• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Persona Community Thread |OT8| Coming Winter 2014

FluxWaveZ

Member
vwEogda.jpg
Is the encircled a drink or a decoration? I always thought the perspective was weird on that one, but if it's the former, I think that might have been an indication of an additional party member and their style all along.

Also, uploaded part of the song that might be related to the cafe.

Could also be a weird barstool.

That sounds likely, and it would explain why it's always looked weird to me.

Now I just need to figure out what that weird translucent thing attached to the door/wall in the hallway is.
 

Zolo

Member
The kind of best friends that everyone assumes are gayer than a Mardi Gras parade, despite any evidence to the contrary.

I approve this ship so hard.

I honestly thought Mitsuru and Yukari or at least Mitsuru for Yukari seemed more shippy than Chie and Yukiko myself. The latter's more 'I was able to be stronger/more confident because you were with me' which is common in close friendships while the former was 'I promised I'd put you above all others in this position.'
 
I seem to recall there being a big debate about that a while back, I think we decided that it was a barstool though.

Tangentially related: but interesting that the coffee shop isn't actually where the group meet to enter the Palace, since we've seen a different location with that option.


Best guess about the thing in the hallway is a phone, although it might not be. Someone with the bluray could check to see if it's any easier to make out.
 

daevious

Member
I honestly thought Mitsuru and Yukari or at least Mitsuru for Yukari seemed more shippy than Chie and Yukiko myself. The latter's more 'I was able to be stronger/more confident because you were with me' which is common in close friendships while the former was 'I promised I'd put you above all others in this position.'

It helps that Yukari starts out being hostile towards Mitsuru and then she eventually stops blaming her family for killing her dad and they start getting along.
Yukiko and Chie were already BFF's from the time you met them, albeit BFF's that may not have had the healthiest of relationships.
 

Lunar15

Member
So I wonder what triggers Personas/persona level ups in this game?

P3: Being faced with death or the death of a loved one
P4: Facing/Accepting/resolving a bad truth about yourself
P5: Breaking free of whatever's stopping you? Perhaps they'll represent it visually with the whole chain thing they have going on. Maybe you'll break that chain and it'll become a new persona.
 
So I wonder what triggers Personas/persona level ups in this game?

P3: Being faced with death or the death of a loved one
P4: Facing/Accepting/resolving a bad truth about yourself
P5: Breaking free of whatever's stopping you? Perhaps they'll represent it visually with the whole chain thing they have going on. Maybe you'll break that chain and it'll become a new persona.

Would make sense. They're also supposed to reform, right? Could be switching roles that does it. Could even do both at the same time.

I hope I can keep Arsene around and viable in battle for a while. Just looking at the magnificent bastard bird-gentleman with knife heels makes me sad his fabulous ridiculousness will probably be eclipsed in usefulness within the first ten levels.
 

FluxWaveZ

Member
Late: I forgot I had actually taken a few screenshots of Naoto talking about Apathy Syndrome in P4D.

No spoilers for these, but complying with the thread rules:

Edit: Or wait, I think I misinterpreted "event scenes." I'll embed these for readability, then.
Goes on for longer than that, obviously.

Bonus:
http://i.imgur.com/kdtp5aU.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/hGLNvjs.jpg [Slightly spoilerish]
http://i.imgur.com/u6t3d7u.jpg [Slightly spoilerish] (Didn't take this one; saw it on Tumblr)
 

PK Gaming

Member
I think I know what fanfiction she's reading now.

I love it when characters are given traits that are fun/hilarious but don't necessarily get in the way of their character. Case in point: straight-laced Yukari being into incestuous fanfiction is goddamn hilarious. Naoto's fascination with robotics (whenever it pops up from time to time) is also another good example.
 
I love it when characters are given traits that are fun/hilarious but don't necessarily get in the way of their character. Case in point: straight-laced Yukari being into incestuous fanfiction is goddamn hilarious. Naoto's fascination with robotics (whenever it pops up from time to time) is also another good example.

Wait what the fuck?
Could you run that one by me again, please?
 

Sophia

Member
I love it when characters are given traits that are fun/hilarious but don't necessarily get in the way of their character. Case in point: straight-laced Yukari being into incestuous fanfiction is goddamn hilarious. Naoto's fascination with robotics (whenever it pops up from time to time) is also another good example.

I like these traits too, especially because they're fairly realistic. We all have traits/quirks like that.
 

PK Gaming

Member
Wait what the fuck?
Could you run that one by me again, please?

It's an incredibly bizarre trait to ascribe to to Yukari of all characters, but i'll take it!

