-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Nintendo Is Now Going After YouTube Accounts Which Show Its Games Being Emulated
- Thread starter IbizaPocholo
- Start date
- Social Drama Game Dev
Mhmmm 2077
Member
I always wanted to get into streaming or such, seems like it's the right time, I'm not afraid of lawless DMCA threats.
Buggy Loop
Member
Soon enough..
Icymanipulator
Member
And people will still just blindly support them.
This is the video game equivalent of the physically abusive relationship, “but he loves me! He doesn’t mean it!”
This is the video game equivalent of the physically abusive relationship, “but he loves me! He doesn’t mean it!”
Roman Empire
Member
Love their games, hate the company. That's my relationship with Nintendo.
Last edited:
PaintTinJr
Member
I very much doubt that would hold in the UK or the EU, and I very much doubt Nintendo come for any UK or EU people doing emulation legally because the lawyer bully boy tactics deployed elsewhere can't work in these regions.
It is one argument with two people in UK/EU law, even if one party needs fully supported by legal aid.
As Lucas films found out, suing a prop manufacturer from the original SW film their massive legal team and money meant nothing in UK law to let the prop maker defend his right to sell the prop moulds he made for making the props because Lucas films only originally contracted to buy the props, and so the work product of the moulds and designs to make the props belonged to the prop maker.
Musashipan
Member
Good job Nintendo
BacklashWave534
Member
Oh no.. not the poor you tubers who leech off other people's creations constantly .. not those poor souls.
Oh no, not a corporate bootlicker who thinks a mult billion dollar corporation cares about them. Absolutlely no excuse for Nintendo's behavior. The don't have a legal leg to stand on in most of these cases but they know that their targets don't have they money to fight them in court. If their CEO had a sac he would try this with a big company. Heck, Apple is allowing emulation now. Why doesn't Nintendo try suing them and see how it goes?!?
Last edited:
tkscz
Member
This is the crap that got Tropical Haze in trouble and started all of this. Nintendo's legal team is ALWAYS looking for something to sue, why would you take that chance and post that?
ZoukGalaxy
Member
That wasn't posted by Ryujinx was it? It would be like suing MS because somebody screenshoted a pirated movie playing on Media Player.
This is the crap that got Tropical Haze in trouble and started all of this. Nintendo's legal team is ALWAYS looking for something to sue, why would you take that chance and post that?
tkscz
Member
Do what I do, I'm a fan of the developers and games. I couldn't care less about their company side and especially their legal team which seems to be on overdrive lately.
It's ammo for them. The one thing they need more than anything is proof/evidence of pirating. This gives them leverage. That said, Nintendo didn't do to Ryujynx what they did to Tropical Haze. The way the Ryujynx devs explained it sound like Nintendo came in with an offer and not a DMCA. They had a choice in the matter and chose to close it down. Nintendo may not have had that much of a legal standing here as they did with Tropical Haze.
RoboFu
One of the green rats
buenoblue
Member
Exactly, so let's not plaster it all over YouTube showing how to play nintendos roms ehIt is legal to sell emulators for money at retail stores.
The history of bleem!
As retro game prices continue to rise and old games become lost to time, emulation is an increasingly popular option fo…www.eurogamer.net
I guess but you would hope that any judge or jury would know that somebody else using it to pirate doesn't mean the creator of said thing can be done for piracy. As much of a legal grey area as it is it would be like charging gun manufacturers for murder because of how somebody used your product/tool.
Walter Matthau
Member
I’m not defending Nintendo, but it’s disingenuous to claim that people are primarily using Switch emulators to play games they’ve legally purchased on stronger hardware or that Nintendo isn’t losing anything because the people pirating would have never bought the games anyway. Of course there are real examples of both, but there’s also plenty of people who would be legitimate customers if they didn’t have these easy to access and well publicized alternatives.
The rom for Tears of the Kingdom was downloaded 1 million times before the game even officially released.
The rom for Tears of the Kingdom was downloaded 1 million times before the game even officially released.
marquimvfs
Member
But that's not the point. Discontinuing a given emulator because people use it for piracy is the same of discontinue a console because people jailbroke it to use downloaded games, at least at the eye of the law. Nintendo doesn't have the right to do that, and that's the main point the people that are defending emulators here are presenting.
Imagine if Microsoft demanded that Apple discontinue BootCamp because people are using it to install pirated copies of Windows in their Macs. I just as ridiculous.
Last edited:
Walter Matthau
Member
Apologies if I didn’t make it clear that I’m not defending Nintendo’s actions. I just find some of the generalizations that people make regarding the piracy itself to be intentionally misleading.
