• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

PoliGAF 2016 |OT9| The Wrath of Khan!

Status
Not open for further replies.
This attention troll father knew exactly what the fuck he was doing and probably tried to get that seat. The guy has clearly shown he cares more about being on TV more than anything his son did or the people who died.
 

pigeon

Banned
I didn't really know it was a crime to be related to a mass shooter.

People are buying into the reactionary narrative a lot here. Don't do that, we're winning. Define a better narrative.
 
I didn't really know it was a crime to be related to a mass shooter.

People are buying into the reactionary narrative a lot here. Don't do that, we're winning. Define a better narrative.

Exactly. Are we saying Clinton needs to screen open door public events for Muslims related to terrorists? Is that what we are saying?
 

Valhelm

contribute something
Can you elaborate? I've only heard a couple statements from him and they just seemed sad.

He's a right-wing Islamist. I've got a sneaking suspicion that Seddique Mateen's presumedly virulent homophia was a contributing factor to Omar Mateen's instability.

I didn't really know it was a crime to be related to a mass shooter.

People are buying into the reactionary narrative a lot here. Don't do that, we're winning. Define a better narrative.

It's not bad that he was allowed to be present, but the failure to vet this nut is only going to feed the narrative that "Democrats are pro-Islamist". Alex Jones Republicans generally believe that Hillary covertly supports ISIS, while most of the Alt-right thinks she's on a mission to destroy American culture as some kind of post-colonial punishment.
 
He's a right-wing Islamist. I've got a sneaking suspicion that Seddique Mateen's presumedly virulent homophia was a contributing factor to Omar Mateen's instability.



It's not bad that he was allowed to be present, but the failure to vet this nut is only going to feed the narrative that "Democrats are pro-Islamist". Alex Jones Republicans generally believe that Hillary covertly supports ISIS, while most of the Alt-right thinks she's on a mission to destroy American culture as some kind of post-colonial punishment.

How do you vet 3000 people at an open air event?
 

pigeon

Banned
He's a right-wing Islamist. I've got a sneaking suspicion that Seddique Mateen's presumedly virulent homophia was a contributing factor to Omar Mateen's instability.

YOUR LINK said:
Since the shooting at the Pulse nightclub, other commenters have left pornographic images in the comments of Mateen’s Facebook page, condemning his son for attacking LGBT people. But there’s nothing in the videos that suggest Mateen was a religious fundamentalist. His diatribes are more nationalist and engineered for self-aggrandizement and political effect.

In comments after his son was killed by police, Mateen made remarks that seemed to condemn homosexuality on religious grounds, but he subsequently tried to walk them back, suggesting that while he might not personally approve of homosexuality, it was no basis for his son to kill 49 people.

It's not bad that he was allowed to be present, but the failure to vet this nut is only going to feed the narrative that "Democrats are pro-Islamist". Alex Jones Republicans generally believe that Hillary covertly supports ISIS, while most of the Alt-right thinks she's on a mission to destroy American culture as some kind of post-colonial punishment.

Great. Why do you care what the alt-right think? The more they invest themselves in insane and unbelievable conspiracy theories the less impact they will have on America. I'm excited that the Trump campaign has retreated to the #HillarysHealth smear which has basically zero plausibility among anybody who doesn't read Infowars. If they also talk about Clinton's secret relationship with a guy who came to one of her rallies that's even better.

oh you already know then

"Optics" is code for "the evil GOP right-wing machine will smear and destroy us."

Since that machine is eating itself, I don't really think we should worry so much.
 
I mean, I'm not happy this happened, but, seriously, if the person makes it through security what else is supposed to happen? They want a diverse set of people on stage. So, he got picked to go on stage. I had no idea who he was by looking at him, after having followed the Orlando shooting religiously. I mean, it's unfortunate, but we allow citizens to take part in democracy. That means there will, from time to time, be people in there that you probably don't want associated with you. (See 99% of the people at a Trump rally)
 
He's a right-wing Islamist. I've got a sneaking suspicion that Seddique Mateen's presumedly virulent homophia was a contributing factor to Omar Mateen's instability.

Lately, the videos have taken on a delusional tone. Mateen has appointed himself president of Afghanistan and has posted to his Facebook pages the names and photos of people he claims are serving as ministers in his cabinet. Recent videos on his Facebook timeline show Mateen wearing camouflage fatigues and saluting the camera.

I don't think anything but a nutball is a fair assessment. He was some weird notion of Afghani nationalism revolving around one border region and a hatred of Pakistan. Dude just wants attention and I doubt they could vet that many people or even need to submit names or be recognized in the crowd.
 

Valhelm

contribute something
How do you vet 3000 people at an open air event?

Don't you have to sign up before-hand to be behind the camera? Or are those people hand-picked the day of the rally?

I think precautionary measures definitely could have been taken, although I guess staffers shouldn't be expected to memorize the names of criminals' relatives.
 