I like these traits too, especially because they're fairly realistic. We all have traits/quirks like that.

Exactly. It helps with humanizing a character and has the side effect of making them a lot more entertaining too. I really like the idea of Yukari hunched over a computer and reading fanfiction while everyone is away. Ahahahaha
 

Jintor

Member
woah whats up everyone someone was talking about hilariously unexpected character traits and yuri and i came running

what did i miss
 

FluxWaveZ

Member
In the time between Persona 5's announcement and its supposed release date:


  • Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold announced and released before P5.
  • Etrian Mystery Dungeon announced and released before P5.
  • SMTxFE, previously evaporated into thin air, resurfaces as Genei Ibun Roku #FE and will be released before P5.
  • Odin Sphere Leifthrasir is announced and will be released before P5.
  • Shin Megami Tensei IV FINAL is announced and will be released before P5.
Maybe there'll be one more thing in that vein.
 
In the time between Persona 5's announcement and its supposed release date:


  • Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold announced and released before P5.
  • Etrian Mystery Dungeon announced and released before P5.
  • SMTxFE, previously evaporated into thin air, resurfaces as Genei Ibun Roku #FE and will be released before P5.
  • Odin Sphere Leifthrasir is announced and will be released before P5.
  • Shin Megami Tensei IV FINAL is announced and will be released before P5.
Maybe there'll be one more thing in that vein.

P3D. Whether that's Dancing or Definitive is anyone's guess. :p

We have found the non-believer.

What can I say? When it comes to these games, I don't seem to have the luckiest taste.
 
...
I'm not sure what to say...

Also shame I don't have anything to contribute to the yukamitsu tide.

We have found the non-believer.

What can I say? When it comes to these games, I don't seem to have the luckiest taste.

It's not about being lucky or not - who do you think works well together in P3 or P4?

Other popular pairings I could see happening would be ones like Yu & Yosuke, Rise & Yu, Rise & Naoto, Junpei & Chidori, FeMC & Shinjiro, MC & Aigis, MC & Mitsuru, Kanji & Naoto to an extent.

There are ways most of these pairings could work
if not for character deaths and the like
- it's just that Yukari & Mitsuru are the 'most canon', they're put together quite a bit.
 

PK Gaming

Member
So a long, long, long time, long time ago I posted some of the translated Persona Q character profiles from the artbook. A few more have been translated (source HERE) and I figured I should share some of the highlights:


Assorted Mutterings on Naoto Shirogane

P3 Hero: “I guess that’s a real gun, not an Evoker.”
Yukari: “It’s pretty amazing that she’s a detective!”
Junpei: “Surprise! It’s a detective gal!”
Akihiko: “That nimble agility of hers, it’s not bad.”
Mitsuru: “It would seem there’s such a thing as a beauty in male dress.”
Fuuka: “A scientifically-minded girl, the same as me!”
Aigis: “Searching for Naoto-san’s measurements…”
Koromaru: “Woof woof!”
Ken: “She feels like… an older sister.”
Shinjiro: “Can’t you tell she’s a girl just by looking at her?”
P4 Hero: “…’Nao-cakes’.”
Yosuke: “C’mon, pay attention to Kanji every once in a while…”
Chie: “Hrm… It’s all super wordy talk all the time with her.”
Yukiko: “I wonder if Naoto-kun knows about the cookies I made?”
Kanji: “Uwah!? N-Na-… aaaaahhh!?”
Teddie: “Nao-chan’s a bear-illiant girl!”
Rise: “But wouldn’t it suit her better if she looked girlier?”
Zen: “A projectile weapon user, like me.”
Rei: “She said it’s just pareidolia… But what’s a dolia?”
Elizabeth: “Yo! The detective heir!”
Theodore: “Ms. Shirogane… Nothing escapes her predictions.”
Margaret: “Indeed… as harmoniously dissonant as the Destiny Sympathy!”
Marie: “A single rose blooming on the moor!”
Nanako: “She’s like Magical Witch Detective Loveline!”

