So, in my efforts in finding the new drums today, I managed to stumble into my local Gamestop who ended up not only having them, but the new Fender Precision Bass as well. I have been waiting a long time to get my hands on it, so I ended up dropping $170 for the both of them. Not being a drummer, I can't really comment much on the drums outside of stuff that was immediately obvious (they sound as quiet as having drum silencers on the old kit, they feel a LOT sturdier, more sensitive to hits), but the bass.
Oh.
My.
God.
With the exception of the upcoming GH:WT guitar, I have a lot of experience with many of the guitars they've put out and I think that I can say that the P-Bass is probably the best one of all. Getting down to basics first, it's a very solid build; there's enough weight to it to feel good while not being heavy at all. The frest are also well-made; they're a great mix of Rock Band's general layout (which I've always adored) with the feel of the Les Paul frets, giving you a nice, quiet time while you go up and down. The strumbar might be the real revelation, though; much has been made of the split nature of it, but just playing on one should convince you; it has a very soft click when you go up and down that while it isn't nearly as quiet as the stock Fender, it's still very quiet and easily trounces the others in that department. It has the same snap as the Les Paul, but has the same mobility as the Fender, giving you a real "best of both worlds" design that's hard to argue with. Most important for bassists, though, is the addition of the thumb rest that lies about inch above the strumbar. It gives your thumb something to hold onto while you upstrum, making it not just more authentic but that much more pleasing to play on. The split strum works like you imagine it would. For upstrummers like me, it really adds so much to the game.
The downfalls are due to them trying to replicate an actual bass as much as they did, which put many of the buttons on knobs. It's a bit confusing to "turn" Start to pause the game as it's nothing you've ever had to do before, but I can see myself getting used to it. Perhaps the most controversial decision was nixing the whammy completely, putting it on a knob that lies a few inches down from the strumbar. It makes it more authentic, but turning a knob like mad just isn't the same as wailing on the whammy bar.
I can forgive those issues since the positives outweigh them by magnitudes. If you want further proof as to how great the P-Bass is, all you need to know is that you can actually twist the tuning heads to your heart's desire. I am in love with this fake instrument, and you should be, too.