• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

My Little Pony FiM Community |OT2| I just don't know what went wrong!

Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Tenumi

Banned
Mine went... about how I expected

1 Fluttershy
2 Rarity
3 Sweetie Belle
4 Twilight Sparkle
5 Apple Bloom
6 Babs Seed
7 Princess Celestia
8 Derpy
9 Princess Cadence
10 Queen Chrysalis
11 Pinkie Pie
12 Vinyl Scratch
13 Lyra
13 Bon Bon
15 Octavia
16 Princess Luna
17 Discord
18 Rainbow Dash
19 Shining Armor
20 Scootaloo
21 Lightning Dust
22 Cloud Chaser
22 Flitter
24 Applejack
25 Cheerilee
26 Spike
27 Nightmare Moon
28 Big Macintosh
29 Fleur de Lys
30 Granny Smith
30 Diamond Tiara
30 Silver Spoon
30 Berry Punch
30 Soarin'
30 Spitfire
30 Fancy Pants
37 Photo Finish
38 Trixie
38 King Sombra
40 Zecora
41 Iron Will
42 Flim
42 Flam
42 Snowflake / Horsepower
45 Rose Luck
45 Colgate
45 Dr. Whooves
45 Carrot Top
45 Braeburn
45 Caramel
45 Hoity Toity
45 Prince Blueblood
53 Twist
54 Pipsqueak
55 Gilda
 
P

PaulloDEC

Member
Top Tier

Applejack, Twilight Sparkle, Rarity, Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie, Fluttershy, Spike, Applebloom, Sweetie Belle, Scootaloo, Celestia, Luna, Discord

Almost Top Tier

Big Mac, The Cakes, Cadance, Shining Armor, Zecora

Slightly Lower Tier

Everypony else
 
L

LuffyZoro

Member
1 Fluttershy
2 Pinkie Pie
3 Lyra
4 Discord
5 Vinyl Scratch
6 Derpy
7 Dr. Whooves
8 Spitfire
9 Soarin'
10 Scootaloo
11 Rarity
12 Trixie
13 Iron Will
14 Nightmare Moon
15 Twilight Sparkle
16 Queen Chrysalis
17 Princess Luna
18 Apple Bloom
19 Octavia
20 Berry Punch
21 Sweetie Belle
22 Cloud Chaser
23 Flitter
24 Gilda
25 Spike
26 Princess Celestia
27 Rainbow Dash
28 Bon Bon
29 Colgate
30 Zecora
31 Fancy Pants
32 Braeburn
33 Shining Armor
34 Pipsqueak
35 Princess Cadence
36 Applejack
37 Photo Finish
38 Granny Smith
39 Big Macintosh
40 Lightning Dust
41 Cheerilee
42 Snowflake / Horsepower
43 Flam
44 Flim
45 Silver Spoon
46 Fleur de Lys
47 Rose Luck
48 Hoity Toity
49 Babs Seed
50 Carrot Top
51 Diamond Tiara
52 Caramel
53 Prince Blueblood
54 King Sombra
55 Twist
 
N

novenD

Member
Rank Character
1 Princess Celestia
2 Twilight Sparkle
3 Rainbow Dash
4 Fluttershy
4 Rarity
6 Pinkie Pie
7 Applejack
8 Princess Luna
9 Discord
10 Spike
10 Trixie
12 Sweetie Belle
13 Apple Bloom
14 Zecora
15 Cheerilee
16 Scootaloo
17 Shining Armor
17 Granny Smith
19 Princess Cadence
19 Pipsqueak
21 Queen Chrysalis
22 Nightmare Moon
23 Flim
23 Flam
25 Spitfire
26 Soarin'
27 Iron Will
28 Derpy
29 Big Macintosh
30 Gilda
31 Snowflake / Horsepower
32 Diamond Tiara
32 Fancy Pants
34 Bon Bon
34 Photo Finish
36 Dr. Whooves
37 Octavia
38 Braeburn
39 Babs Seed
40 Silver Spoon
41 Lyra
41 Carrot Top
41 Hoity Toity
44 Rose Luck
44 Caramel
46 Vinyl Scratch
47 Berry Punch
47 Lightning Dust
49 Fleur de Lys
50 Prince Blueblood
51 Colgate
52 King Sombra
52 Cloud Chaser
52 Twist
55 Flitter
Click to expand...

Princess_Celestia_smiling_S2E02.png
Click to expand...

Pretty much what I expected.
 
H

Hitokage

Setec Astronomer
1 Twilight Sparkle
2 Pinkie Pie
3 Rainbow Dash
3 Princess Luna
5 Rarity
5 Applejack
7 Apple Bloom
7 Trixie
9 Zecora
10 Sweetie Belle
10 Cheerilee
10 Big Macintosh
10 Diamond Tiara
10 Silver Spoon
10 Pipsqueak
10 Lyra
10 Bon Bon
18 Scootaloo
18 Granny Smith
20 Spike
20 Nightmare Moon
20 Flim
20 Flam
20 Vinyl Scratch
20 Lightning Dust
20 Photo Finish
20 Fancy Pants
20 Fleur de Lys
20 Prince Blueblood
30 Queen Chrysalis
31 Princess Celestia
31 Octavia
33 Fluttershy
34 Dr. Whooves
35 Derpy
35 Colgate
37 Discord
37 Shining Armor
37 Rose Luck
37 Berry Punch
41 Princess Cadence
41 Carrot Top
41 Soarin'
41 Spitfire
41 Braeburn
41 Babs Seed
47 Caramel
48 King Sombra
48 Cloud Chaser
48 Flitter
48 Twist
48 Gilda
48 Snowflake / Horsepower
48 Hoity Toity
55 Iron Will

Names that didn't ring a bell marked out. Also, not sure how Gilda ended up so low. Might have overlooked her entry when it came up.
 
W

wookieofdoom

Member
1 Princess Luna
2 Applejack
3 Derpy
4 Rarity
5 Rainbow Dash
6 Trixie
7 Twilight Sparkle
7 Fluttershy
7 Pinkie Pie
7 Spike
11 Discord
12 Sweetie Belle
12 Apple Bloom
12 Scootaloo
12 Big Macintosh
16 Princess Celestia
17 Queen Chrysalis
17 Cheerilee
19 Lyra
19 Bon Bon
21 Octavia
21 Vinyl Scratch
23 Zecora
24 Spitfire
25 Flim
25 Flam
25 Diamond Tiara
28 Granny Smith
29 Princess Cadence
29 Shining Armor
31 Nightmare Moon
32 Silver Spoon
33 Colgate
34 Cloud Chaser
34 Flitter
36 Gilda
37 Photo Finish
38 Snowflake / Horsepower
39 Lightning Dust
40 Iron Will
41 Berry Punch
41 Soarin'
43 Babs Seed
44 Rose Luck
44 Dr. Whooves
46 Carrot Top
46 Braeburn
48 Caramel
49 Pipsqueak
49 King Sombra
49 Twist
49 Fancy Pants
49 Fleur de Lys
54 Hoity Toity
54 Prince Blueblood

BpYtCXP.png


Luna is like: "I am best pony. What of it?"
 
UberTag

UberTag

Member
Here's my list of pony rankings... glad to have Sweetie Belle ranked higher than everyone else here. Surprised how low Applejack wound up.
Evidently I'm also the biggest Diamond Tiara fan here.

1 Rarity
2 Sweetie Belle
3 Fluttershy
4 Twilight Sparkle
5 Rainbow Dash
6 Spitfire
7 Trixie
8 Princess Celestia
9 Spike
10 Pinkie Pie
11 Diamond Tiara
12 Granny Smith
13 Apple Bloom
14 Scootaloo
15 Lightning Dust
16 Princess Luna
17 Discord
18 Cheerilee
19 Applejack
20 Derpy
21 Zecora
22 Princess Cadence
23 Big Macintosh
24 Shining Armor
25 Babs Seed
26 Fancy Pants
27 Vinyl Scratch
28 Berry Punch
29 Silver Spoon
30 Photo Finish
31 Carrot Top
32 Nightmare Moon
33 Soarin'
34 Twist
35 Gilda
36 Queen Chrysalis
37 Lyra
38 Iron Will
39 Flim
40 Flam
41 Fleur de Lys
42 Hoity Toity
43 Colgate
44 Cloud Chaser
45 Bon Bon
46 Braeburn
47 Caramel
48 Rose Luck
49 Pipsqueak
50 Octavia
51 Dr. Whooves
52 Prince Blueblood
53 Snowflake / Horsepower
54 Flitter
55 King Sombra
 
P

Parfait

Member
1 Trixie
2 Queen Chrysalis
3 Nightmare Moon
4 Rarity
5 Princess Luna
6 Twilight Sparkle
7 Princess Celestia
8 Fleur de Lys
9 Princess Cadence
10 Octavia

yeah that's about right
 
M

McNum

Member
Let's see...

1 Twilight Sparkle
2 Princess Luna
3 Fluttershy
4 Pinkie Pie
5 Rarity
6 Rainbow Dash
7 Applejack
8 Princess Celestia
9 Sweetie Belle
10 Scootaloo
11 Spike
12 Apple Bloom
13 Cheerilee
13 Big Macintosh
15 Nightmare Moon
16 Discord
17 Zecora
18 Babs Seed
19 Princess Cadence
20 Derpy
21 Octavia
22 Vinyl Scratch
23 Shining Armor
24 Queen Chrysalis
25 Spitfire
26 Soarin'
27 Trixie
28 Pipsqueak
29 Lyra
30 Bon Bon
31 Granny Smith
32 Cloud Chaser
33 Flitter
34 Snowflake / Horsepower
35 Iron Will
36 Braeburn
37 Fancy Pants
38 Photo Finish
39 King Sombra
40 Lightning Dust
41 Diamond Tiara
42 Silver Spoon
43 Flim
43 Flam
45 Carrot Top
45 Caramel
47 Twist
48 Berry Punch
48 Hoity Toity
50 Fleur de Lys
51 Rose Luck
52 Dr. Whooves
53 Colgate
54 Prince Blueblood
55 Gilda

Well, the top 20 seems pretty accurate, and Gilda is safe in last place as usual. She's a bully and she made Fluttershy cry, she'll stay right down there where she belongs.

