• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NHL Off-Season 2016 |OT| My prospects are better than yours

DopeyFish

Not bitter, just unsweetened
Man I really hope Zaitsev is as good as advertised, or better, would really help solidify our D corps

Still not entirely confident in our 5/6

Which i guess would be hunwick/valiev/carrick

Hoping we can snag demers in FA
 

zroid

Banned
Still not entirely confident in our 5/6

Which i guess would be hunwick/valiev/carrick

Hoping we can snag demers in FA

My personal NHL depth chart probably goes like this, assuming LH/RH play their natural sides

Rielly-Zaitsev
Gardiner-Corrado
Marincin-Carrick
Hunwick
Percy
Harrington

Left side is fine top to bottom, but right side is still a bunch of question marks. Zaitsev being a solid, say, 2/3 would make things a lot easier to figure out.
 

yyzjohn

Banned
I think it is time for an avatar bet

You do yourself a disservice my man. Comparing the Leafs to the Habs you're either suggesting:

a) the Habs aren't all that much of a team without Price
b) the Leafs are suddenly as good/better than Habs with the new additions.

Yes the Habs had a disaster of a season in large part due to Price's injury. But I for one don't believe the team is total garbage without Price. It was a host of factors that went into their collapse, the biggest being Price going down, but I think the losing snowballed on them, the entire team lost confidence and played well below their ability. They're a better team than they showed, with or without Price. I don't think anyone doubts that the Habs are a legitimate playoff team WITH Price in the lineup.

Now onto the Leafs, no Leafs fan will dispute that the team should be a lot better next season. Hell they were 30th this year so any jump in the standings would be better, but how much better is better? Do you actually believe the Leafs are suddenly a playoff contender with the new guys? I don't. I believe they'll be better, but that being said I see an overall league finish of somewhere between 18th-22nd overall in the standings. So that means out of the playoffs, probably a draft pick in the 12th-10th range or thereabouts. And that's if EVERYTHING goes right for the team. They need to get capable goaltending, the young guys need to play like they did down the stretch last season, Matthews has to show he's a legitimate #1 NHL center. Any one of those things goes wrong and suddenly the Leafs are bottom 5 again.
 

yyzjohn

Banned
Dopey is the most Leafs fan of all Leafs fans

i'm 99% sur he owns a Pogge jersey

It's fine to be optimistic, but at least be realistic about it. The Leafs were in a ton of close games last year due to Babcock's system. So improved talent this season + capable goaltending and you could see them winning 6-8 more of those games which is 12-16 points more in the standings. That's somewhere in the 81-85 point range...and again that's IF everything goes according to plan. If Bernier (or whatever goalie they have) shits the bed, all bets are off.
 

imBask

Banned
It's fine to be optimistic, but at least be realistic about it. The Leafs were in a ton of close games last year due to Babcock's system. So improved talent this season + capable goaltending and you could see them winning 6-8 more of those games which is 12-16 points more in the standings. That's somewhere in the 81-85 point range...and again that's IF everything goes according to plan. If Bernier (or whatever goalie they have) shits the bed, all bets are off.

I doubt Leafs will finish last again, but then again nothing is impossible with that defense/goalie combo

Lots of work to be done on that team
 

DopeyFish

Not bitter, just unsweetened
It's fine to be optimistic, but at least be realistic about it. The Leafs were in a ton of close games last year due to Babcock's system. So improved talent this season + capable goaltending and you could see them winning 6-8 more of those games which is 12-16 points more in the standings. That's somewhere in the 81-85 point range...and again that's IF everything goes according to plan. If Bernier (or whatever goalie they have) shits the bed, all bets are off.

are you bashing me and agreeing with me at the same time? o_O
 

yyzjohn

Banned
are you bashing me and agreeing with me at the same time? o_O

How is that agreeing with you? You compared the Leafs to the Habs and asked what would be the bigger impact in points. The Habs had a 28 point decline from the previous season to this one. I think it's obvious that they'll be much better this season, maybe not 28 points better but I can easily see them having an 18-20 point jump from 82 points.
 

imBask

Banned
heh, it's just that people who don't watch every Habs game think it was ONLY about Price. This season was a shitshow, it was Murphy's Law in a nutshell

EVERY SINGLE THING that could've went wrong went wrong, everything. Price was ONE of the many things that happened this year
 

Foggy

Member
Stat that feels nice

"Aaron Portzline ‏@Aportzline
Bjorkstrand's fifth GW goal of the playoffs, second in two games. Has four goals in last two games. @monstershockey"

Hopefully they find room on the roster for Ollie next season. Werenski looks fantastic as well but that dumbass extension for Prout might keep Werenski in the AHL for a bit longer. Unless they trade or buy out Tyutin.
 

DopeyFish

Not bitter, just unsweetened
How is that agreeing with you? You compared the Leafs to the Habs and asked what would be the bigger impact in points. The Habs had a 28 point decline from the previous season to this one. I think it's obvious that they'll be much better this season, maybe not 28 points better but I can easily see them having an 18-20 point jump from 82 points.

I was saying this entire time the Leafs would improve and become a bubble team.

81-85 team is on the bubble, fyi. we did have a team make the playoffs this year with 87.

I doubt Leafs will finish last again, but then again nothing is impossible with that defense/goalie combo

Lots of work to be done on that team

Defense isn't a major issue. It's an issue but it's one that doesn't require major work. Good thing is... if our team sucks again, we can focus on defense!

goaltending, though? halp
 

imBask

Banned
Defense isn't a major issue. It's an issue but it's one that doesn't require major work. Good thing is... if our team sucks again, we can focus on defense!

goaltending, though? halp

agree to disagree, Defense IS a major issue

and focusing on defense is the plan, but i'm sure it was the plan in Edmonton at some point too, it's a slippery slope
 

DopeyFish

Not bitter, just unsweetened
agree to disagree, Defense IS a major issue

and focusing on defense is the plan, but i'm sure it was the plan in Edmonton at some point too, it's a slippery slope

I'm not saying defense isn't a major issue, i'm saying it's not a major issue for us at the moment.

We have 3 solid D right now and we're hopeful for a 4th.

My expectation is most of our picks after Matthews will be D and G.

Leafs will be active on trade and UFA front... though I feel best course is to push very hard for Demers.

Leafs D is still in way better shape than the Oilers allowed theirs to deteriorate into. At this point it's a major and a minor piece away from being a very good corps.
 

calder

Member
RDS reporting only Las Vegas expansion, expansion draft before entry draft next season

lol

That would be what most ppl would have as the most likely outcome going in, easy to imagine it's true.

I just want some clarity so we can all start doing our roster predictions and see what trades are going to happen this summer.
 

yyzjohn

Banned
Love all the Leafs haters thinking the team will never improve. While I'm not as optimistic as the Dope-meister, I think this management team has the plan on the right track. This team will be a legitimate playoff threat in 2-3 years.
 

Line_HTX

Member
From the Winter 2014 promo poster to Feb. 2017....

This better be well worth the wait because Atlus is pissing me off.

That and a little something called a patch that never came for Arena Ultimax to bring it to 2.0.



FUCK!!
 

Yawnier

Banned
I'm waiting on the thread where someone says that 2017 is looking stacked for games.

Then half the games next year will probably get delayed to 2018, and someone will make a thread on 2018 being stacked like a year from now.

The circle of life~~~~
 

Line_HTX

Member
I'm guessing they're trying to get the right people together for the localization, but whatever, fuck Sega anyways.

I want Haru Okumura already.
 
I'm waiting on the thread where someone says that 2017 is looking stacked for games.

Then half the games next year will probably get delayed to 2018, and someone will make a thread on 2018 being stacked like a year from now.

The circle of life~~~~

Well I am actually worried about Persona 5. I want to love it when it comes out and I hope I do.. but all this is not making me feel good about it. There has to have been some development troubles behind the scenes either creatively or technically.
 

zroid

Banned
I think Dopey is correct in the sense that the Leafs D corps is probably underrated right now. The league-worst goaltending they received last season made them look a lot worse than they were. By xGA they ranked 13th at 5v5 in the league. Note that's with Matt Hunwick playing top pair minutes for much of the season, which probably hopefully won't continue next season. I don't think they have anywhere near the 13th best D personnel, but Babcock's defensive system is strong.

That's not to say their D is the 13th best, as xG isn't a perfect evaluation tool, BUT it's safe to say it's pretty close to middle of the pack, which is a good starting point.
 

DopeyFish

Not bitter, just unsweetened
They also had Phaneuf until February

I somehow purged him out of memory so quickly I somehow convinced myself they traded him before the season started
 

Kuro Madoushi

Unconfirmed Member
I think Dopey is correct in the sense that the Leafs D corps is probably underrated right now. The league-worst goaltending they received last season made them look a lot worse than they were. By xGA they ranked 13th at 5v5 in the league. Note that's with Matt Hunwick playing top pair minutes for much of the season, which probably hopefully won't continue next season. I don't think they have anywhere near the 13th best D personnel, but Babcock's defensive system is strong.

That's not to say their D is the 13th best, as xG isn't a perfect evaluation tool, BUT it's safe to say it's pretty close to middle of the pack, which is a good starting point.
I need a chart to visualize this.
 

Red_Man

I Was There! Official L Receiver 2/12/2016
You do yourself a disservice my man. Comparing the Leafs to the Habs you're either suggesting:

a) the Habs aren't all that much of a team without Price
b) the Leafs are suddenly as good/better than Habs with the new additions.

Yes the Habs had a disaster of a season in large part due to Price's injury. But I for one don't believe the team is total garbage without Price. It was a host of factors that went into their collapse, the biggest being Price going down, but I think the losing snowballed on them, the entire team lost confidence and played well below their ability. They're a better team than they showed, with or without Price. I don't think anyone doubts that the Habs are a legitimate playoff team WITH Price in the lineup.
Weird reading someone who gets it, and a Leafs fan of all people.

We have the best goalie in the world, a top 2 D man, a 30 goal scoring centre who's 21 and a top 3 goal scorer in the league over the past 4 years as this teams core. Give them a competent PP and goaltending that isn't the league worst for half the season and this team will contend for top spot in the East next season.

Xcom 2 coming to consoles makes me happy.
Really? That's awesome, I loved the first on my iPad but don't have a good enough computer to play the second.

Love all the Leafs haters thinking the team will never improve. While I'm not as optimistic as the Dope-meister, I think this management team has the plan on the right track. This team will be a legitimate playoff threat in 2-3 years.
I think the Leafs are in better shape for the future than probably any other Canadian team, but assuming they'll be suddenly in the fight for a playoff spot next season is reaching.
 

Cake Boss

Banned
Leafs will be better than 30th (Vancouver or Lumbus got that locked down) but they are not suddenly a playoff team like Dopey is saying. The organizational goalie and defense depth needs improvement, I think most sane leaf fans can agree with that.
 
Leafs will be better than 30th (Vancouver or Lumbus got that locked down) but they are not suddenly a playoff team like Dopey is saying. The organizational goalie and defense depth needs improvement, I think most sane leaf fans can agree with that.

If they do it'll be in the vein of a Colorado "everything lines up for one year, then they're right back to where they should be"
 

DopeyFish

Not bitter, just unsweetened
second I think the Leafs are in better shape for the future than probably any other Canadian team, but assuming they'll be suddenly in the fight for a playoff spot next season is reaching.

So avatar bet me, then.

Also, where did I say they'd be a playoff team? I said they'd be out of bottom 10.
 
Top Bottom