In all honesty was what Hinkie did actually that impressive? He tanked and took the obvious best value in the draft each time. He never really made a team, just a collection of assets. I get that he was fired before the job was done but still.
Sixers before Hinkie
Spencer Hawes
Thad Young
Evan Turner
Jrue Holiday
Nick Young
Lavoy Allen
Jason Richardson
Arnet Moultrie
Kwame Brown
And a whole slew of other really bad players. The Sixers literally had a roster of all backup players on their team, while owing their future 1sts to other teams. Our team was essentially the Nets
Sam Hinkie took the franchise from being one of the bleakest futures in the league to one of the best in 3 years. Remember, we have draft swap rights with the Kings this year, and are still owed the Lakers 1st round pick that's top 3 protected (although, the Lakers are revving up their tank engines right now. They now have a worse record then the Sixers and are 4th in the league)
The nets are in a really similar situation to what the Sixers were in. If you could tell the fans of that franchise that it would only take 3 years to leave that situation, I think they'd take it every day.
Next, he was a masterful trader. His MCW for the Lakers pick is an incredible trade. MCW is literally worthless right now. His take on the salaries of Carl Landry for Nik Stauskas, draft pick swap rights, and a 2019 unprotected 1st was also an incredible trade.
Robert Covington is a top defensive wing in the league right now. While his shooting has been bad this year, his shooting has always been fairly good. TJ McConnel is a surprising young point guard who plays great defense and is a great team leader.
Jerami Grant has been a fairly good success in Oklahoma this year. Dude looks to be a really nice role player.
Nik Stauskas has turned into a somewhat reliable NBA player and has become a decent defensive player.
Those are 4 really good role players all got for basically nothing
On his drafting:
Nerlens Noel is a premier defensive center in the league who will flourish in basically any small ball system. Great PnR player, good enough on defense to guard wings on switches. His offense has also dramatically improved
Michael Carter Williams was the 12th pick in a draft that ended up being really bad for early picks. Some will crucify him for not drafting Gianni's (BTW Gianni's was slow and only 6'9" before the draft, that's why he went so late). This pick was a major success as it netted us the Lakers future pick.
Joel Embiid, do I have to say anything else
Dario Saric, he's had his ups and downs this year Luke any rookie, but he's probably 2nd in ROTY this year. Great effort and great locker room player. Also, shows a knack for making clutch plays.
Jahlil Okafor. Let's assume this was Hinkies pick. (There are rumors online that ownership forced him to take Okafor and that KP was his guy, not assumed unless anything else comes out that verifies it) Jahlil will always be hated in Philly because he's the guy that got Hinkie fired. Okafor will either come to dominate in European Leagues, or he'll learn how to play mediocre to good defense. I really like Okafor and think he can flourish elsewhere. But he got a really bad situation.
We all know Hinkie would've taken Simmons, just like any other sane human being would.
And you wanna know something. Yeah, while the national media hated it, basically every sixers fan I've talked to was fine with the process. Nobody cared about the Sixers with Doug Collins. People were fine with ignoring them for another 3 years, because at the end of the day, they were already being ignored.
Also, it was kind of fun being horrendous for 3 years instead of being mediocre for 10. Ask any diehard Lakers fan right now on this forum if they are horrendously upset about tanking. I'd imagine none of them really are all that mad. It's how you win in Basketball, it's legitimately the best long term solution possible for teams. Hinkie was the most efficient tanker the game has ever seen.