Notes
1 Pareidolia. Think back to the third labyrinth.
2 This refers to the scene after the Wildcard fight


Assorted Mutterings on Rise Kujikawa

P3 Hero: “She and Fuuka really hit it off, huh?”
Yukari: “Uh oh! She’s too cute!”
Junpei: “A working idol! She’s heeeeere!!”
Akihiko: “41 kilograms!? Far too low! Eat more, stat!”
Mitsuru: “Apparently she possesses a great mass of girl power.”
Fuuka: “Isn’t it fun to chat about things with fellow girls!”
Aigis: “Tears are a female weapon… I get it, yo.”
Koromaru: “Pant, pant…!”
Ken: “A-A public entertainer!?”
Shinjiro: “Eating too much cayenne could be dangerous, y'know?”
P4 Hero: “Tofu is justice! …just the way it is.” 1
Yosuke: “You sure can’t beat Rise for sheer energy!”
Chie: “Whoa! She’s not shy about anything!”
Yukiko: “She really does look out for everyone.”
Kanji: “Just shut up, would ya? Every single time…”
Teddie: “Rise-chan, let’s go on a date!”
Naoto: “She has a candour I couldn’t possibly imitate.”
Zen: “I see, she’s our offensive backup.”
Rei: “Idols are amazing!”
Elizabeth: “‘Waaaah, sweetie, cutieeee! ☆’, yes?”
Theodore: “A beautiful pair / Ah, such a beautiful pair / these fine ladies are.” 2
Margaret: “Shall I tell your fortune for you?”
Marie: “No way. I hate you. Too intense.”
Nanako: “Rise-chan, you’re Risette!”

Notes
1 The second part is really hard to translate out of Japanese without copious amounts of context. My current best guess is either a reference to the hotpot sidequest, or to Rise’s Social Link comments on tofu in Persona 4 itself. I might edit this after replaying PQ again.
2 Haiku


Assorted Mutterings on Chie Satonaka

P3 Hero: “Akihiko-senpai’s disciple appears!”
Yukari: “Sheesh, I don’t need any of that Meat Gum stuff!”
Junpei: “A kung fu chick! Niiiice!”
Akihiko: “Faster!! Stronger!! Hotter!!!”
Mitsuru: “I see, she acquired martial arts through self-education.”
Fuuka: “This kind of hairstyle really suits us, doesn’t it?”
Aigis: “The average percentage of meat in her diet exceeds a substantial level!”
Koromaru: “Woof, woof.”
Ken: “Isn’t smashing things bad…?”
Shinjiro: “Great… Two meatheads.”
P4 Hero: “Don’t think! Feel!”
Yosuke: “No matter how much gut destruction her crappy cooking causes, she just doesn’t get it…!”
Yukiko: “They say it appears in Inaba Municipal Hospital…”
Kanji: “Meat party time again?”
Teddie: “She doesn’t like grilled rice cakes at aaaaall.” 1
Rise: “But doesn’t meat make you put on weight…?”
Naoto: “I’m a little jealous of her strong constitution.”
Zen: “Chie’s always energetic.”
Rei: “With beef, it’s gotta be beef tongue and marinated spare ribs!”
Elizabeth: “I shall call her Ms. S. for Ms. Satonaka.”
Theodore: “Ms. Satonaka’s meat jel- …Ahem.”
Margaret: “Ah, such wonderful meat.”
Marie: “Positivity. Bordered with meat.”
Nanako: “Big sis Chie’s always really lively!”

Notes
1 Yakimochi.


Assorted Mutterings on Yosuke Hanamura

P3 Hero: “A disappointment, huh…”
Yukari: “Why does he act like Kanji-kun’s dad, though…?”
Junpei: “We’re in the same position!”
Akihiko: “You’re saying… you’ll treat me at the food court!?”
Mitsuru: “It seems he’s from a wealthy family.”
Fuuka: “Oh, I’ll treat you to hotpot!”
Aigis: “The meaning of Yosuke-san is a jyovial skeever.” 1
Koromaru: “Woof.”
Ken: “The ‘Super Junes Ranger’… isn’t it?”
Shinjiro: “About those guys’ cooking… I sympathize.”
P4 Hero: “Punching each other makes us equal…?”
Chie: “If anything happens to my meat jelly, your life is forfeit, okay!?”
Yukiko: “…Idols’ old bras? Yosuke-kun, you’re awful.”
Kanji: “I’ll show you just how much of a real man I am!”
Teddie: “The bear fact of the matter is… we have a live-in relationship!”
Rise: “Geez, it’s just creepy when he says anything cool!”
Naoto: “Yosuke-senpai, he… o-on the corner of the table, he… his vitals……”
Zen: “He’s the Comic Foil Prince.”
Rei: “Sweets? That means - sssoft-boiled eggs, curreee, and beaten egg whitessss!” 2
Elizabeth: “Yosuke Hanamura… a comic foil of deceptive skill.” 3
Theodore: “As Rei once said - set a dried squid snack to catch a yo-yo.”
Margaret: “Come now, my servants. Let’s rehearse our arrival scene.”
Marie: “Yep, a disappointment.”
Nanako: “Every day’s great at your Junes! ♪”

Notes
1 A pun on the characters in Yosuke’s given name. The localisation went with the more literal “cheerful pervert”.
2 Another pun, kind of. The sounds at the start of each word here spell おかし okashi, “candy”.
3 In Japanese, the Velvet Room residents (except Marie) all speak formally to guests and address everyone with 様 sama, a very polite honorific. The official localisation drops the latter entirely, so I have too.
 
