+6*3+5*4+1*5)/12 - 3.58
Sisterhooves Social: (1*1+2*2+0*3+3*4+1*5)/7 - 3.14
Baby Cakes: (1*1+1*2+4*3+3*4+0*5)/9 - 3.00
The Mysterious Mare Do Well: (0*1+4*2+1*3+3*4+0*5)/8 - 2.88
The Cutie Pox: (0*1+2*2+4*3+1*4+0*5)/7 - 2.86

Personally I think they should be lower on the list.

http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/000/263/344/6a0.jpg[IMG][/QUOTE]

Oh crap, this was today? Oops. Good to see a certain episode ranking where it belongs.

[quote="Link Man, post: 41163329"]I don't need a pony avatar. I'll stick with slightly-embarrassed Link, as it fits my persona.

[url=http://fav.me/d5bmpsq][img]http://th03.deviantart.net/fs70/PRE/f/2012/231/8/c/rarity_despair_2_by_mysticalpha-d5bmpsq.jpg[img][/url][/QUOTE]

I still really like the one you made for me. I don't think I'll be changing it for a while.

[quote="brian577, post: 41163410"]Oh Fluttershy fans, your almost bad as the Rainbow Dash fans, give your favorite character some development and it's immediately a bad episode.
Too many fans hold her up as an unblemished embodiment of virgin purity than anything. And a big reason Fluttershy fans hate PYHD is because it has the audacity to make Fluttershy look bad. The writers can't developer her character in any direction that will please the rabid Fluttershy fans.[/QUOTE]

Once she shows her true side and the monster lurking inside her she isn't so fluttertastic anymore. Personally, I like her complex. It gives her some actual character.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
Once she shows her true side and the monster lurking inside her she isn't so fluttertastic anymore. Personally, I like her complex. It gives her some actual character.

Least Fluttershy can acknowledge her faults and confront them, unlike ponies like Rarity who lie and manipulate without consequence.
 

Razek

Banned
Least Fluttershy can acknowledge her faults and confront them, unlike ponies like Rarity who lie and manipulate without consequence.

I was pretty mean to Fluttershy when I first got here. I still believe what she said in that episode is the most sinister and hateful possible thing within the universe. You just don't insult another pony for their birth skill, ever. However, I failed to realize she did ultimately understand her faults after that moment and was able to move on. I suppose that is quite admirable. Maybe she isn't on the way way way down bottom of the list for me after all.

Even though Rarity got away with her scheme, she still was willing to stick up for her friends in the end. She just didn't have to pay a penalty to learn the lesson. I think that's admirable as well.
 
got my posters! <3 <3 <3 thanks judhudson! and lol yeah, they are super super super creased. that poster tube suuuucked lol. but yeah still super happy about this.
 

judhudson

Member
got my posters! <3 <3 <3 thanks judhudson! and lol yeah, they are super super super creased. that poster tube suuuucked lol. but yeah still super happy about this.

Arrggghhh, hate my post office for recommending those to me! Knew I should of just bought the big tubes at Walmart. So sorry about that :(
 

Videoneon

Member
S1 rankings

---

S2 rankings

Family Appreciation Day: (0*1+0*2+0*3+0*4+5*5)/5 - 5.00
Hearts and Hooves Day: (0*1+0*2+0*3+1*4+5*5)/6 - 4.83
The Return of Harmony Part 2: (0*1+0*2+0*3+2*4+8*5)/10 - 4.80
It's About Time: (0*1+0*2+0*3+2*4+4*5)/6 - 4.67
The Last Roundup: (0*1+0*2+0*3+4*4+5*5)/9 - 4.56
A Friend in Deed: (0*1+0*2+0*3+3*4+3*5)/6 - 4.50
Luna Eclipsed: (0*1+0*2+0*3+4*4+3*5)/7 - 4.43
The Return of Harmony Part 1: (0*1+0*2+0*3+7*4+5*5)/12 - 4.42
Sweet and Elite: (0*1+0*2+2*3+3*4+5*5)/10 - 4.30
Hearth's Warming Eve: (0*1+0*2+1*3+4*4+1*5)/6 - 4.00
Read It and Weep: (0*1+0*2+3*3+8*4+2*5)/13 - 3.92
May the Best Pet Win!: (0*1+0*2+4*3+2*4+3*5)/9 - 3.89
Putting Your Hoof Down: (0*1+0*2+2*3+2*4+1*5)/5 - 3.80
Lesson Zero: (1*1+1*2+0*3+2*4+3*5)/7 - 3.71
Secret of My Excess: (0*1+2*2+2*3+4*4+2*5)/10 - 3.60
The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000: (0*1+0*2+6*3+5*4+1*5)/12 - 3.58
Sisterhooves Social: (1*1+2*2+0*3+3*4+1*5)/7 - 3.14
Baby Cakes: (1*1+1*2+4*3+3*4+0*5)/9 - 3.00
The Mysterious Mare Do Well: (0*1+4*2+1*3+3*4+0*5)/8 - 2.88
The Cutie Pox: (0*1+2*2+4*3+1*4+0*5)/7 - 2.86

Personally I think they should be lower on the list.

6a0.jpg

Thanks. Damn, Sisterhooves and Super Speedy Cider Squeezy didn't even make middle of the pack? I don't think they're top, and I know I like Rarity, but I can't say Sisterhooves was 4th worst episode.

Hurry up Season 3!
 
That CMC comic was awesome, unfortunately, I accidentally saw the end first by starting at the end of the page. :/

And I think some congratulations are in order...

SVgsr.jpg


Good job Carek!
 
Angel's still an asshole, but that is pretty damn adorable. In a sense I find it a better way of resolving the power struggle than Putting Your Hoof Down did.

I never really got the whole aversion to using the term Brony. It seems like people are afraid to use the term because Brony somehow means you're one of those who are completely and utterly obsessed with it. To me if you watch the show, enjoy it, and like talking about it, you're a Brony. The ones who do all the crazy stuff, they're.. well....crazy.

The resistance to the label always struck me as high school identity politics - surely I can't be in the same group as those freaks, so I'll put all the ones I don't want to be associated in with column A and myself and those who enjoy it in the same way I do in column B. But I suppose it isn't the most important thing in the world.
 

Link Man

Banned
The resistance to the label always struck me as high school identity politics - surely I can't be in the same group as those freaks, so I'll put all the ones I don't want to be associated in with column A and myself and those who enjoy it in the same way I do in column B. But I suppose it isn't the most important thing in the world.

And yet the label itself doesn't smack of high school politics?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom