• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Sega Genesis/MegaDrive Appreciation Thread: Alien Storm > Golden Axe

This Interact controller is currently my favorite. Great d-pad, responsive face buttons, no hard convex X Y Z buttons, and rapid/auto fire for all six buttons.

controllerSnazy.jpg
 

Noahd41

Neo Member
Just bought a model 1 Genesis on ebay. It's coming with a 3 button controller and RF (yuck). I'm going to have to mod it for s-video. A couple questions:

  1. Is the 6-button controller worth having? I have zero interest in fighting games FWIW. I had one of these controllers as a kid but I don't remember anything about it.
  2. Are there any JP only Mega Drive games worth owning? I'm thinking about widening the cartridge slot but since it turned out not so great for my Super Famicom I'd rather not unless there are games that make it worth it.

Six button is the way to go. It's unreal how much of a superior controller it is.
 
Thanks everyone. I'm pretty picky about dpads so I bought a JP 6-button controller.

I also thought about buying a SNES to Genesis adapter from Raphnet since I already have a bunch of great condition Super Famicom controllers but I figured I might as well go for the authentic experience.
 

Mercutio

Member
Just bought a model 1 Genesis on ebay. It's coming with a 3 button controller and RF (yuck). I'm going to have to mod it for s-video. A couple questions:

  1. Is the 6-button controller worth having? I have zero interest in fighting games FWIW. I had one of these controllers as a kid but I don't remember anything about it.
  2. Are there any JP only Mega Drive games worth owning? I'm thinking about widening the cartridge slot but since it turned out not so great for my Super Famicom I'd rather not unless there are games that make it worth it.

The 6 button controller is both more comfortable (for me) and has a Saturn-Grade D-Pad. I think it's far superior to the original 3 button varieties, of all vintages.
 

Slermy

Member
This Interact controller is currently my favorite. Great d-pad, responsive face buttons, no hard convex X Y Z buttons, and rapid/auto fire for all six buttons.

controllerSnazy.jpg

What are some other gaffer's favorite 3rd party controllers? I absolutely adored this one as a kid:

The programmable function was pretty neat to play with and it had autofire!

I don't like it quite as much as the MK-1653 these days, but I think it's still a pretty good controller, even though it uses a SNES style layout.
 

Teknoman

Member
Just bought a model 1 Genesis on ebay. It's coming with a 3 button controller and RF (yuck). I'm going to have to mod it for s-video. A couple questions:

  1. Is the 6-button controller worth having? I have zero interest in fighting games FWIW. I had one of these controllers as a kid but I don't remember anything about it.
  2. Are there any JP only Mega Drive games worth owning? I'm thinking about widening the cartridge slot but since it turned out not so great for my Super Famicom I'd rather not unless there are games that make it worth it.

Just get a game genie. And yes, unless you want to go the repro route, Alien Soldier, Trouble Shooter 2, Pulseman (might not be all that worth it, but looks cool), Verytex, Eliminate Down, and probably other games with better differences / possibly cheaper.
 
The MK-1653 6 button controller are the best ones that are easily available. I like to buy the 3rd party 6 button controllers from performance(they usually gor for less than 5 bucks whenever I find them) and take the rubber contacts to put into the MK-1653. Buttons feel better.

Though there is one 3rd party controller that looks to be comparable to the official controllers, the Competition Pro Series III, but I can't for the life of me find one anywhere,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lxfGR3RRIsI

Basically a 6 button controller with the original dogbone girth the original 3 button controller has. SEGA has a wireless 6 button controller that would have been GOAT if it was actually wired.
 

Lord_Santa

Neo Member
The Mega Drive was the first gaming console I ever had. So it has a special place in my heart. I remember playing Sonic,The Ooze, Revenge of the Shinobi, X-Men and Streets of Rage with such glee. I was young back then, so I had a very active imagination, I recall one incident where I had a nightmare about one of the games I was playing (can't remember which) and got banned from playing for a week.

Those were the days :)
 
http://r.ebay.com/tMAOAd

Someone trying to pass off a repro? Or just uninformed?

