sca2511 said:
so guys, Madcatz standard fightstick or HRAP3? is the 30 dollar difference justified?
It would be a plus to play some BC on my PS3 and a big plus if there is easy modding for a noob like me.
drohne said:
i haven't tried the madcatz stick, but the difference should only be $20, and that certainly seems worth it for a sanwa stick and a more solid base. and afaik the madcatz stick won't work with ps2 games via bc at the moment, though hopefully that'll be corrected in firmware
On Amazon, it's currently $30 difference. $100 for HRAP3 and $70 for PS3 FightStick. However, the 360 FightStick is $80, so if he was getting the 360 stick, it would, indeed, be $20 difference.
sca2511, too bad you didn't get the HRAP3, earlier, if you wanted one. Amazon had it for only $90, just last week.
If PS2 BC is a major factor in your purchasing decision, one can only honestly recommend the HRAP3 over the FightStick, since there is no guarantee Sony will release a future firmware, adding PS2 BC support to the MadCatz sticks.
If you were planning to fully modify either stick to full Sanwa parts, you'd also need to purchase a Sanwa stick for the FightStick. The Sanwa JLF joystick is listed for $24.95 on Lizardlick, although it's currently out-of-stock. The HRAP3 already comes with a Sanwa stick. Both arcade sticks utilize quick-disconnect buttons, so should be equally difficult/easy to replace the buttons. You would need to take the additional step of installing the Sanwa JLF stick in the FightStick.
Fully Sanwa-fitted, the HRAP3 would be about the same price as the FightStick, but the HRAP3 has guaranteed PS2 BC. The other physical differences are personal preference.
If you plan on leaving either stick stock, then the difference in price (currently $30 on Amazon) gets you the HRAP3 body, with Sanwa JLF stick and PS2 BC on PS3.
Hope that helps! =)
-Mikey- said:
So I'm looking into getting an HRAP2:SA.
Thing is I know I'll need to pick up an adapter of some sort but after doing some research I don't know which would be the best to pick up.
The TAC Universal Converter seems like it would get the job done but I don't know how bad the lag would be. I'll mainly be playing SF IV so dunno for sure how bad it would really be while playing, would it be enough to notice and maybe hurt the experience?
Guess the Pelican converters are up next but they've been discontinued and I can't even find one on ebay. Lastly there is the REAL converter that I saw markman reviewed. Again, discontinued.
Sucks jumping into the arcade stick / fighting game scene a little too late being ready to go with everything out of stock or discontinued.
I've actually been researching that, too.
Check out this thread:
http://forums.shoryuken.com/showthread.php?t=132493
The first one listed, the inPin, is supposed to be really good. MarkMan actually has a review on sdtekken.
http://sdtekken.com/tech-area/converters/inpin-play-converter/inpin-play-converter-review/
Apparently, the only way to order it, is by contacting one of the members, Laugh, on SRK. It's said to be one of the better converters, at a decent price, that's not so hard to get, assuming you go through the right channels...