And you guys is crazy. The new persona doesn't need to be all sunshines and rainbows like 4 was, but we don't need to get to SMT levels of dark either. It's one of the reasons you have two series in the first place.
That's the thing, though. I personally want both in equal amounts. I love sunshine and rainbows and generally following the motto of "let's positive thinking," but I also would like the stakes to be higher than they have been before. Though that just might be my take as a Lovecraft fan.
When people started posting screenshots of the Japanese version of SMT4, I was disappointed that the final representative of the chaos side wasn't a boss fight earlier in the game, as that would mean things could get even darker and possibly involve more elements of cosmic horror. As dark as people say SMT is, I thought SMT4 wasn't dark enough.
Though I am a fan of stories in which the characters need to go through hell and back, but the ending really is a "happily ever after."
Oh, and happy birthday, PK Gaming! I might not have been here long enough to really get to know you that well, but I hope you continue to renovate life's ass for many more years to come.