SweetTooth
Gold Member
Dude?
Why 4Tb.. you can preserve entire Nintendo history in less than 0.5TB . Lol
sudolicious
Gold Member
For your information, there was no credible source to that number at the time this claim was made. It was - as you might've guessed it - sensationalist bullshit.
About your broader point: Sure, Nintendo is losing some money. Also I understand Emulators not being in their interest, as a corporation. I'm not Nintendo though, you're not Nintendo. They have no legal or moral standing to interfere with Emulators (emulators!!). Piracy, sure. Leaking, distributing games and whatnot. Go after these guys, or the guys that post the screenshots two weeks prior to release. I understand wanting to go after the "root cause", but that's just not how things work, unless you're some totalitarian megalomanic. You don't ban the internet because there are thing on there you don't like, you go after the things that are an issue.
I'm pissed at Nintendo, yes, but also I'm pissed at a system in which Nintendo gets away with this kind of bullshit. And yes, I can both hate the player, as well as the game. To a much stronger extent I'm irritated at the people who actually defend Nintendo in all of this. It's alright to not know better, to not form a strong enough opinion one way or the other. But don't let Nintendo/Corporations deceive you, because it will only get worse.
Last edited:
MMaRsu
Member
There's more consoles than just Nintendo's.
tusharngf
Member
Got other platforms as well
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
The piracy here is the rom being distributed, NOT the emulator. Duh.
Last edited:
Shane89
Member
It's not the same thing. They are doing a real witch-hunt
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
Not even only the Switch games fits on 500GB. Lol
U n i o n 0015
Member
And TOTK still sold over 18 million copies.
Nintendo still made a buttload of profit.
The reality is that emulation and piracy have a higher technical barrier of entry for 99% of normies that want to the games.
Now that I think about it, are there any examples of any companies actually going out of business because of piracy? Did Metallic stop doing concerts, did Lars Ulrich have to s**k dick on the streets to make a living? Are Nintendo execs putting out 2nd mortgages to put food on the table?
Astray
Member
Lots of dumbassery in this post.You don't know what you're talking about.
Again, get your facts straight before spreading bullshit.
Emulation is a very broad thing, you know?
I can show you several, here you go:
Oh, but you mean gaming only? Here ya go:
Well, you mean RECENT gaming only? Ok, then:
I hope that now you stop spreading bullshit. The use case you're using as an sample isn't anything near the "95%" you told. I'd be surprised if it's anything near 10%. Emulators are used in a daily basis for everything you could imagine, isn't just a gaming thing. If you mean gaming only, you need to specify, but piracy is not the only use case, also it's not near the percentage you talked.
It's extremely, EXTREMELY clear that I'm talking about game emulators that are built by individual or groups of devs to play ROMs and hacked copies of games.
No one here brought up those Genesis or NES nostalgia boxes, or re-release collections (even if those use web-sourced emulators and ROMs, it's not like Sega or Nintendo can't make their own, the original devs were just chumps that did the work for free).
Did anyone in this thread even mention anything bad about compatibility layers for Windows apps on Mac, or any of the shit you posted? (which I resized, because again, you're very enraged and didn't even see fit to resize those screenshots for easy reading).
Your absolute seethe over Nintendo blocking your favored piracy method is abundantly clear in your post.
If you didn't, you wouldn't be searching up countless things that weren't mentioned by anyone to try to "own me".
A bit sketchier than I'd like, but fair enough.
Which is why I said "widespread", you are clearly in the minority here.
My prediction is that PS4 emulator will get ganked too just as soon as they achieve results (just in time to get to keep all the work done for free). And people will mald over it too because the fundamental problem here is that people want to have free shit.
BlackTron
Gold Member
Not spoken from experience I take it.
analog_future
Resident Crybaby
Meanwhile I'm enjoying my legally purchased and dumped copy of Echoes of Wisdom at 4k/60fps/RTX HDR and it's gorgeous:
Is piracy a reason Nintendo is going after emulators? Sure. But it's also because these emulators offer a superior experience to Nintendo's own hardware and Nintendo knows it. They're already making Nintendo's own games look and perform better than what even the Switch 2 will provide.
Is piracy a reason Nintendo is going after emulators? Sure. But it's also because these emulators offer a superior experience to Nintendo's own hardware and Nintendo knows it. They're already making Nintendo's own games look and perform better than what even the Switch 2 will provide.
Musashipan
Member
According to the criminals from this place, this is okay.
ReyBrujo
Member
That was the number Nintendo estimated in his lawsuit against Yuzu, so it wasn't that bullshit.
Nintendo can't do much against emulators themselves, we know that, so they find ways to take them down in various ways. For Yuzu they discovered they were using illegal dumps so they went for DMCA, for Ryujinx they (allegedly) did bribe him into retirement (since apparently they had no weak point). I believe Nintendo is actually more afraid of their accumulated know-how: these teams have vast experience in the Switch hardware and they would have been the ones that could have a Switch 2 emulator running in the shortest span of time (being that 1 or 5 years), so by bullying/bribing them out of the scene they know the next emulator will have to start pretty much from scratch.
But only okay for Nintendo because their hardware doesn't have the power Sony's does lol
Last edited:
I'm fairly sure with the standardized ARM architecture nVidia is likely providing Nintendo, that these emulators would probably be able to emulate Switch 2 games from Day 1 with no modifications whatsoever.
marquimvfs
Member
Likewise, fellow
No, it's not. Everytime someone talks about emulators here is the most generic nonsense like you did in your previous posts. Like I said, emulation is a very widespread thing, and yes, you need to be specific. If you meant to say that "Ryujinx have no real use outside piracy" while questionable, you wouldn't be so far away from reality, but even that is anecdotal.
I bought up. I own the SNES classic (pretty neat thing) and the Mega Man X collection for PS4 and they are the perfect example of a genuine use for emulators, witch you said that weren't useful for anything but piracy.
Now, that's dumbassery, for real.
Yes, you put emulation, in general, in the same jar as yours anecdotal piracy uses.
My bad, in phone it looked just fine, will resize later.
That's not just anecdotal, is a serious accusation. I'm not a pirate, but I admit to have done it in the past. I've never used a Switch emulator to see what's like, I'm just in this kind of thread to help people that hear (reads) shit about emulators see the truth behind all the misinformation spreaded by people like you.
If those kind of blocks starts to be accepted by the law, it will open a very dangerous precedent for evey single legitimate use case for emulators that are not made by the IP owner, and I'm not talking gaming only. See, the very palm emulator that I posted a screenshot is used by Imax Cinemas, given that the motors that move the films are controlled by an ancient palm. Once the device gave up on life, their only solution was to replace everything or use a software that could emulate the palmOS.
You could argue that this is nothing related to gaming emulation, but, in the end, emulation is emulation, it doesn't matter if the device is used for gaming or not. If Nintendo keeps being successful in court, some people in the future could acquire the Palm rights with the intention to use, and send a cease and desist letter to every developer who kept old systems running by this very day.
So, yes, when you talk about "emulators", you need to specify, and when your favourite company targets them, it's dangerous for every legit emulator out there, even the not gaming related ones.
Last edited:
chokotoureiki
Member
A lot of Nintendo fans have battered wife syndrome. Next, Nintendo will go after artists selling Nintendo inspired merch on Etsy and artwork on Deviantart and it will be all their fault.
The point is all of these corporations are out for their own self interest. You're just mad at Nintendo because they're going after people you like.
Trilobit
Gold Member
Meanwhile I'm enjoying my legally purchased and dumped copy of Echoes of Wisdom at 4k/60fps/RTX HDR and it's gorgeous:
Is piracy a reason Nintendo is going after emulators? Sure. But it's also because these emulators offer a superior experience to Nintendo's own hardware and Nintendo knows it. They're already making Nintendo's own games look and perform better than what even the Switch 2 will provide.
As long as you are required to put your BIOS from your purchased Switch into the emulator then it should be dandy in my eyes. It's going to be interesting to see what this means for emulation going forward.
SportsFan581
Member
Seems like a stretch. I guess everyone should just stop discussing Nintendo all together, that would make them so happy.
NeoIkaruGAF
Gold Member
This BS really should stop.
There is absolutely nobody blindly supporting Nintendo when they do this. Literally everyone hates it when Nintendo goes after something like people reviewing Chinese emulation handhelds and showing Nintendo games running on those. I, for one, don't like this one bit.
This still doesn't mean a) it isn't Nintendo's absolute right to do so if they wish, b) one should stop buying Nintendo products they like because of this. Just like releasing one good Astrobot game doesn't cancel the whole Concord catastrophe and a lot of questionable decisions from Sony, Nintendo flexing their legal machine to go after small-time YouTuber enthusiasts doesn't mean everyone should boycott the good products they do make.
And you can bet your ass that if a $50 Chinese handheld comes out and it can run Bloodborne better than a PS4, Sony would go after videos showing that if they had a Bloodborne remaster ready to launch. Some people are too young to remember when Sony went after Lik Sang when the products that company was selling were actually making Sony lose money.