Dr. Buni
Member
Definitely. They gave some great musics to Hamuko in P3P.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Persona Community Thread |OT2| Burn My Thread
- Thread starter Dantis
- Start date
- Status
Definitely. They gave some great musics to Hamuko in P3P.
Dr. Buni
Member
Only the beginning of Sun is weird (and lame), the rest of the track is quite good.
For some reason, I always feel nostalgic when I listen to this track. Even in the first time I listened to it I felt it. Weird.
cj_iwakura
Member
I gave Maken Shao another go. Boy is this game a graphical mess compared to Maken X.
I hate that name. It makes me think of a Muchi Muchi Pork character. She deserves something more elegant.
I hate that name. It makes me think of a Muchi Muchi Pork character. She deserves something more elegant.
Oh definitely
Can we just admit that everything that related to FeMC is just perfect
Her official name should be Hamuko Debest
Dr. Buni
Member
Hamuko is the best protagonist.
Well, it sounds better than Minako and FeMC.
cj_iwakura
Member
I like Minako a LOT more.
No, not it really doesn't. Reminds me of Hamtaro if anything.
Dr. Buni
Member
That is okay, but Minako is just a variation of Minato's name. That is confusing and lame imo, she deserve better than that.
Well... Hamtaro is cute.
That'd probably play well enough. I still think that show is best with the experience of the game under your belt, but if they can air SAO and that Kickheart nonsense than sure, why not!
Anyway, Fuuja is so cute in P3M.
<3
The face and hair could be better on that art, imo. Then again, that pic of Makoto and Thanatos set the bar for movie promo art for me. lol
Haven't posted much here after being bombarded for tests
. Luckily I'll have it easy going around the time of whatever that Persona announcement is.
Haven't posted much here after being bombarded for tests
. Luckily I'll have it easy going around the time of whatever that Persona announcement is.Lollipop Dave
Member
..but they already topped it with "Shadow World" on P4G
buddha0991
Member
Hellllllllllllllllllll no
Dr. Buni
Member
You're drunk.
buddha0991
Member
P2EPP is the best srs opening, P3 original is the most stylish, and P4 original is the most catchy.
IS PSP eats EP PSP for breakfast. Who's the female voice on it anyways?
EP isn't even the best version of Knights. Meguro's version crushes it.
No idea who the vocalist is on the opening. Presumably nobody of note.
Also, worst opening is Soul Phrase. What a mediocre track by Meguro standards.
No idea who the vocalist is on the opening. Presumably nobody of note.
Also, worst opening is Soul Phrase. What a mediocre track by Meguro standards.
buddha0991
Member
^Love that song but it hardly even sounds like knights anymore.
btw, I have come to the conclusion that despite being all atmosphere ruining and all, the completely original songs and very different remixes of old songs in P1P are better than the very same to the original and sometimes a little better, sometimes worse remixes of P2ISP/ESP. They should have put a little more effort into the P2 ost's. Some songs sound better than others, with some sounding like proper remixes, but there is a pretty big chunk of hardly redone songs that sound like they just used a cheap synth or something.
btw, I have come to the conclusion that despite being all atmosphere ruining and all, the completely original songs and very different remixes of old songs in P1P are better than the very same to the original and sometimes a little better, sometimes worse remixes of P2ISP/ESP. They should have put a little more effort into the P2 ost's. Some songs sound better than others, with some sounding like proper remixes, but there is a pretty big chunk of hardly redone songs that sound like they just used a cheap synth or something.
Asami Izawa
Oh, I thought he meant the lady singing in the EP opening, not Unbreakable Tie.
My bad.
So after a year and a half of telling me I'm wrong, you've decided that I'm right after all?
Basically, the songs that Konishi did are good. The piano tracks that Koduka did are good. The rest is hit and miss.
Lollipop Dave
Member
I like shadow world, but
D'aww, you guys are so cute <3
Keats always on the right!
Dr. Buni
Member
I am worried about everything music-related. Meguro better deliver this time.
buddha0991
Member
Oh, I thought he meant the lady singing in the EP opening, not Unbreakable Tie.
My bad.
So after a year and a half of telling me I'm wrong, you've decided that I'm right after all?
Basically, the songs that Konishi did are good. The piano tracks that Koduka did are good. The rest is hit and miss.
I still very much like the P2 ost's but you can tell they clearly put in less effort. I may not particularly enjoy the new P1 atmosphere over the old one, but you can clearly tell they put some effort in it at least. I guess the way I see it now that I'm a little more far removed from P1 and P2IS these days (Need to go back and finish P2EP that I bought on PSN), in game, I think I like the P2IS soundtrack more because it fits what I remember and expect, but out of game, P1P's ost is the better one.
Keats, how you gon' try to play me for a sucka? You ain't off the cheese burgers!
Honestly, outside of a few tracks, I think Innocent Sin's remixed soundtrack holds up really well. It's Eternal Punishment where the remixes are lacking.
Monad Mandala, the final dungeon, is a fantastic example of what I mean. The drums aren't as strong, the creepy voice in the background is missing, the intro is missing, cheap synths...
As an aside, they were weirdly inconsistent about how they applied the Velvet Room theme to the remixes. Persona 1 PSP got a new remix that's similar to the P3 version, but with elements of the original. Persona 2 IS/EP just flat out uses the P3/4 version for the remix. It's even the same length on the OST.
Monad Mandala, the final dungeon, is a fantastic example of what I mean. The drums aren't as strong, the creepy voice in the background is missing, the intro is missing, cheap synths...
As an aside, they were weirdly inconsistent about how they applied the Velvet Room theme to the remixes. Persona 1 PSP got a new remix that's similar to the P3 version, but with elements of the original. Persona 2 IS/EP just flat out uses the P3/4 version for the remix. It's even the same length on the OST.
buddha0991
Member
One is a Meguro OST, the other two aren't.
Mystery solved!
why dont you take out meguros garbage while you are at it or cut the dudes hair yo
One is a Meguro OST, the other two aren't.
Mystery solved!
Oh, you're referring to Poem of Everyone's Souls? Lrrn2quote correctly.
Or maybe you could actually think about the context and realise that I'm right, ho hum.
Poem of Everyone's Souls is a Meguro track. It's always been a Meguro track. The reason the two OSTs that weren't by Meguro didn't have a new mix of it is because it's a track that's always done by Meguro.
Whether it's because he doesn't want them to, or someone else doesn't want them to, or maybe they like Meguro's version just fine, I'm pretty sure that's why.
He didn't do any. That's my point.
You're aware that each Persona game had a new version of Aria of the Soul? Just the P2 remakes didn't.
buddha0991
Member
oh this conversation again
Yes. And in all of them, it's Meguro.
Wait. I'm still confused. What the hell are you talking about?
buddha0991
Member
ARE you Meguro or something?
- Status