• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NFL 2017 Week 2 |OT| The Dawn of a New Era

Status
Not open for further replies.

darkside31337

Tomodachi wa Mahou
His left foot never touched out. It technically wasn't a catch until his right knee hit down in the end zone, at which point the play was over.

His 2nd foot was never in bounds. It kicked the pylon as hes dragging it. The pylon is considered in bounds for the sake of the ball crossing the plane but its still technically an object that is located out of bounds. If his foot literally kicks the pylon down... it wasnt in bounds.

His foot never landed out of bounds. The pylon doesn't count as out of bounds and looks like it actually assisted him in staying in bounds.

Yeah I guess this is probably it.
 
His 2nd foot was never in bounds. It kicked the pylon as hes dragging it. The pylon is considered in bounds for the sake of the ball crossing the plane but its still technically an object that is located out of bounds. If his foot literally kicks the pylon down... it wasnt in bounds.
right knee

Remember Madden, one knee == two feet

Also, the pylon is in bounds. No, you're right.
 
His 2nd foot was never in bounds. It kicked the pylon as hes dragging it. The pylon is considered in bounds for the sake of the ball crossing the plane but its still technically an object that is located out of bounds. If his foot literally kicks the pylon down... it wasnt in bounds.

Thanks to the stupidity of the rulebook, you are incorrect.
 
@IanKenyonNFL
GB pts allowed last 9 road games:

2017
ATL - 34 (ongoing)

2016:
ATL - 44
DAL - 31
DET - 24
CHI - 27
PHI - 13
WAS - 42
TEN - 47
ATL - 33
 

darkside31337

Tomodachi wa Mahou
right knee

Remember Madden, one knee == two feet

Also, the pylon is in bounds.

Its technically out of bounds in regards to the actual physical object. Seeing that last replay, yeah if the pylon isn't there hes ruled out of bounds because his foot hits white chalk instead of the pylon itself. So the pylon helped him make the catch. They got the call right even though its shrug to me.
 
His 2nd foot was never in bounds. It kicked the pylon as hes dragging it. The pylon is considered in bounds for the sake of the ball crossing the plane but its still technically an object that is located out of bounds. If his foot literally kicks the pylon down... it wasnt in bounds.



Yeah I guess this is probably it.
???
 

brentech

Member
His 2nd foot was never in bounds. It kicked the pylon as hes dragging it. The pylon is considered in bounds for the sake of the ball crossing the plane but its still technically an object that is located out of bounds. If his foot literally kicks the pylon down... it wasnt in bounds.
.

The pylon is part of the imaginary plane of the OOB. His foot had to hit the ground. It never did. The pylon only exists for visual aid, not part of the playing field.
 

chuckddd

Fear of a GAF Planet
DJ-brErVoAA0__9.jpg
 
Dom Capers must have some impressive dirt on McCarthy and Thompson. I have no idea how he still has his job
Capers, in fairness, works minor miracles with personnel groupings when injuries hit.

The problem is that the ceiling for his defenses has always been around mid-league since the SB season. Whether that's personnel (not enough superstars, injury luck) or scheme related can be debated, but it is definitely the case that they always make dumb mistakes in crunch time, and always suck at tackling. Those problems seem systemic at this point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom