• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NFL 2014 Week 14 |OT| Best In The World

M

MechDX

Member
wienke said:
^He better win the MVP


!
Click to expand...

Another way to look at it, which is the way I tend to do, is that if anybody but Watt wins the league’s Most Valuable Player award this season, the NFL might as well do away with the damned thing. Because as impressive as Rodgers is this season (a 66.3% completion rate for 3,325 yards, 32 touchdowns and three interceptions), what Watt is accomplishing has literally never been seen before. Not at any level of football
Click to expand...

No.

10847863_1012124542153342_8366435545910427669_n.jpg
 
E

eznark

Banned
MechDX said:
No.

https://scontent-a-atl.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xpa1/v/t1.0-9/10847863_1012124542153342_8366435545910427669_n.jpg?oh=654328bcac77acf16422a9a0e28387d0&oe=54FE8DB9[/img[/QUOTE]

That's the same guy who said Ryan Mallett was going to be a super star right?
Click to expand...
 
T

The_Darkest_Red

Member
Take away Rodgers, Packers lose ~8 more games and miss the playoffs.

Take away Watt, Texans lose ~2 more games and miss the playoffs just like they will with him.

Rodgers = MVP
 
T

Tom Penny

Member
I'd love to see Rodgers on Houston and Put Fitz and Watt on the Packers just to kill the notion that a defensive player has the same impact as the best QB in the league. It's laughable and I don't care what math geek is coming up with stats. The math would be in the win totals.
 
M

MechDX

Member
The_Darkest_Red said:
Take away Rodgers, Packers lose ~8 more games and miss the playoffs.

Take away Watt, Texans lose ~2 more games and miss the playoffs just like they will with him.

Rodgers = MVP
Click to expand...

Watt is doing things on defense no one has done in years, if ever, in the league. How much difference is what Rodgers is doing to what Peyton did just last year? That is not discrediting Rodgers at all, he is the best QB in the league, but Watt is rewriting what a defensive player can do in an era where you can no longer play defense like in the past.

The same way Rodgers is basically "the offense" in GB Watt is "the defense" in Houston. This is not about team wins and losses it is about awarding the best single player on an individual team in the league.
 
T

The_Darkest_Red

Member
MechDX said:
Watt is doing things on defense no one has done in years, if ever, in the league. How much difference is what Rodgers is doing to what Peyton did just last year? That is not discrediting Rodgers at all, he is the best QB in the league, but Watt is rewriting what a defensive player can do in an era where you can no longer play defense like in the past.
Click to expand...
The point of the NFL is winning games and winning the SB, right? Rodgers is more important to his team in that regard than Watt. I realize that means a DE will probably never be able to win MVP but that's the nature of a QB driven league.

It's all based on what you think MVP is. To me "value" in a player is based on how they affect wins and losses. Obviously the QB will almost always have the biggest impact in that regard, but I'm okay with that.
 
Y

yankeehater

Member
MechDX said:
Watt is doing things on defense no one has done in years, if ever, in the league. How much difference is what Rodgers is doing to what Peyton did just last year? That is not discrediting Rodgers at all, he is the best QB in the league, but Watt is rewriting what a defensive player can do in an era where you can no longer play defense like in the past.

The same way Rodgers is basically "the offense" in GB Watt is "the defense" in Houston. This is not about team wins and losses it is about awarding the best single player on an individual team in the league.
Click to expand...

None of that makes Watt the most valuable player. The Texans are a bad team with him, and would be a bad team without him. Packers are the best team in football with Rodgers, and would be a bad team without him. There is no way that Watt deserves MVP over Rodgers.
 
B

brentech

Member
Dutch Patriot said:
What's your PSN ? I wanna play Fifa too!
Click to expand...
Same ID on PSN
The_Darkest_Red said:
Take away Rodgers, Packers lose ~8 more games and miss the playoffs.

Take away Watt, Texans lose ~2 more games and miss the playoffs just like they will with him.

Rodgers = MVP
Click to expand...
Exactly what I was thinking while reading the last page.

MechDX said:
Watt is doing things on defense no one has done in years, if ever, in the league. How much difference is what Rodgers is doing to what Peyton did just last year? That is not discrediting Rodgers at all, he is the best QB in the league, but Watt is rewriting what a defensive player can do in an era where you can no longer play defense like in the past.
Click to expand...
No one is taking away what Watt is doing as absolutely amazing. But I think you misunderstand what MOST VALUABLE PLAYER actually means. What Watt has done compared to other defensive players doesn't change what the entire concept of the award is.
 