Description says it's only for the cart and booklet, which I suppose acknowledges that the clamshell case it a reprint. This makes sense as the Genesis release is cardboard only.
I would request more pics (especially of the PCB) and a more detailed description if you're spending that kind of money though.
 
Description says it's only for the cart and booklet, which I suppose acknowledges that the clamshell case it a reprint. This makes sense as the Genesis release is cardboard only.
I would request more pics (especially of the PCB) and a more detailed description if you're spending that kind of money though.

The cart has the modern ESRB rating icon (solid black KA instead of white with a black outline). Dead giveaway that it's a repro.
 

Khaz

Member
If anyone is interested in getting Pier Solar, I think now would be a great time. My order has already shipped!

They told me they change it to "shipped" when they print the sticker. It doesn't means it has left their warehouse or even been put in a box.

I waited for mine for about a month, but I live in the same city.

It's still a good time to order one copy though, it's probably their last batch ever.
 

Mercutio

Member
If anyone is interested in getting Pier Solar, I think now would be a great time. My order has already shipped!

Anyone who buys is advised to be careful about system compatibility, though. My VA6 Genesis couldn't run the game. As far as I know, that's the only model that truly cannot run it at all, and this advisement only applies to the print run.
 

Teknoman

Member
So with all the modding, homebrew, and indie stuff going on these days, would it be possible at all for a team to take Phantasy Star 1, make it playable on a Genesis but with the FM sound version of the soundtrack, complete with repro label/cartridge and everything?
 
So with all the modding, homebrew, and indie stuff going on these days, would it be possible at all for a team to take Phantasy Star 1, make it playable on a Genesis but with the FM sound version of the soundtrack, complete with repro label/cartridge and everything?

I doubt it. I assume they'd need to reprogram the music entirely because the FM chips in the Genesis and the FM Module for Sega Mark III are different.
 
My Genesis arrived today. It's a VA6 and I was expecting a VA3. Not sure I'm concerned enough to return it but it'll probably warrant negative feedback for the thing not being as described.

Am I crazy or does RF not actually look that bad? I must be crazy. My s-video / RCA jacks will get here sometime later this month so I'm still going to mod that in but I feel like RF on this looks better than the composite coming out of my SNES or PS1.

So with all the modding, homebrew, and indie stuff going on these days, would it be possible at all for a team to take Phantasy Star 1, make it playable on a Genesis but with the FM sound version of the soundtrack, complete with repro label/cartridge and everything?

You could do it with the FM power base converter that db electronics makes but I think that would be kind of a waste.
 

Teknoman

Member

televator

Member
Welp. I just sent back my Mega EverDrive for a refund. It's a finicky piece of tech that I just couldn't get working for some reason. I don't know what was wrong. Either something I was doing, or my hardware wasn't playing nice with it, or it was just broken... I mean it's not rocket science and I tried it on 4 Genesis systems that swapped with 5 different power supplies. One of them was a model 2 and that made no difference.

Well at least I can hope to get most of my money back on it, but man... What a bust.
 

D.Lo

Member
Im still surprised no one has just made a repro cart with the translated rom. At least then you could just roll with the original system no problem or the Power Base mini FM. At least Golvellius isnt like that heh.
It's just too specific a market. The Master System FM board and Power Base Mini FM are niche products, you'd need a system with one of those or a Mark III with FM unit to be in the market for one. So a fraction of a fraction of a market.

I'll make one if you like, It will be an Everdrive with a single ROM in it. Easy enough to print a cart label. Heck, can even just use the original cart and box! It'll be $300 thanks ;)

Or you mean a Power Base+Mark III board with custom ROM integrated into a Mega Drive cart shell? That would be prohibitively expensive, requiring a custom PCB.
 

Teknoman

Member
Well what I was thinking was take a english Phantasy Star 1 cart, get someone to flash it(?) with that PS1 translated rom, and then use that cart to play on the Power Base mini FM.
 
Took apart my Genesis a bit more and did some tinkering. I got it running off a USB power supply. :) Basically just bypass the 7805s and supply 5V directly.