It's weird, the only mentions from the right wing about the Orlando shooter's dad I'm seeing are just whataboutisms if something similar happened at a Trump rally. These people just can't give up the "media is against us!" narrative.
 
Don't you have to sign up before-hand to be behind the camera? Or are those people hand-picked the day of the rally?

I think precautionary measures definitely could have been taken, although I guess staffers shouldn't be expected to memorize the names of criminals' relatives.

Not always. The rallies I';ve been too, they just selected some people to go on stage. Typically, they want people of different age, races, genders, etc. It makes the crowd look more diverse, even if it's not completely diverse. Some events have RSVP, but this was not one of them, so far as I know.

And, again, I can't say that I've always been asked my name when I went to a rally. And, what reason would there to believe that this man was related to the shooter, outside he's a brown person? I doubt I could pick him out of a line up of people, to be honest.
 
donald-trump-dirt-files-hillary-clinton-cronies-4.jpg


"Weird" Tim Kaine as a nickname. Sad!

Hillary, also a lesbian, incredible stuff:

http://www.nationalenquirer.com/photos/hillary-clinton-lesbian-huma-email-scandal/photo/157386/
 

dramatis

Member
Don't you have to sign up before-hand to be behind the camera? Or are those people hand-picked the day of the rally?
I don't think you have to sign up to be behind the camera, there's been events where speakers have been heckled or protested by people behind them.
 

Valhelm

contribute something
Great. Why do you care what the alt-right think? The more they invest themselves in insane and unbelievable conspiracy theories the less impact they will have on America. I'm excited that the Trump campaign has retreated to the #HillarysHealth smear which has basically zero plausibility among anybody who doesn't read Infowars. If they also talk about Clinton's secret relationship with a guy who came to one of her rallies that's even better.

Trump's poll numbers might be down, but the alt-right's social media presence allows their bullshit to quickly spread outside their small core of edgy millennials. Lots of white voters use Hillary's spurious KKK connection as proof that she's actually the racist one, and if this gaffe explodes on Facebook, Trump may get some more votes.
 

pigeon

Banned
Trump's poll numbers might be down, but the alt-right's social media presence allows their bullshit to quickly spread outside their small core of edgy millennials. Lots of white voters use Hillary's spurious KKK connection as proof that she's actually the racist one, and if this gaffe explodes on Facebook, Trump may get some more votes.

Who is this going to convince to vote for Trump that is not currently planning on voting for Trump?

Describe this target voter.
 

Valhelm

contribute something
Who is this going to convince to vote for Trump that is not currently planning on voting for Trump?

Describe this target voter.

Two weeks ago, Hillary was 2% above Trump in most polls. Now her lead is 13%.

As wildly different as Hillary and Trump are, 11% of voters can be swayed by two weeks' worth of events. What else could change their minds?
 
Yeah, not everyone has realized what an alt-right shit hole Reddit has become.

And, for the most part, Reddit is irrelevant! Like, seriously. If Reddit mattered, Bernie would be the nominee. A bunch of racist idiots want to try to make something that no major media channel even has on their front page a main story? Fine. No one in the real world cares what Reddit or the alt-right thinks about things.

I'm the first one to argue the optics of a situation. But, seriously. Who cares about Reddit? Is Reddit going to sway the Latino voter to vote Trump? The middle-class, suburban white soccer mom? Or is it just going to get a bunch of internet warrior dude bros all up in a huff about whatever they get in a huff about today?
 
Two weeks ago, Hillary was 2% above Trump in most polls. Now her lead is 13%.

As wildly different as Hillary and Trump are, 11% of voters can be swayed by two weeks' worth of events. What else could change their minds?

You're equating two completely unequal things.

On one hand we have an uninvited, unknown (to 99% of people) person making their way on stage at a public event, where the candidate praised police, first responders and pledged to support the victims....

And on the other we have a candidate who was dragged through the mud for a week at a well received convention, got into a fight with a baby, attacked a Gold Star family, refused to endorse his own Party's leadership, took a Purple Heart and said "That was easy," threatened to use nuclear weapons, and said that women who are sexually harassed should get a new career.

This doesn't take into account the plethora of GOPPERS who have come out and said Trump is dangerous....I mean, these two things are so far removed that I can't quite understand how one would think this has the potential to move the electorate.
 
Two weeks ago, Hillary was 2% above Trump in most polls. Now her lead is 13%.

As wildly different as Hillary and Trump are, 11% of voters can be swayed by two weeks' worth of events. What else could change their minds?

I think the conventions were really just turning points of people realizing a Trump presidency could actually be a reality and then his week after the DNC reinforced that scary thought.
 

Link

The Autumn Wind
Trump's poll numbers might be down, but the alt-right's social media presence allows their bullshit to quickly spread outside their small core of edgy millennials. Lots of white voters use Hillary's spurious KKK connection as proof that she's actually the racist one, and if this gaffe explodes on Facebook, Trump may get some more votes.

Two weeks ago, Hillary was 2% above Trump in most polls. Now her lead is 13%.