There are ways most of these pairings could work
if not for character deaths and the like
- it's just that Yukari & Mitsuru are the 'most canon', they're put together quite a bit.

Well, that's the problem, isn't it? Equating popularity with being canon.
I seem to regularly bet on the wrong horse in JRPGs. :/

Jesus Fuuka. More of a robot than Aigis.

Reminds me of a post from a while back...
 

Sophia

Member
So a long, long, long time, long time ago I posted some of the translated Persona Q character profiles from the artbook. A few more have been translated (source HERE) and I figured I should share some of the highlights:

The Aigis ones there are pretty funny too:

Assorted Mutterings on Aigis

P3 Hero: “It’s kind of like having an alarm clock with a Vulcan cannon.”
Yukari: “No more with the weird jokes!”
Junpei: “That Ai-chan sure doesn’t go easy on the straight bot stuff…” 1
Akihiko: “In my matches with Shinji, I’ve left the judging to her!”
Mitsuru: “The culmination of all the Kirijo Group’s arsenal.”
Fuuka: “She’s like Koro-chan’s interpreter!”
Koromaru: “Woof!”
Ken: “She doesn’t look like what you’d think of as a robot.”
Shinjiro: “She… updated her data on the wheat flour in donuts?”
P4 Hero: “She even has a Koromaru-translating function…!?”
Yosuke: “Poinking and the like are strictly forbidden!”
Chie: “Just as I’d expect from a robot! The way she moves is amazing!”
Yukiko: “Her head can…! Her head can…! Pffahaha!”
Kanji: “Is she seriously like a mecha!?” 2
Teddie: “Ahh, come light a flaming torch in this bear’s heart…!”
Rise: “Aww, she’s super-cute like a doll! That’s so cool!”
Naoto: “M-May I touch…?”
Zen: “Breaking all of those chopsticks without picking up any takoyaki…?”
Rei: “I wanna poink!”
Elizabeth: “The mechanical young lady… Quite a fascinating being.”
Theodore: “I’ll create appropriate ammunition for you by eye!”
Margaret: “She exists as a practical joke of destiny, hm.”
Marie: “Ugh. So straightforward, it’s sneaky.”
Nanako: “A robot big sis! Amazing!”

Notes
1 In the straight man / comic foil sense.
2 Not really.

Makoto has the best comment ever. XD

These should have been in Persona Q itself, like when you're looking at the profile of other party members.
 

PK Gaming

Member
The Aigis ones there are pretty funny too:



Makoto has the best comment ever. XD

These should have been in Persona Q itself, like when you're looking at the profile of other party members.

For sure.

Persona Q stumbles a few times when it comes to characterization, but it absolutely nails character interaction. It definitely deserves props for the way it handles both casts slowing become closer.
 

arue

Member
In the time between Persona 5's announcement and its supposed release date:

Maybe there'll be one more thing in that vein.
Devil Survivor 3 announced and released before P5.

Those PQ comments remind that I still need to finish the game. P3MC's characterization still surprises me.
 

FluxWaveZ

Member
Devil Survivor 3 announced and released before P5.

Let me see... Time intervals between announcements and releases:


  • EO2U = 114 days
  • EMD = 101 days
  • GIR #FE = 269 days [Nintendo]
  • OSL = 178 days
  • SMTIV F = 128 days
Excluding the Nintendo published one, that's an average of ~130 days.

If we assume the most optimistic possibility of Persona 5 releasing on June 23, 2016, that leaves us with 261 days between now and then.

If we give them until the end of December to announce something new before they start pumping out games (and not Atlus Best Collection releases) in 2016—starting with Odin Sphere—and if we give P5 a 1-month buffer with a max. end point of May 23, 2016, that's 144 days.

I guess I'll call it now and say with a lot of confidence that, once more, there will in fact be a brand new Atlus game announced and released before Persona 5.

P Studio is busy with Persona 5, Team Maniax is busy with Shin Megami Tensei IV Final and Etrian Odyssey team is busy with Etrian Odyssey V. The Devil Survivor team's director is busy with that #FE thing. If there is to be a new game, I think it would have to be a studio collab. project like EMD and P4A, or it would have to be some kind of remake.
 
Top Bottom