Support NeoGAF

[Vazra]

Was this the fastest OT in the PopGaf history? Seems like it.

 

[Mumei]

You know in your heart the right answer.

Or maybe I'll write you an essay about it. lol

Speaking of, I was gonna do an ARTPOP review but thought it might get paid dust (except for some sass from Godels), so I might just do a top 20 Christina songs countdown instead.

I would be here for this, but you should do a joint Bey-Xtina Top 20 countdown (e.g. Top 20 for both, as opposed to comparing them directly).

 

[botty]

Was this the fastest OT in the PopGaf history? Seems like it.

It would have been if not for the deletion. So in actuality, it will be the longest with 30k+ posts.

 

[You Know Nothing]

Neither is ARTPOP Gaga.

And you won't see me disagreeing about that tbh.

 

[Vazra]

It would have been if not for the deletion. So in actuality, it will be the longest with 30k+ posts.

It has been a nice and active thread. Congratz on the OT botty (Despite not updating the OP since September)

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

Skip to 4:00



She does have a lot of great tools to use but she overuses them and they can become annoying and sometimes tries to do more than she can really chew at times. If she didnt go through her melisma screeching boiling kettle sounds too often she would be doing better.

Yes. I guess that's what I'm trying to get at.

@ Botty At least she doesn't sound like a truck engine starting up

 

[Soulscribe]

I would be here for this, but you should do a joint Bey-Xtina Top 20 countdown (e.g. Top 20 for both, as opposed to comparing them directly).

Oh I thought I did one for Bey already. Oop

But yeah I can do that. I was gonna do another Gaga countdown to include the ARTPOP material but I'll wait on that ;___;

Jeez are we already close to a new OT? We post way too much. I blame Natalia Kills.

 

[You Know Nothing]

Kind of impossible to do a top twenty hasBeyn countdown when she doesn't even have twenty good songs to begin with.

 

[Mumei]

Oh I thought I did one for Bey already. Oop

Did you?

I don't read every page, so I could have missed it.

Kind of impossible to do a top twenty hasBeyn countdown when she doesn't even have twenty good songs to begin with.

She (probably) does.

Spoiler

Maybe.

Spoiler

I'd have to actually look at her discography to see how many I like

 

[Vazra]

Oh I thought I did one for Bey already. Oop

But yeah I can do that. I was gonna do another Gaga countdown to include the ARTPOP material but I'll wait on that ;___;

You can always do a revised version of Bey. Afterall your opinions might have changed on some of the songs you have on the list. You make good articles so I wouldn't mind revised lists from you afterall you do a great work at that.

Jeez are we already close to a new OT? We post way too much. I stan Natalia Kills.

Stan.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

Kind of impossible to do a top twenty hasBeyn when she doesn't even have twenty good songs to begin with.

Probably not 20, but at least ten for sure.

 

[You Know Nothing]

Naughty Girl better be on the list. That's all I'm sayin'.

 

[Weapxn]

Probably not 20, but at least ten for sure.

Maybe if you count features.

 

[You Know Nothing]

Maybe if you count features.

nojdfhjhfjahjkfhjashdkjha

You didn't lie, though.

 

[botty]

It has been a nice and active thread. Congratz on the OT botty (Despite not updating the OP since September)

evilore deleting all my work with the first thread made me not want to update anymore.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

Naughty Girl better be on the list. That's all I'm sayin'.

Of course. In no order:

Crazy in Love
Naughty Girl
I Was Here
Countdown
Single Ladies
Irreplaceable
Check on It
If I Were a Boy
Halo
Best Thing I Never Had

 

[Matt_]

 

[Vazra]

evilore deleting all my work with the first thread made me not want to update anymore.

Yet this thread exists...

As for Beyonce in no particular order

• Survivor
• Bills Bills Bills
• Say My Name
• Bootylicious
• Lose My Breath
• Jumpin Jumpin
• Confession
• Independent Woman
• Brown Eyes
• Crazy in Love
• Naughty Girl
• Deja Vu
• Freakum Dress
• Get Me bodied
• Love on top
• Schoolin Life
• Irreplaceable
• Check On it
• Baby Boy
• Me, Myself and I

 

[SilentSoldier]

I think it's time for a POP-GAF field trip.

Will Paula Patton be there?

 

[You Know Nothing]

Of course. In no order:

Crazy in Love (with Jesus)
Naughty Girlsus
I Was Flopped Here
Countdown (To the End of Your Fave's Career)
Single Ladies (Waiting in the Unemployment Line Because This Song Slays)
Irreplaceable Replaceable
Check on It (Your Fave's Wig Is Burning)
If I Were a Boy Flop
Halo Trashlo
Best Worst Thing I Never Ever Had Made

My revisions.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

My revisions.

