I don't know if I'd say Shattered Crystal was the better of the two Sonic Boom games. The more functional of the two, I guess, but Shattered Crystal felt like an empty, hollow void. A platformer template they inserted Sonic the Hedgehog in to. It was a completely joyless production, devoid of any kind of love, care, or craftsmanship.
It was a licensed game to a T, the very definition of "we're making this because we have to."
Rise of Lyric might've been a pile of burning garbage, but at least it was an interesting pile of burning garbage. Sure, on the surface it might seem similar in the "take a generic platformer template and put Sonic in it" way, but Rise of Lyric doesn't seem quite as cynical about it was Shattered Crystal did.
Like, Shattered Crystal aimed low and hit the target dead on, whereas Rise of Lyric was really going for something and missed the mark.
I don't know, I 'respected' SC more as it knew it was a Sonic game and tried its best to be one....even if it wasn't close to the quality of titles like the Advance series or the Rush series.
RoL didn't
want to be a Sonic game, it wanted to be Jak and Daxter. I wouldn't have minded that....but it failed on that level so badly X(. So, all that's left is how it is a Sonic game....and it failed even worse there. Horrid combat system, blandest speed sections in the series and visuals that don't come close to matching Sonic Team's tittles. Overall disappointing mess that could have been a fun Jak 4 if it was finished and designed right....but it wasn't
.
Sanzaru knew what they were coming into with SC; a side-project based on the Sonic IP. So, they didn't put their complete heart and effort into like Sly 4 because...they didn't care about that game too much; it was a way to make some more money for future projects with other publishers. With Fire and Ice though, they
have to put their A game into the project, as people are coming into the tittle with RoL fresh in their minds; they expect this new game to be just as horrid as that game.
So, (I hope at least) they will feel motivated into putting a lot more care into SC, leading to a fun, solid 2D Sonic this year
.
Again, I enjoyed the demo of SC, so I enjoy their take on Sonic. I just hope they take it seriously as Sly 4.