I like the Red battle more because it's more of a "face yourself" kind of battle. It'll never be replicated in that sense due to how big Pokemon was at the time, and how iconic it was.
I'd say the Gary battle is my second favorite.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Pokémon Community Thread: Gotta Catch 'Em All!
- Thread starter ThatObviousUser
- Start date
I like the Red battle more because it's more of a "face yourself" kind of battle. It'll never be replicated in that sense due to how big Pokemon was at the time, and how iconic it was.
I'd say the Gary battle is my second favorite.
Syph Medwes
Member
Totally agree, Red #1, Gary #2.
Especially since you had no idea what to expect while "climbing" Mt. Silver.
Also what happened to your avatar? :$
tiggerkiddo
Member
Hmmm green seems like it would look good for Deino.
Syph Medwes
Member
Can't tell if I like shiny Hydreigon or not..
Ok, we did a champion, now for a RIVAL BATTLE:
BLUE:
Exggutor: Psychic/Leaf Storm/Hypnosis/Trick Room
Rhydon: Stone Edge/Earthquake/Meaghorn/Thunder Fang
Machamp: ThunderPunch/Stone Edge/Earthquake/DynamicPunch
Gyarados: Dragon Dance/Waterfall/Ice Fang/Return
Arcaine: ExtremeSpeed/Dragon Pulse/Flare Blitz/Roar
Pidgeot: Whilwind/Return/Mirror Move/Air Slash
SILVER
Sneasel: Shadow Claw/Faint Attack/Icy Wind/Metal Claw
Magneton: Discharge/Magnet Bomb/Mirror Shot/Thunder Wave
Gengar: Dark Pulse/Confuse Ray/Sludge Bomb/Shadow Ball
Crobat: Air Cutter/Bite/Confuse Ray/Toxic
Alakazam: Psychic/Reflect/Focus Blast/Recover
Feraligator: Slash/Crunch/Aqua Tail/Ice Fang
Silver can have any starter, but I gave him Totodile as most players seem to pick Cyndaquil as their starter (although I always go for Chikorita).
BLUE:
Exggutor: Psychic/Leaf Storm/Hypnosis/Trick Room
Rhydon: Stone Edge/Earthquake/Meaghorn/Thunder Fang
Machamp: ThunderPunch/Stone Edge/Earthquake/DynamicPunch
Gyarados: Dragon Dance/Waterfall/Ice Fang/Return
Arcaine: ExtremeSpeed/Dragon Pulse/Flare Blitz/Roar
Pidgeot: Whilwind/Return/Mirror Move/Air Slash
SILVER
Sneasel: Shadow Claw/Faint Attack/Icy Wind/Metal Claw
Magneton: Discharge/Magnet Bomb/Mirror Shot/Thunder Wave
Gengar: Dark Pulse/Confuse Ray/Sludge Bomb/Shadow Ball
Crobat: Air Cutter/Bite/Confuse Ray/Toxic
Alakazam: Psychic/Reflect/Focus Blast/Recover
Feraligator: Slash/Crunch/Aqua Tail/Ice Fang
Silver can have any starter, but I gave him Totodile as most players seem to pick Cyndaquil as their starter (although I always go for Chikorita).
Syph Medwes
Member
Blue needs some dark type attacks eh
Professor Beef
Banned
I think Silver might have the edge over Gary mainly because Gary doesn't have a real answer for Alakazam outside of resisting it with Exeggutor.
I think Gyarados could probably handle Alakazam, and Arcanine could probably revenge kill it if Reflect isn't set up.
ThatObviousUser
ὠαἴÏÏιÏÏÎ¿Ï Ïαá¿Ï εἶ
Yeah... I like the original better.
it's my favorite thing to come out of Gen V because it makes raising in game teams so much easier. if i want to add a new Pokemon to the team, i just have to find some Audino. since i love using tons of different Pokemon, it means i don't have to sit forever grinding.
It will forever be a Missingno, but Gravjiah got it back.
I love Audino too. The level 47 ones on route 12 give around 5000 xp, which is amazing, but I would also like to find the Unfezant I want. still haven't seen one after being here for over an hour. On another note, does anyone with White Version want to trade for a Thunderus or any White exclusives? GTS trades are way too unreasonable. A Deoxys for a Solosis? yeah no.
And Flareon is half the battle.
Professor Beef
Banned
No wonder they won't give Flareon anything. He's so OP, he's always in the E4!
According to Flint in Platinum, Gamefreak apparently thinks his best set is Overheat/Giga Impact/Quick Attack/Will-O-Wisp
Maybe in the RSE remake Steven can have a Flareon he can use to tank Fire hits for his Steel Pokemon.
Syph Medwes
Member
Flint may be one of my least favourite E4 members.
For a "Master fire-type trainer" he sure lacks in fire-type pokemon. (In D/P I mean)
besides all of gen 5's elite 4
Congrats! Shiny hydreigon is just awesome <3
Modest
31/X/31/31/31/31
After *many* tries and some serious help with egg RNG, I finally managed to get my precious shiny Deino
Now all I need to do is get a good Jellicent and my Super Train team will be ready!
tiggerkiddo
Member
What? Flint's interactions with Volkner are great. Now that bug guy? He sucks. Have him give the title to Volkner.
