Eolz
Member
Todd Howard seems to be strictly talking of a demonstration on how well/coherent the hardware functions. Not graphics.
This.
Todd Howard seems to be strictly talking of a demonstration on how well/coherent the hardware functions. Not graphics.
So since a lot of people are apparently looking at this thread now and because this is pretty much the Nintendo tech thread, I wanna float this theory that I tried to ask about the other day:
So I remembered a rumor from about a year ago that the NX was running this demo which was apparently impossible to run on anything but a high end PC:
Source
And I remembered that Todd Howard of Bethesda recently said something about a Switch demo that's under NDA:
Source
So, let's say that these two demos are the same thing, a tech demo running on the Switch. I'm not saying that the Switch will somehow get an enormous power boost to put it at high end PC levels, but consider the visuals Nintendo was able to get out of the Wii U, including those tech demos- the Zelda demo, the bird demo...
Now that Nintendo's software sorcerers have access to modern, cutting edge mobile tech, I wonder if they've actually managed to prepare a tech demo which does visually blow away the supposed limitations of the hardware. Something which takes maximum advantage of Tegra's capabilities, like FP16, to produce visuals that would seriously fool people who work in the game industry (like Todd Howard) into thinking the device was far more powerful than it is on paper.
So what do you think? Will we see a ridiculously impressive looking tech demo in January?
So since a lot of people are apparently looking at this thread now and because this is pretty much the Nintendo tech thread, I wanna float this theory that I tried to ask about the other day:
So I remembered a rumor from about a year ago that the NX was running this demo which was apparently impossible to run on anything but a high end PC:
Source
And I remembered that Todd Howard of Bethesda recently said something about a Switch demo that's under NDA:
Source
So, let's say that these two demos are the same thing, a tech demo running on the Switch. I'm not saying that the Switch will somehow get an enormous power boost to put it at high end PC levels, but consider the visuals Nintendo was able to get out of the Wii U, including those tech demos- the Zelda demo, the bird demo...
Now that Nintendo's software sorcerers have access to modern, cutting edge mobile tech, I wonder if they've actually managed to prepare a tech demo which does visually blow away the supposed limitations of the hardware. Something which takes maximum advantage of Tegra's capabilities, like FP16, to produce visuals that would seriously fool people who work in the game industry (like Todd Howard) into thinking the device was far more powerful than it is on paper.
So what do you think? Will we see a ridiculously impressive looking tech demo in January?
Hardware is not the real limit to gaming these days a lack of optimizing is or a shitty api/os that cuts in to performance. This rumor is a good way to expose how the industry utter incompetence on optimizing is costing them these days besides sticking with windows as the main gaming os. There are many ways to crush a demo operating on windows especially if it's not being optimized correctly or worse the OS and machine it is on aren't configured properly.
I've gone after this magic sauce rumor in every form it comes out about. These rumor don't actually say if the say demo would run the same on PS4/PS4pro environment if it still didn't run in that situation at 60fps I would say it was total hardware improvement that nintendo has figured out for themselves.
I do think tech demos are in bound, mainly cause in general nintendo does them every generation. My issue is whether we see a product that matches or exceeds it. Nintendo is hit or miss with differing consistency every generation since they made the n64. The rumor is very old but I can't stress enough to those pimping out this rumor, microsoft types were willing to eat magic sauce rumors we really shouldn't be when there's no clear explanation for things.
Hardware is not the real limit to gaming these days a lack of optimizing is or a shitty api/os that cuts in to performance. This rumor is a good way to expose how the industry utter incompetence on optimizing is costing them these days besides sticking with windows as the main gaming os. There are many ways to crush a demo operating on windows especially if it's not being optimized correctly or worse the OS and machine it is on aren't configured properly.
I've gone after this magic sauce rumor in every form it comes out about. These rumor don't actually say if the say demo would run the same on PS4/PS4pro environment if it still didn't run in that situation at 60fps I would say it was total hardware improvement that nintendo has figured out for themselves.
I do think tech demos are in bound, mainly cause in general nintendo does them every generation. My issue is whether we see a product that matches or exceeds it. Nintendo is hit or miss with differing consistency every generation since they made the n64. The rumor is very old but I can't stress enough to those pimping out this rumor, microsoft types were willing to eat magic sauce rumors we really shouldn't be when there's no clear explanation for things.
