I repeat, this is the one
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
One Piece Manga |OT2| Four Emperors, One King, All Blue
- Thread starter Cloud Strife
- Start date
- Status
I repeat, this is the one
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Yesh.
I'm sorry, but that one is just perfect. The Charlotte Family is fucking with everybody, not just Sanji, after all.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Silence traitor
KuwabaraTheMan
Banned
I think the dish best served cold is the better choice, but the "Charlotte family sends their regards" works as a secondary option.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
AkaWe need the Gorosei of the thread to decided.
Going by most posts.
Young one: Me
Beard and Stache combo: Blackleg
Liver Spots guy: Veelk
Sword Guy: Cloud Strife
Cane guy: Ganzlinger
the puppets of the Celestial dragons
NOTHING PROVEN YET!
I remember those times, I guess people were kinda right.
We need the Gorosei of the thread to decided.
Going by most posts.
Young one: Me
Beard and Stache combo: Blackleg
Liver Spots guy: Veelk
Sword Guy: Cloud Strife
Cane guy: Ganzlinger
Blackleg should be the young one, since he was speculated to be a Vinsmoke before.
I'd rather take the Beard and Stache combo or sword guy.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Cindi Mayweather
Member
I hope not!
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
You guys want 3 new straw hats at once? Isn't that a little overkill? Jinbe is basically confirmed, but two more would be a little too much.
By the way:
Those avatars kind of tell a story, don't they?
Lmao I only just now caught this
"The Charlottes send their regards" still works long-term. Regardless of how this ends, Luffy and co. certainly can't say it's been a pleasure meeting them.
Stop fighting this
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
"The Charlottes send their regards" still works long-term. Regardless of how this ends, Luffy and co. certainly can't say it's been a pleasure meeting them.
Stop fighting this
D's never learn to stop a fight!
You guys are gonna be so disappointed not naming it after Pudding when she stays on the ship
I hope it's a sinking ship.
Blackleg-sanji1
Banned
Lol I'm of the mindset he should never do that so meh
But she can't swim...
Blackleg-sanji1
Banned
Was raised on that philosophy as well I can relateGlad to see your a real Sanji fan with that
I'm honestly surprised.
Do you think Sanji will forgive then?
Honestly, one thing I notice is that people who want Sanji to kick her isn't because she's a threat or in his way of freedom or anything, but more because that's the moral justice she deserves. Which...isn't inconsistent with how OP handles a lot of it's villains, arguably. Still, if it turns out that Pudding isn't a fighter that's an actual threat, Sanji kicking Pudding basically means he has to be the aggressor. That I think there is no way in hell happening. Which is why I hope that Pudding is a real fighter. Otherwise, Sanji won't really have a palpable reason for breaking away from his stupidity.
Blackleg-sanji1
Banned
Forgive perhaps not. Attempt to harm her himself not likely at all.
oreomunsta
Banned
I'm gonna pitch an |OT| idea.
|OT| The path to Wano is paved with cake and pudding
|OT| The path to Wano is paved with cake and pudding
I'm about to play Devil's advocate here but....
Carrot is absolutely not going to join the Strawhats.
I'm making this bold statement here, but as much as I enjoy Carrot's character, she really doesn't fit the credentials of what it means to be a Strawhat.
On the other hand, characters like Jinbe, Pedro, and even Momonosuke have all of these features in some capacity or form. Every Strawhat member follows this guideline.
Carrot is absolutely not going to join the Strawhats.
I'm making this bold statement here, but as much as I enjoy Carrot's character, she really doesn't fit the credentials of what it means to be a Strawhat.
- She doesn't have a tragic backstory - Unless there's something we don't know about her, nothing in the story has showcased her having a backstory of some sort. The only chance for her to get his is if she turns out to be the traitor on Zou that gave Jack the vivre card.
- She doesn't have a role on the crew - Her specialty is fighting...that's it.
- She doesn't have a dream - Again, as far as we know, there's really nothing here to suggest she's motivated by anything other than wanting to go on an adventure.
