Aka where everything goes to shit. The entire game has been building up to this moment and the payoff was
intense. Starting off, public opinion for the Phantom Thieves has hit rock bottom. All of the support you accumulated throughout the game literally disappears. Okumura may he been a scumbag, but people don't take to brutal deaths all that well, and it was fascinating seeing public opinion steadily drop as they slowly started losing faith in the Phantom Thieves. I just love how the Phantom Thieves were set up and wrecked by adults. It's a good call back to a day where adults were actually competent and capable like in 1/2, rather than being ignorant and bumbling like in 3/4. It's like the kiddie leagues are over; they're playing ball with adults who don't fuck around, and seeing the Phantom Thieves squirm is great. It's not all bad though, as that scene were Sojiro ends up finding out that Joker and Futaba are a part of the Phantom Thieves is touching, and it absolutely solidified him as being
better than Dojima.
Makoto's gambit of squeezing Goro for information pays off, but with an interesting twist, Goro ends up blackmailing himself into joining Phantom Thieves. There's more I want to say about him, but to keep things short, I can't stress how great of a moment that was. It totally subverts the trend of advertised party members joining the party with good intentions. Goro has complete control over the situation, and it was legitimately depressing having him demand the Phantom Thieves break up after this. He wasn't the big break they needed to get out of a sticky situation, but rather, another force that's having their way with them. He's completely different from Naoto, who ultimately felt like a good person, even when she was an abrasive jerk. The following scene where the characters literally have a mini breakdown in Joker's room is like, a top 5 Persona moment for me.
"Where did we go wrong?"
It's heavy and intense, and almost cathartic. Characters bicker and argue in natural ways. There's talk of backing out and blaming, and everyone is extremely upset. Eventually they come to the conclusion that they lost their way, prioritizing fame and indulging in power rather than actually trying to better society. It's a surprisingly human moment, and the scene where Ryuji calls Joker to talk about how much of a shithead is the perfect cap to that thread. They fucked up, though they haven't lost yet.
Moving on, the atmosphere in Sae's dungeon is obviously fantastic, but even the group atmosphere is worth noting. With the exception of Goro, nobody is happy. They all have this "back against the wall" type of vibe and it's awesome. Seeing Goro almost gleefully talk about "learning the ropes" (his reaction to the calling card was great) made for a funny yet dark contrast with everyone else's dire disposition. To Goro, he's just using them to get back at society in his own way, but to them, this is literally it. Success or failure. Do or die. Goro himself is an exceptional party member. I expected Naoto, but his stat allocation and skills make him a superb damage dealer. Unlike Naoto however, his Persona actually has a weakness, but I see this as more of a good thing. After all, everyone has their strengths and weaknesses in life, and it was a bit silly when her Persona in P4 completely lacked one.
With Goro on the team, literally every element in the game is covered, so i'm pretty much set. All in all, i'm extremely excited for following dungeon.
'CAUSE I FEEL