No way, Aaron's cool. All jumping down from the ceiling and whatnot.
tiggerkiddo
Member
That's all you got? What is he, some kind of bug? Look at his hair! Then look at Volkner, then back to Aaron and then back to Volkner. Sadly, he is not Volkner...blah blah blah.
ScraftyDevil
Banned
Whoa man; Grimsley's the best Elite Four member. He uses the best type, has the best taste in regards to his team, and by far the best and most philisophical quotes in the game. Plus, just look at that swag:
Woah just found out that magic coat gained priority this gen...might be useful with some pokes.
Whoa man; Grimsley's the best Elite Four member. He uses the best type, has the best taste in regards to his team, and by far the best and most philisophical quotes in the game. Plus, just look at that swag:[/QUOTE]"]
Yep, he is pretty awesome, too bad his team sucks a bit
Whoa man; Grimsley's the best Elite Four member. He uses the best type, has the best taste in regards to his team, and by far the best and most philisophical quotes in the game. Plus, just look at that swag:
[/QUOTE]"]
Whoa man; Grimsley's the best Elite Four member. He uses the best type, has the best taste in regards to his team, and by far the best and most philisophical quotes in the game. Plus, just look at that swag:
Yep, he is pretty awesome, too bad his team sucks a bit
HOW CAN YOU HATE THIS
I just imagine people walking into the first room of the Pokémon League, to Aaron falling from the rafter and proclaiming "Welcome to the Elite Four!"
ScraftyDevil
Banned
Yep, he is pretty awesome, too bad his team sucks a bit
The only part of his team that needs replacing is Liepard (I can't believe they didn't give him Tyranitar or something instead). Scrafty, Krookodile and Bisharp all pull their own weight.
Chet Rippo
Member
Wiseblade proving his wrongness yet again.
Syph Medwes
Member
Grimsley was the lesser of the 4 evils to me; I just didn't like Gen 5's Elite 4. Maybe it was the format they were presented in.
too weak to fighting, they should have given him honchrow and/or spiritomb.
How about facing your character from the last game?
Facing Red was probably the most mindblowing experience I will ever have in a video game. I did not have access to the Internet playing through Gold, so there were no spoilers. Came out of fucking nowhere. Soooooo good.
just didn't do as much. there's no buildup to it. you just randomly wander around and then hey it's red and he uses lance's theme!
ScraftyDevil
Banned
I wish they would just go ahead and release Black and White 2 already so we can talk about how awesome one of the battles is...
tiggerkiddo
Member
HOW CAN YOU HATE THIS
I just imagine people walking into the first room of the Pokémon League, to Aaron falling from the rafter and proclaiming "Welcome to the Elite Four!"
Bet he gets great radio reception with that idiot hair.
I wish they would just go ahead and release Black and White 2 already so we can talk about how awesome one of the battles is...
is it N?
Exterminieren
Banned
FFS guys, stop even hinting at BW2 stuff. People have made it perfectly clear that they don't want to hear it.
Also, while the Red battle was a good moment, some of its power was robbed by the fact it was so easy. I shouldn't be able to beat him with a team in the 60s.
Also, while the Red battle was a good moment, some of its power was robbed by the fact it was so easy. I shouldn't be able to beat him with a team in the 60s.
Kanto scaling could have been better. I beat him in SS with an Infernape at 60, so there is also the fact that too many of his guys had similar weaknesses.
Chet Rippo
Member
Wasn't easy to me. I also recall having a 1-2 hour battle with him in HeartGold.
2 HOUR BATTLE?
My longest battle was a 45 minute battle with Wallace in Ruby. My Starmie and his Milotic walled the hell out of each other.
It was very intense. I was surprised myself after I saw the time.
tiggerkiddo
Member
I think my first fight with Cynthia took over a hour and a half. That Garchomp OHKO everyone in my party and I kept having to revive them.
As for Red...I strangely didn't have much trouble with him, even though his party was really high leveled. Tyranitar (Ugly as he may be) rolled over most of that party by himself.
As for Red...I strangely didn't have much trouble with him, even though his party was really high leveled. Tyranitar (Ugly as he may be) rolled over most of that party by himself.
My Level 50 Gyarados took out Cynthia in like 5 minutes.
Red in HG/SS is a lot harder than in GSC.
GSC Red is actually easily.
Graveler/Rhydon>Pikachu
Dark Type>Espeon (only has Psychic and Shift)
Ghost>Snorlax (doesnt have anything to hit ghosts with)
The starters can be taken down with something that has a type advantage.
Red in HG/SS is a lot harder than in GSC.
GSC Red is actually easily.
Graveler/Rhydon>Pikachu
Dark Type>Espeon (only has Psychic and Shift)
Ghost>Snorlax (doesnt have anything to hit ghosts with)
The starters can be taken down with something that has a type advantage.
I recall the details, I'm referring to another point just for whatever. It still wasn't easy for me at the time.
tiggerkiddo
Member
I agree, Gyrados makes mincemeat of Garchomp. I usually never run with a full party in Platinum and enjoy getting through the game with the least amount of Pokemon I can. Last time I beat it with just Infernape and Gengar.
Nocturnowl
Member
Most of my champion battles these days involve me with an underleveled team selecting one chosen pokemon to get pumped up with tons of X items (or use their own stat boosting moves if they have any) to simply power and defence up so they can just sweep through to victory. Hate the pre elite 4 grinding they expect you to do, the gap in levels between elite 4 members always seemed a bit silly to me.