How did Cheerilee and Big Mac end up tied, though? The only one I picked No Opinion on was Flim vs. Flam. Because those two are really just one character in two ponies. I suppose it does seem fitting, though. They're cute together.
 
B

BDGAME

Member
Mine:

1 Twilight Sparkle
2 Fluttershy
3 Pinkie Pie
4 Princess Celestia
5 Applejack
6 Princess Luna
7 Rainbow Dash
7 Rarity
9 Zecora
10 Discord
10 Shining Armor
12 Sweetie Belle
12 Apple Bloom
12 Scootaloo
12 Lyra
12 Bon Bon
17 Cheerilee
17 Granny Smith
19 Big Macintosh
20 Spike
21 Trixie
22 Princess Cadence
23 Babs Seed
24 Derpy
25 Octavia
25 Berry Punch
25 Vinyl Scratch
28 Diamond Tiara
28 Photo Finish
30 Pipsqueak
31 Fancy Pants
32 Iron Will
33 Gilda
34 Fleur de Lys
35 Spitfire
36 Soarin'
37 Braeburn
38 Colgate
38 Dr. Whooves
38 Carrot Top
41 Rose Luck
41 Caramel
41 Twist
41 Snowflake / Horsepower
41 Lightning Dust
41 Hoity Toity
41 Prince Blueblood
48 Queen Chrysalis
48 Nightmare Moon
48 Flim
48 Flam
48 King Sombra
53 Silver Spoon
53 Cloud Chaser
53 Flitter
Click to expand...

I don`t like Discord and Shining Armor mora than the CMC and Lyra.
 
B

brian577

Banned
So the premier is called Princess Twilight and
the sun and moon are caught in perpetual Twilight because of the princesses absence?
Brilliant.
 
P

PaulloDEC

Member
So there's a big horse-racing event going on in Australia today, which has become a bit of a cultural event. My boss is super keen on it, so he always badgers me into putting a bet on.

I can never pick a single horse, so Boss suggests I pick four (for some weird horse-racing reason I don't pretend to understand). I notice four horses happen to each have a colour in their name, so I go with those.

Only now of course do I realise I've just found a new way to integrate pretty-coloured horses into my life.
 
G

Gotchaye

Member
FYI that 4th Dimension place's stuffed Twilight turned out pretty well. I didn't look at it too closely - I unboxed it at the post office before repacking it and shipping it overseas - but it seems like a pretty good deal, if you're into that sort of thing. It did take forever to ship, though.
 
$

$200

Banned
Gotchaye said:
FYI that 4th Dimension place's stuffed Twilight turned out pretty well. I didn't look at it too closely - I unboxed it at the post office before repacking it and shipping it overseas - but it seems like a pretty good deal, if you're into that sort of thing. It did take forever to ship, though.
Click to expand...

Still waiting for them to ship out the Pinkie and Twilight I ordered together. That was supposed to happen in September >_>
 
$

$200

Banned
Hitokage said:
It's a Hub promotional pic! Don't look!

You'll find out that Luna can use MAGIC.
Click to expand...

I don't mind them personally but I know some do...the Hub tends to leak way too much for the bigger episodes anyway. Last season finale we pretty much knew everything that was going to happen before the episode airs.
 
N

Narag

Member
Huh, I'd been avoiding this thread due to people posting open spoilers last time I visited and I find myself not really wanting to visit again if it's still policy. Might just unsub since people can't be bothered to preserve the first time experience of a viewer because of some race to be first to post images. Oh well.
 
P

PaulloDEC

Member
Owlowiscious said:
Bullying is fun and easy!
Click to expand...

I have no idea what this is a reference to, but that Fluttershy/Snake picture is pretty adorable.

Narag said:
Huh, I'd been avoiding this thread due to people posting open spoilers last time I visited and I find myself not really wanting to visit again if it's still policy. Might just unsub since people can't be bothered to preserve the first time experience of a viewer because of some race to be first to post images. Oh well.
Click to expand...

If you've seen any of the last few pages, people are being pretty spoiler-conscious. The above picture of Celestia and Luna doesn't really show anything noteworthy, which I imagine is why no-one is making a fuss about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

What actually happened to Warren Ellis?
14
2K
CGNoire replied
To bestselling gaming franchises, what are voice actors worth?
5
1K
Kdad replied
Horizon Forbidden West: An authentic world
News 2 3
111
17K
GymWolf replied
What went wrong with Aaron Carter? -An investigation.
2 3
110
23K
DeafTourette replied
Equestria Girls (My Little Pony spinoff) 45-episode web series announced
7
4K
SigmasonicX replied
Top Bottom