To be honest games as art and the future of gaming as a medium are two topics that I don't think about and therefore I don't have much to say. But I would be interested in reading/participating in other discussions about game design.
Pretty much where i'm at right now.
I can see how you guys can feel that way, for me it's been awhile since I discussed the topic and it was hard writing it without the inspiration from seeing statements from other people I may disagree with. I hope the thread itself doesn't come off as pretentious or anything as most of those types of discussions do in order to legitimize an opinion.
I think I've been on GAF for about 3 months now, and while I got carried away with having fun with the other discussions on most of these threads, I wanted to return to my initial reason for coming here in the first place and promote that kind of discussion.
Usually when it's brought up, I usually hear people discuss it in terms of narrative or making it "mature"/validate it as a hobby for adults/etc, which a lot I've disagreed with, and even felt that those mentalities were hindering it's evolution, especially when you consider the options we have when it comes to gaming, game design, control schemes, etc. I know that there are some devs that are more motivated to make gaming like film, and while I understand that we can learn or become inspired from film, attempts to emulate the medium is anything but the way to go.
I think about when people may consider games that may seem
artsy/intellectual or narrative-driven as what makes video games art, due to the idea of them having "meaning", while ignoring everything else the core of what I believe truly is the art of a game (mechanics, gamplay, design). Therefore games that may not focus in being those type of psuedo-intellectual joints my not get as much love from the media or spotlight, despite being in the hands of a great player, it could look amazing. Or perhaps the puzzles and challenges may encourage you to approach everyday obstacles in life differently. As I say, "Shit like that."
*
"artsy/intellectual" may be one of those buzzwords I need to add to that list.