M

MechDX

Member
The_Darkest_Red said:
The point of the NFL is winning games and winning the SB, right? Rodgers is more important to his team in that regard than Watt. I realize that means a DE will probably never be able to win MVP but that's the nature of a QB driven league.

It's all based on what you think MVP is. To me "value" in a player is based on how they affect wins and losses. Obviously the QB will almost always have the biggest impact in that regard, but I'm okay with that.
Click to expand...

Then rename it "The Most Valuable QB in the League" award. That is not what an MVP is.
 
T

Tom Penny

Member
MechDX said:
Watt is doing things on defense no one has done in years, if ever, in the league. How much difference is what Rodgers is doing to what Peyton did just last year? That is not discrediting Rodgers at all, he is the best QB in the league, but Watt is rewriting what a defensive player can do in an era where you can no longer play defense like in the past.

The same way Rodgers is basically "the offense" in GB Watt is "the defense" in Houston. This is not about team wins and losses it is about awarding the best single player on an individual team in the league.
Click to expand...

Weird how Michael Jordon never won 10 MVP's in a row..
 
E

eznark

Banned
JJ Watt is on the 10th best scoring defense in the league. I agree with Mech though we need to stop giving it to a QB. So give it to the best defensive player on one of the 9 defenses better than the garbage ass Texans.

LJ, which Bill should we give the MVP to?
 
B

brentech

Member
I think mech believed we're all slighting Watt in some way, but he literally is misinterpreting what MVP stands for. Maybe he didn't see what happened when Rodgers missed extended time last year.
maybe he is just gagging on his JJ Watt figurine, but he clearly is losing oxygen to his head and can't comprehend basic wording.

This isn't the heisman trophy, which Watt would have a much greater chance at winning. Won't even be mad if he wins the MVP. I just don't THINK he will. On the basis of what the award is given for.
 
B

BigAT

Member
The_Darkest_Red said:
The point of the NFL is winning games and winning the SB, right? Rodgers is more important to his team in that regard than Watt. I realize that means a DE will probably never be able to win MVP but that's the nature of a QB driven league.

It's all based on what you think MVP is. To me "value" in a player is based on how they affect wins and losses. Obviously the QB will almost always have the biggest impact in that regard, but I'm okay with that.
Click to expand...

Texans fans have had to redefine value to not include silly things like wins, Super Bowls, success, etc.
 
D

Dutch Gronk

Banned
eznark said:
JJ Watt is on the 10th best scoring defense in the league. I agree with Mech though we need to stop giving it to a QB. So give it to the best defensive player on one of the 9 defenses better than the garbage ass Texans.

LJ, which Bill should we give the MVP to?
Click to expand...

Would be perfect if Mario Willams won it
 
D

Dutch Gronk

Banned
If we had an all-time fantasy draft. Who would you guys take? (After the obvious number 1 Tom Brady of course)

Montana? Barry Sanders? Rice? Vrabel? Moss?
 
R

Respect

Member
ActStriker said:
Dobson to IR

shocker
Click to expand...

Disappointing, but he seems to always have some nagging injury in addition to the fact he fell out of favor with the coaching staff anyway. Another wasted pick on a receiver by NE. Hopefully he took the injury bug from Gronk.

The Dobson/Thompkins era has now completely ended in NE.../moment of silence
 
M

MechDX

Member
I hope you people are enjoying the Texans farm system!

Barwin, Williams, Glover Quinn, Jacoby jones
Fuck him!
, 1/3 of the Eagles roster, Schaub
lol. We got a 6th round pick!
, Forsett, etc....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

NFL SUPER Wildcard Weekend |OT| The most super of wildcards, folks
2
70
4K
West Texas CEO replied
  • Poll
2021 NFL Season | OT | "Some of those blokes are giving 110, 120%"
|OT| Social News 27 28 29 30 31
2K
75K
Smiggs replied
NFL 2017 Week 7 |OT| Kraft Money Rules Everything Around Me
40 41 42 43 44
2K
125K
WizardofPeace replied
NFL 2016 Week 11 |OT| - football
93 94 95 96 97
5K
180K
Greg replied
NFL 2017 Week 6 |OT| Fulfill Your Destiny
104 105 106 107 108
5K
223K
gutshot replied
Top Bottom