As wildly different as Hillary and Trump are, 11% of voters can be swayed by two weeks' worth of events. What else could change their minds?
Even Diablos would think you're overreacting.
 

pigeon

Banned
Two weeks ago, Hillary was 2% above Trump in most polls. Now her lead is 13%.

As wildly different as Hillary and Trump are, 11% of voters can be swayed by two weeks' worth of events. What else could change their minds?

I feel like this is just an argument from uncertainty, out of the old "HOW CAN WE KNOW ANYTHING REALLY" playbook.

Hillary accumulated leftist voters who were uncertain and moderate Republicans who fear Trump. More moderate Republicans became undecided or third-party as they began paying more attention to the election and were repelled by Trump's ongoing antisocial behavior and the consistent evidence that he is a terrible person.

I don't think any of those people are going to give a shit about an alt-right meme. You can't just argue that people see things and change their minds and you can't explain that. Marketing is a targeted effort.

For this guy to matter to you requires a mental structure something like this:

1. Our government is soft on Islamic terrorism.
2. We should be more aggressive both with people who are terrorists and with their families, who share the blame. (OR) We should be much more aggressive in condemning Islam in America in general.
3. Hillary allowed this Islamic guy who is associated with a mass shooter to go to her rally and sit on camera.
4. This demonstrates that she will continue to be soft on Islamic terrorism.

I submit that by the time you get to 2 you are already voting for Trump. Note that this is the beginner-level belief structure. You can also go the advanced route of believing that Hillary is in a secret conspiracy with Islamists including Barack Obama to fill our country with terrorists, and that this global conspiracy let a guy go to Hillary's rally and sit in camera view to deliberately taunt those who are trying to destroy it. But, again, those people are probably not saying "I'm just not sure about Trump."
 

thebloo

Member
I mean, I'm not happy this happened, but, seriously, if the person makes it through security what else is supposed to happen?

They should build a wall around the stage.

Screw "optics". The DNC was about not giving into fear and hate. Demonizing this man is opposite of everything this election is supposed to be about. And it's not like she invited the man. He was just there.
 
I think the polls will definitely tighten slightly by the end of the year. No chance of getting the House. Also, Georgia and Arizona are still out of reach this year.

I don't know how I feel about Norh Carolina. The demographic argument is interesting.
 

Valhelm

contribute something
I don't think Mateen's presence alone will help Trump, but it opens a line of attack for Trump's campaign.

No Hillary voters will switch sides, but I do think little gaffes like this can change the the mind of casual racists who are ambivalent towards Trump. Soccer moms and white-collar workers who are bothered by demographic change but don't like Trump enough to vote for him.

You know how most Trump supporters insist they're only being hateful in self-defense? I think this kind thing can be exploited to promote Trump's narrative of defending America and its values. Omar Mateen's father in a photo with Hillary Clinton justifies these delusions to some people.
 
Describing the target voter who would be affected by Mateen sitting in the audience reminds me of how the "missing white voters" theory of Trump supporters was doomed from the beginning.

"What if there are hardcore racist white voters out there looking to vote for a white nationalist who didn't bother to vote against a black guy named Barack Hussein Obama?"
 

dramatis

Member
I think the polls will definitely tighten slightly by the end of the year. No chance of getting the House. Also, Georgia and Arizona are still out of reach this year.

I don't know how I feel about Norh Carolina. The demographic argument is interesting.
So you have become Kristrawberry?
 

Piecake

Member
Don Trump’s frustration is palpable.

"Every day I get at least one comment," he tells me, gruffly, over the phone. "I rue the day my forefathers took the name."

To be clear, this is not the schismatic Republican candidate. This is a 62-year-old from Virginia, who works as a technician and prides himself as a "free-loving Democrat." But today, Don has become a guilty-by-association casualty of the prominent Trump’s antics: He cannot hand over his credit card in a restaurant without being chided. He is coaxed into political debates at backyard barbecues.

Armed with quick one-liner retorts — "No relation"; "Not my uncle"; "I’m with Hillary" — he lives in a perennial state of verbal self-defense. Since the election, his surname has become a gadfly.

Won't someone think of the other Trumps?

http://www.vox.com/2016/8/9/12411282/trumps-in-america-last-name
 
I think the polls will definitely tighten slightly by the end of the year. No chance of getting the House. Also, Georgia and Arizona are still out of reach this year.

I don't know how I feel about Norh Carolina. The demographic argument is interesting.

Their restrictive voter ID laws were shut down too IIRC.
 
Yeah, not everyone has realized what an alt-right shit hole Reddit has become.

Who'd have thought r/politics would turn into the anti-Trump oasis in the desert of stupidity

The swing from "WE HATE HILLARY ARGGRGGR" to "We like Hillary now, Trump is a piece of garbage" in the span of 2 weeks.

Of course, the Don is blaming Correct the Record, but it's more likely just the dramatic swing of opinion the entire country had.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom