Support NeoGAF

[LotusHD]

Crew's biggest moment of suffering was the separation.
Nobody knew what was going on and what had happened to the others. Imagine getting separated from your friends and ending up in a strange location with no idea what the fate of the others are, and you couldn't do anything to stop it from happening.

I'm talking about Marineford though. Probably should've clarified, but I dont think it is necessarily fair to bunch up Saobody and Marineford as this one big thing, especially considering both Amazon Lily and Impel Down happen in between that.

I already said that the separation was the biggest singular moment.

 

[Rebel Leader]

I'm on the "Pudding, Carrot and Jimbei for crewmate" train. Imagine the interactions.

Drop pudding and we have a deal.

 

[KuwabaraTheMan]

Drop pudding and we have a deal.

Drop Jinbe instead.

 

[Ray Down]

Drop Jinbe instead.

Drop Carrot instead.

 

[Rebel Leader]

Drop Jinbe instead.

If that means carrot is official ......

Deal.

 

[KuwabaraTheMan]

Drop Carrot instead.

No way. Carrot is awesome.

If that means carrpt is offial......

Deal.

Sold. I'll fax the details over to Oda right now.

 

[ArgyleReptile]

This libel against Sanji and Jinbe must stop!

 

[Lightning_Roller]

Pudding can go to hell. She is nothing but pure evil. Just like newspaper comics.

Spoiler

I swear if you don't get the reference, you guys are dead to me.

 

[Ray Down]

Drop pudding and we have a deal.

Let's drop Sanji and Carrot & call it a deal.

Pudding can go to hell. She is nothing but pure evil. Just like newspaper comics.

Spoiler

I swear if you don't get the reference, you guys are dead to me.

Spoiler

Pretty sure a Spongebob reference.

 

[Rebel Leader]

Pudding can go to hell. She is nothing but pure evil. Just like newspaper comics.

Spoiler

I swear if you don't get the reference, you guys are dead to me.

Ypu been as dead as bomberman for a long time so what makes you think you have the power to say such things?

 

[NSESN]

When Carrot is revealed to be traitor you guys will react just like Sanji

 

[Ray Down]

When Carrot is revealed to be traitor you guys will react just like Sanji

Like this?

 

[Cindi Mayweather]

We're talking about the crew's biggest moments of suffering right? Hence why I'm saying, while the war sucked and all, I wouldn't say it's the worst, assuming that's what is being argued, since that was primarily just Luffy's experience. Stuff like the aforementioned Water 7 arc would rank higher for me in that regard.

I just don't see how the separation isn't the obvious answer here. When their captain saw his brother murdered in his very eyes, they weren't there for him. They knew how low he must have been. And there was nothing they could do.

 

[Veelk]

When Carrot is revealed to be traitor you guys will react just like Sanji

Carrot trying to have the strawhats killed is something that would improve her in my eyes.

 

[Principate]

Luffy loses his crew and watches his brother get murdered while giving up years of his life to save him while being outgunned and outmatched at every turn, WB is murdered like a dog, BB wrecks absolute havok. Water 7 has nothing on Sabaody/Marineford.

It's worse than that, Luffy breaks out the most dangerous criminals in the world including scumbags he helped put in there, leaves his friend (Bon Clay) behind to what seems like to him certain death, sacrifices years of his lifespan and rush through battle with the most powerful forces in the world for the priviledge of watching his brother die in his hands. His mind litterally breaks due to the accumulated stress. WB also get's gangbanged BB rag tag group of people Luffy helped free.

Nothing productive was achieved during the escapade. He would have been litterally better off not bothering if not for the fact he got his shit kicked in so badly he realised he was in no shape remotely to progress on his journey.

 

[KuwabaraTheMan]

I just don't see how the separation isn't the obvious answer here.

I think it's more that the separation was a single event over two chapters. It's probably the single biggest event, but it was also fairly singular. A few chapters after that we were off on Luffy's Amazon Lily story.

The Water Seven stuff was different because it was like 20 straight chapters of things getting progressively worse and worse. Same for this arc right now.

Nothing individually compares to the crew getting separated, but as far as the most prolonged instances of suffering for the characters, they come out ahead.

 

[Rebel Leader]

Let's drop Sanji and Carrot & call it a deal.

Sanji sure but
Since this involves dropping carrot
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zjB0nQT3PJQ

 

[Imperial Bishop]

When Carrot is revealed to be traitor you guys will react just like Sanji

If it kills the "Carrot for nakama" brigade, then great!

 

[Lightning_Roller]

Ypu been as dead as bomberman for a long time so what makes you think you have the power to say such things?

Hmm good point.

Spoiler

Note to self, watch out for Rebel Leader.

 

[Ray Down]

If it kills the "Carrot for nakama" brigade, then great!

Yes Imperial Bishop is on the right side.

 

[Rebel Leader]

Fpr those whp don't want carrot as crew then i will appoint zoro as navigator! !!!!!!!

 

[Veelk]

Ace: … do you think… I should have really been born?
Pudding: No. Also, you were in the womb for like 2, you should have been stillborn or atleast have some major defects.

*Luffy makes his stupid agony face when Ace dies*
*Pudding grabs Ace's fallen anal beads off the ground and plays a game tossing them in Luffy's open mouth*

*at the Whitebeard and Ace Grave scene where everyone is mourning*
Pudding: They were nazi's, you know. Had swastikas on their back and everything.

 

[LotusHD]

It's worse than that, Luffy breaks out the most dangerous criminals in the world including scumbags he helped put in there, leaves his friend (Bon Clay) behind to what seems like to him certain death, sacrifices years of his lifespan and rush through battle with the most powerful forces in the world for the priviledge of watching his brother die in his hands. His mind litterally breaks due to the accumulated stress. WB also get's gangbanged BB rag tag group of people Luffy helped free.

Nothing productive was achieved during the escapade. He would have been litterally better off not bothering if not for the fact he got his shit kicked in so badly he realised he was in no shape remotely to progress on his journey.

Incorrect. Luffy taught Hancock how to love again. ;D

Jinbe was freed. ;D

Buggy and Crocodile was freed. ;D (YMMV)

 

[Cindi Mayweather]

I think it's more that the separation was a single event over two chapters. It's probably the single biggest event, but it was also fairly singular. A few chapters after that we were off on Luffy's Amazon Lily story.

The Water Seven stuff was different because it was like 20 straight chapters of things getting progressively worse and worse. Same for this arc right now.

Nothing individually compares to the crew getting separated, but as far as the most prolonged instances of suffering for the characters, they come out ahead.

Sure enough, but the crew always comes out ahead in the end, don't they?

 

[smurfx]

pudding is going to kill carrot and make a carrot cake for sanji to apologize to him. wonder what kind of face he will make when he finds out.

 

[Rebel Leader]

pudding is going to kill carrot and make a carrot cake for sanji to apologize to him. wonder what kind of face he will make when he finds out.

That will not happen.

 

[Ray Down]

pudding is going to kill carrot and make a carrot cake for sanji to apologize to him. wonder what kind of face he will make when he finds out.

 

[KuwabaraTheMan]

pudding is going to kill carrot and make a carrot cake for sanji to apologize to him. wonder what kind of face he will make when he finds out.

I'm pretty sure Carrot is immortal.

 

[Rebel Leader]

I'm pretty sure Carrot is immortal.

Carrot took luffy out.

Pudding would be like swatting a frozen fly

 

[Veelk]

Carrot took luffy out.

Pudding would be like swatting a frozen fly

Yet can't handle Brulee.

 

[Rebel Leader]

Yet can't handle Brulee.

She took Brulee out with ease

 

[NSESN]

She took Brulee out with ease

Chopper plan did it
Carrot is too dumb to beat a bad guy

Spoiler

or at least she pretends to be dumb

 

[Genryu]

I feel like I'm one of the few people that actually DOESN'T like Villain Pudding.

 

[Rebel Leader]

Chopper plan did it
Carrot is too dumb to beat a bad guy

Spoiler

or at least she pretends to be dumb

Plans don't beat people


People beat people and carrot beat her

 

[Veelk]

She took Brulee out with ease

What? Am I remembering it wrong, but iirc, Brulee just deflected her shit with her mirror powers and then trapped her in the wonderland world.

 

[KuwabaraTheMan]

I feel like I'm one of the few people that actually DOESN'T like Villain Pudding.

Probably.

She's fantastic.

 

[Rebel Leader]

What? Am I remembering it wrong, but iirc, Brulee just deflected her shit with her mirror powers and then trapped her in the wonderland world.

See? Perfect strawhat materal.

Gets caught and beats captor!

 

[Grexeno]

Still think Evil Pudding is an act.

 

[KuwabaraTheMan]

Still think Evil Pudding is an act.

For who? She erased Reiju's memory of the whole thing, and she had no clue Sanji was outside.

 

[Rebel Leader]

Still think Evil Pudding is an act.

Areosmith dream on songbis perfect for you

 

[Grexeno]

For who? She erased Reiju's memory of the whole thing, and she had no clue Sanji was outside.

Or did she.

 

[Rebel Leader]

Or did she.

No. She didn't.

 

[Ray Down]

Or did she.

 

[Veelk]

For who? She erased Reiju's memory of the whole thing, and she had no clue Sanji was outside.

Unless she did know, told the guard so that Sanji would go around back and spy on her and is playing 99th dimensional superchess

 

[NSESN]

I feel like I'm one of the few people that actually DOESN'T like Villain Pudding.

I am with you. But what we can do

 

[Ray Down]

I am with you. But what we can do

You can try and hold the flag of Pudding is good.

 

[Rebel Leader]

You can try and hold the flag of Pudding is good.

Pudding is both shit food and character

 

[Cindi Mayweather]

When did Carrot take Luffy out? I thought she cut him?

 

[Rebel Leader]

When did Carrot take Luffy out? I thought she cut him?

She bit his neck when he started eating her food on the ship

 

[RalchAC]

For who? She erased Reiju's memory of the whole thing, and she had no clue Sanji was outside.

She may not be helping her mother, she may want to scape, but that doesn't turn her into a good person. She may just be a sadistic person that loves to be in the spotlight and see other people's reactions. That kind of personality would suit her fruit, TBH.

And she doesn't give a crap about Sanji. That's for sure.

Unless she did know, told the guard so that Sanji would go around back and spy on her and is playing 99th dimensional superchess

Or she has observation Haki, knows that Sanji is there but doesn't care.