I did something similar with my SNES and I really like the result so I'll probably make this permanent tomorrow. I think I just need to desolder the 7805s, wire the 7805 in lines to the out lines and see if I can give 5V through the existing barrel jack. That would be the cleanest way to do this. If not I'll have to rewire a few other things to make the power switch work. Then I can just throw out the heat sink and run this thing with no heat and way lower power use.

The one risk is someone who's not me plugging a >5V jack into this at some point in the future, but I think that's pretty unlikely and I'll leave some sort of notation just in case.
 

Fularu

Banned
It's just too specific a market. The Master System FM board and Power Base Mini FM are niche products, you'd need a system with one of those or a Mark III with FM unit to be in the market for one. So a fraction of a fraction of a market.

I'll make one if you like, It will be an Everdrive with a single ROM in it. Easy enough to print a cart label. Heck, can even just use the original cart and box! It'll be $300 thanks ;)

Or you mean a Power Base+Mark III board with custom ROM integrated into a Mega Drive cart shell? That would be prohibitively expensive, requiring a custom PCB.

Or you could just convert the translated SMS rom (with PGM/FM switch) to a genesis rom and flash it on a blank genesis eeprom and call it a day (and it would cost a grand total of... 7$? if you have the flasher that is)

Also there's no risk involved, the new flashable eeproms are reflashable.
 

televator

Member
Took apart my Genesis a bit more and did some tinkering. I got it running off a USB power supply. :) Basically just bypass the 7805s and supply 5V directly.

I did something similar with my SNES and I really like the result so I'll probably make this permanent tomorrow. I think I just need to desolder the 7805s, wire the 7805 in lines to the out lines and see if I can give 5V through the existing barrel jack. That would be the cleanest way to do this. If not I'll have to rewire a few other things to make the power switch work. Then I can just throw out the heat sink and run this thing with no heat and way lower power use.

The one risk is someone who's not me plugging a >5V jack into this at some point in the future, but I think that's pretty unlikely and I'll leave some sort of notation just in case.

That's super interesting. I've heard of modding more efficient power supplies into old consoles before but I wonder if it affects the ability to have other mods that require power like an over clock or anything with a discrete circuit.
 
That's super interesting. I've heard of modding more efficient power supplies into old consoles before but I wonder if it affects the ability to have other mods that require power like an over clock or anything with a discrete circuit.

I think as long as those mods all operate on the 5V section of the console and don't draw more amps than my USB power supply can handle they would work just fine. Since the Genesis wallwart only puts out 1A (and a bunch of that is used for a space heater from the 7805s) and my Sony adapter puts out 1.5A I think that would be fine.

Another thing to note is that the quality of your adapter matters a lot here. I'll have to check if the same thing happens with my Genesis but on my SNES many USB AC adapters would cause horrible artifacts to appear on the video output, I think because they didn't put out a very stable 5Vs. When connected to a PC USB jack it was fine, and the only wall adapters I could find that would work perfectly were a proper Apple USB AC adapter (don't even try knockoffs, they could be super dangerous) and Sony's xperia USB AC adapter.
 

Khaz

Member
Well what I was thinking was take a english Phantasy Star 1 cart, get someone to flash it(?) with that PS1 translated rom, and then use that cart to play on the Power Base mini FM.

That's possible, I did it with the Japanese cartridge. But you can't just change the ROM chip on most 8bits games, if they're bigger than 512k they need an extra proprietary chip. If the extra chip is on the board, you're good, but most of the games had the extra chip integrated within the ROM chip. And you can't replace that with a normal eeprom, it just won't work.

Some cartridges are susceptible to some mod like this, however I would advise against it as they are already rare enough, and the pool will never grow back. There are plans to make new cartridges for this very purpose, that would allow homebrewers to make new physical releases without murdering old games. Or people to play new translations like the Phantasy Star one.
 

D.Lo

Member
Or you could just convert the translated SMS rom (with PGM/FM switch) to a genesis rom and flash it on a blank genesis eeprom and call it a day (and it would cost a grand total of... 7$? if you have the flasher that is)

Also there's no risk involved, the new flashable eeproms are reflashable.
You do know that would involve porting the game, including re-writing the music for a completely different FM chip, which would be an immense amount of work?
 
Top Bottom