Was this posted yet?. A lengthy analysis and discussion from a developer perspective (Paul Kilduff-Taylor, one of the founders of Mode7, who made Frozen Synapse)
https://blog.mode7games.com/promising-the-earth-no-mans-sky-c6227ae3a35d#.g4e3rcqs7
Thanks, hadn't seen that. I always felt the focus of multiplayer by people (even here on GAF, even by some big fans) was overblown and at times entirely unrealistic, believing that somehow Hello was secretly building a Destiny-style MMO on the sly, despite the best attempts of you and I and others to dissuade them from this. I think, after the incident with the Twitch streamers, and Sean's Twitter response, and the data mining and packet sniffing that found no player locations were even being sent, that how Sean handled being "caught red-handed" was far worse than the fact that they dropped the MP component from the game. He needs to be more honest and direct during the bad moments, because those things go much farther with customers than silence or vague statements.
With a game like NMS, we all have our own "multiplayer", our own feature which we felt was crucial to what makes NMS what it was supposed to be. For me, it was star systems just being faked when we were told they'd be at least somewhat realistic representations of real systems. For others, it may be the Faction system, or the diversity of planets, or something else. If they weren't doing free updates, maybe I'd have a different opinion, but right now I'm giving them the benefit of the doubt and trusting that Hello's intentions are in the right place, even if the execution of the vision they conjured in our heads didn't always live up to our expectations.
Really, the only thing I can really hold Hello's feet to the fire over right now is the PS4 pre-order dynamic theme. Because it's straight-up not dynamic, it's a JPEG. That was false advertising and they need to make that right.
Right now you'll have to excuse me, because I just landed on a scorched planet with 2-meter tall carnivorous T-rexes who have a mean streak and are looking a bit snacky.