Not you coming for I Was Here (with God)

 

[RobotChant]

So I looked up Marlboro Lights and no wonder no one knows Natalia. Too much realness for just a popstar. Radio ain't ready for someone so trill.

 

[You Know Nothing]

The masturbatory nature of I Flopped Here would be endearing if it wasn't hasBeyn singing it and me knowing she means every single word.

An arrogant mess.

 

[Vazra]

So I looked up Marlboro Lights and no wonder no one knows Natalia. Too much realness for just a popstar. Radio ain't ready for someone so trill.

STAN.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

I guess I can forgive your lack of taste this one time for showing me that ocean song

 

[You Know Nothing]

You need to get into the b-side already, though. I think I'm starting to prefer Something In My Heart to Running to the Sea.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

I will later. I'm currently worshiping another Swedish queen

Side note: I just used the word "reductive" in my paper.

 

[You Know Nothing]

 

[Vazra]

Pink Top 20​

IN NO PARTICULAR ORDER​

• There You Go
• Just Like a Pill
• Get This Party Started
• Most Girls
• You Make Me Sick
• Family Portrait
• Don't Let Me Get Me
• Do What U Do
• Can't Take Me Home
• Dear Mr. President
• U + Ur Hand
• Trouble
• Oh My God
• Who Knew
• Glitter in The Air
• Respect
• Sober
• Funhouse
• Try
• Just Give Me a Reason
• Blow Me (One Last Kiss)

 

[Soulscribe]

"Worst Thing I Ever Made"

Screaming

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

That Pink picture

asdasdasfsadasfsDSCADFADAS

 

[You Know Nothing]

St!nk having twenty good songs, now that's a good one.

Australia's infatuation with her is unexplainable.

 

[Vazra]

That Pink picture

asdasdasfsadasfsDSCADFADAS

This used to be a funhouse
But now it's full of evil clowns
It's time to start the countdown
I'm gonna burn it down down down

St!nk having twenty good songs, now that's a good one.

Australia's infatuation with her is unexplainable.

I ain't Australian tho.

 

[You Know Nothing]

Oh, I know. I was just making an offhand comment.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

waiT why is Just Give Me A Reason on that list

Pupi, sis....

 

[Vazra]

waiT why is Just Give Me A Reason on that list

Pupi, sis....

I might hate the fun guy but the song its cute.

 

[You Know Nothing]

Poor St!nk. Try is her only good song and it's not even hers originally.

 

[Touchdown]

Mariah Carey ‏@MariahCarey
Shout out to @Pink, a great artist & a risk taker musically. ♥

I approve.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

I might hate the fun guy but the song its cute.

 

[You Know Nothing]

Mariah Carey ‏@MariahCarey
Shout out to @Pink, a great artist & a risk taker musically. ♥

I don't mean to question Mariahsus, but what? She's been peddling the same songs and schtick for years and years. Anything but a risk taker.

 

[Vazra]

Do not worry if I see him in person I would still kick him in the balls so he can continue reaching his notes.

 

[twobear]

@ Botty At least she doesn't sound like a truck engine starting up

like an all-goose gang fight

 

[Yado]

...a risk taker musically

Does she really know who Pink is?

 

[Touchdown]

Does she really know who Pink is?

Probably not tbh...

 

[You Know Nothing]

St!nk is one of the safest most boring artists we currently have. She literally hasn't changed at all in over a decade.

 

[WhereAreMahDragonz]

I still use U + Ur Hand tho

 

[Touchdown]

St!nk is one of the safest most boring artists we currently have. She literally hasn't changed at all in over a decade.

To play devil's advocate though, who's fave has actually "changed" that much over time?

 

[Vazra]

Natalia Kills Top 20 Songs​

In No Particular Order​

• Television
• Problem
• Stop Me
• Boys Don’t Cry
• Daddy’s Girl
• Saturday Night
• Devil Don’t Fly
• Outta Time
• Controversy
• Rabbit Hole
• Watching You
• Marlboro Lights
• Trouble
• Wonderland
• Free
• Kill My Boyfriend
• Mirrors
• Broken
• Heaven
• If I Was God

 

[You Know Nothing]

They have changed at least somewhat, though. Trying out different sounds and aesthetics.

Pink's literally been nothing but "Look at me and how punk and rebellious I am. Listen to these songs which totally convey how much I don't give a fuck."

That's all she's about and that's all she's ever been about since she first popped up as an anti-Britney and Xtina in the late 90's.

 

[Trigger]

To play devil's advocate though, who's fave has actually "changed" that much over time?

Madonna?