On the other hand, characters like Jinbe, Pedro, and even Momonosuke have all of these features in some capacity or form. Every Strawhat member follows this guideline.
Change cake to tears.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
She has a tragic backstory or did you forget what jack did to zou?
She doesn't need a "dream" or she does whenbshe considered the sea a wonderland
Zoro specialty is also fighting... that it
No getting lost does not count
That wasn't her backstory, that was Zou's backstory.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
It was hers too
Agreed, it's not happening guys.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Zou backatory is her vack atory
That's like saying ohara backstory shouldn't count for robin
Ohara=zou
Robbin=carrot
KuwabaraTheMan
Banned
Her dream is to see the world after being sheltered her whole life. And that's largely what Usopp and Nami's dreams are, too, at least in the broadest idea.
And there's certainly room for Carrot to have some sort of past story at least on par with "My mom died" or "Someone fell down a flight of stairs". Not everyone needs to have some sort of Robin level lifetime of suffering.
And there's certainly room for Carrot to have some sort of past story at least on par with "My mom died" or "Someone fell down a flight of stairs". Not everyone needs to have some sort of Robin level lifetime of suffering.
Damn, who ate your carrot cake as a kid =(
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Vleek
Randomly came across this clip.
I loved Sogeking and I love Nami's anger at the end:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZ3A0BH_pD4
I loved Sogeking and I love Nami's anger at the end:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZ3A0BH_pD4
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Luffy is not a true strawhat
No tragic back story
no skill other than fighting
He's only 33% strawhat
You may go "but but shanks arm" it's only a flesh wound you wimps
No tragic back story
no skill other than fighting
He's only 33% strawhat
You may go "but but shanks arm" it's only a flesh wound you wimps
Zou flashback was focused on nekomamashi and dogstorm she wasn't even in it at all really. And could be a think for all minks not just carrot.
Robin is the character we view the Ohara incident through.
She isn't even Jinbei with the fish tiger flashback where he struggles what ideals to follow between tiger and otohime.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
KuwabaraTheMan
Banned
Hearing Kappei Yamaguchi perform this in person is my absolute favorite memory of every convention that I've ever attended.
Guy sounds like a jerk.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Evil twins are like that
So I may as well be talking to a wall.
You who have nothing to back himself up with or defend against complaints.
Congrats, your a step away from being on ignored.
Meh, y'all acting like Oda can't come out the cut with some depressing backstory or expand on her dreams (Though I thought her wanting to see the world and being sick of being on the island was okay, not everything has to be grandiose or heartbreaking, though I'll concede there's obviously a trend for it) whenever he feels like it, as if we didn't just get yet another one with Sanji not too long ago after all these years lol. Now yea, that is not the same thing of course, but all I'm saying is, I'm happy to be patient and see what happens after this arc. There's a lot going on since the timeskip, so it wouldn't be too out there for Oda to take his time to introducing a new member. After all, we're only just now getting Jinbe. Furthermore, it's been 9 years since someone joined, and there's also been a timeskip since then. I wouldn't necessarily be surprised if after all this time Oda decided a more roundabout approach to eventually making her a member, or at the very least stop caring about each member needing a "proper role". (Because honestly, how many roles are left to fill, I'm genuinely curious lol)
In the end though, I don't want to come off as utterly reaching, or act like some desperate Monet fan that will never give up hope, so I try not to get too crazy with the Carrot love. All I know is, Oda dangled the bait right in front of us with him randomly making her a stowaway, and having a personality that jives quite well with the rest of the crew.
So I blame him.
In the end though, I don't want to come off as utterly reaching, or act like some desperate Monet fan that will never give up hope, so I try not to get too crazy with the Carrot love. All I know is, Oda dangled the bait right in front of us with him randomly making her a stowaway, and having a personality that jives quite well with the rest of the crew.
So I blame him.
Yeah but there's really no hints whatsoever on Carrot having a backstory. Even when Nico Robin started to become Luffy's ally, there was hints in Alabasta that there was more to her than meets the eye. Carrot does not have this whatsoever.
- Status