Nah he's specifically talking about the hardware, that's why when asked about the Nintendo game he clarified himself. Anything is heavily reading into things that aren't stated.I can remember him hyping up that "radiant AI" and "radiant quests" and all that bullshit but I don't really remember him trying to hype up hardware, or any non-Bethesda product. Still, he could very well be trying to oversell whatever he saw quite a bit.
The fact that he mentioned an NDA makes me think he was talking about a specific demo, not just the hardware. His next quote sorta reinforces that:
It sure seems like he slipped up a bit mentioning this "demo" and then backtracked it to mean he was excited about the device itself. I really doubt he would say "I got to play it" and then say "Probably the best demo I've ever seen. At E3." referring to the hardware itself. People don't really say they "play" on a device and then say it's the best device they've "seen".
Of course that could just be me massively reaching.
Windows isn't really the behemoth it used to be, and modern apis on windows aren't really the fat filled pork barrels they used to be either. Modern console apis are pretty comparable nowadays, in fact, which is why the "coding to the metal" talk has been bunk for a long time now.
If we do see tech demos then they'll be shown right alongside near-final games (given the unusually short time from reveal to launch), so there won't be a whole lot of scope for them to misrepresent the hardware. It's a bit different than the old days of showing tech demos long before any actual games.
Your mention of APIs does actually remind me of something I'd meant to bring up in this thread, which is the rumour about the Dark Souls 3 port. More specifically, I find it quite interesting (and positive regarding APIs/tools/etc) that they've apparently got a port of the game running at "acceptable performance" on Switch before even deciding whether to release it or not. The fact that getting a decent PS4/XBO port running on Switch is such a low investment that a mid-tier developer with a custom engine would do it speculatively bodes well for the ease at which other developers could bring their games over (if they choose to).
I think the Switch, due to some happenstances, is turning out to be a 'perfect tech storm' type of system (not unlike the cube, which, too, had its fair share of luck). We should give credit to several factors:This maybe the first system in a while were media storage and architecture design aren't going to fuck nintendo it maybe the first since snes without it.
Nintendo Switch |OT| The NX Generation
Barely anyone uses DX12 or Vulkan compared to older apis. DX11 doesn't fully utilize your your system. APIS aren't the problem services, bad configuration in the registry, and bloat programs/service hogging IO, interrupts, and cpu cycles are. I'm not talking about coding to the metal. The OS is the problem not the apis trying to manage the fucks up MS refuses to fix.
Windows on this issue is largely the same as it was since I started using XP.
We have have a bird demo and zelda demo that never turned up from WiiU. Just saying as someone who could literally post tons of nintendo tech demos from various generations I would like to see more of those products show up or be matched.
The DS3 and from software rumor is very interesting to me considering that their games are lookers but performance/optimization can be hit and miss on their titles. Very good to news to hear in a few short months they have stuff up, as that almost gamecube like dev times vs any other nintendo console which has had more for devs. This maybe the first system in a while were media storage and architecture design aren't going to fuck nintendo it maybe the first since snes without it.
Well, the N64 (Zelda) and GameCube demos (Zelda and Rebirth) didn't seem out of reach to what we saw those systems could do. I also believe the Wii U Zelda demo is much more tame and constrainted than what BOTW is doing. Idk about the bird demo since I don't know what I can compare it to. That Red Steel game for the Wii has a bull-demo, though. Were there particular demos that you referring to that never match the actual performance of the system?
Anyway, your optimism about the Switch hardware is great. You have been very dissappointed with them in the past, but this system may show some very impressive performance for its form factor.
I think the Switch, due to some happenstances, is turning out to be a 'perfect tech storm' type of system (not unlike the cube, which, too, had its fair share of luck). We should give credit to several factors:
- sub-20nm FF fabnodes becoming viable, after a very prolonged super-20nm period.
- NV SoC hw - generally considered too power hungry for strict HH/mobiles, but can be a great hybrid match, given the platform holder is willing to make the right concessions for HH mode (as in a larger body housing heat dissipation and battery apparata, appropriate downclock when undocked).
- the general advent of ARMv8 - just at the start of this current generation we had Jaguars and 32-bit PPCs as the best console candidates. Today we have ARMs that outclass those former uarchs in every possible way.
- NV's GPU and GPGPU API expertise - people round here might know me as a stern OCL proponent, but NV know how to make the best out of their proprietary APIs. And let's face it - 'proprietary' is a synonym to 'console'. So that's par for the course.
This one is really good.Nintendo Switch |OT| The NX Generation
So since a lot of people are apparently looking at this thread now and because this is pretty much the Nintendo tech thread, I wanna float this theory that I tried to ask about the other day:
So I remembered a rumor from about a year ago that the NX was running this demo which was apparently impossible to run on anything but a high end PC:
Source
And I remembered that Todd Howard of Bethesda recently said something about a Switch demo that's under NDA:
Source
So, let's say that these two demos are the same thing, a tech demo running on the Switch. I'm not saying that the Switch will somehow get an enormous power boost to put it at high end PC levels, but consider the visuals Nintendo was able to get out of the Wii U, including those tech demos- the Zelda demo, the bird demo...
Now that Nintendo's software sorcerers have access to modern, cutting edge mobile tech, I wonder if they've actually managed to prepare a tech demo which does visually blow away the supposed limitations of the hardware. Something which takes maximum advantage of Tegra's capabilities, like FP16, to produce visuals that would seriously fool people who work in the game industry (like Todd Howard) into thinking the device was far more powerful than it is on paper.
So what do you think? Will we see a ridiculously impressive looking tech demo in January?
Uhhh, they do design their own engines right?
3. The rumor that got me in trouble. I'm glad it panned out and that nintendo finally got off powerpc shit. I loved it for the time especially against amd/intel as it could compete but it shouldn't have even been considered in the Wii/WiiU but I think nintendo is really dumb to have gimped those consoles just due to form concerns and nothing else.
4. Can't stress it enough, nintendo and nvidia have stepped up on that front. We are giving nvidia huge credit but nintendo has been making exotic GPU designs literally since flipper. To have probably the two most customizing companies in this area make a system and be happy about it, nvidia wasn't happy about PS3 they did love the NV2a though. Nintendo just letting nvidia do it's thing is one thing but to let them specialize the OS, HLSL, and the API is flipping nuts to me. Unlike incomptent and lazy MS on windows or people using bsd/linux variants that aren't tweaked for gaming this is huge to enthusiast in to that stuff. Total dream territory right here.
I suppose the Switch event on Jan 12th will give us a true glimpse into the power of the system because we will see if it is indeed running current gen only ports which some people seem to think will be impossible.
IIRC Rise of the Tomb Raider runs on a 360 so it's not unthinkable that PS4/Xbone games can be downgraded enough to run on this.
The Nintendo Switch |OT| This one won't leak, we swear it.
The Nintendo Switch |OT| Only the best NDAs, trust me, We've got the best NDAs.
As for the technical side I am interested to see the technology that NERD was working on finally come to bear fruit. They were created(bought) to make software and development more efficient . They already have been showing up more recently. Hopefully whatever they had been working on combined with whatever NV has brought to the table makes for the "sauce" that helps the Switch look more impressive than expected
Hey. What is this about you getting in trouble? Was it the range you gave us? Hope it wasn't serious.These people should be laughed at for not using youtube and typing in current gen games running on much worse.
This thread probably should get locked anyway given the disproven op. We should start a new general tech thread.We have a Switch "discussion" thread, can't you all take the nonsense there and not get the tech thread locked?
These people should be laughed at for not using youtube and typing in current gen games running on much worse.
IIRC Rise of the Tomb Raider runs on a 360 so it's not unthinkable that PS4/Xbone games can be downgraded enough to run on this.
I thought this a heavily modified version made by another team?IIRC Rise of the Tomb Raider runs on a 360 so it's not unthinkable that PS4/Xbone games can be downgraded enough to run on this.
I thought this a heavily modified version made by another team?
Is switch rumored to have an sd card memory expansion slot?
Some people are speculating that vicarious visions is helping Bungie to bring Destiny 2 to switch. But it's just fan speculation.
Have you heard any indication of the power of the GPU, even a ballpark figure like "50% of XB1" for example in raw paper specs ?