Oddly, a word I never see mentioned is 'fashion' and yet that's one of the major factors for why older anime can be seen as being different to today's offerings. But this isn't actually an anime issue but a wider one. Fashion affects everything which is why 80s pop music is different to 10s pop music, 80s action flicks aren't as common in the 10s, and the less said about 80s outfits the better. Anime will just be a reflection of the current tastes in society.
But no, we get a blame game and have words like 'cute' and 'moe' thrown around.
So yeah, content by default may be different in 80s anime because fashion was different back then, but considering or dismissing a show primarily based on a broadcast date, which is how the thoughts of some of the people in that thread come across, is silly.
I guess that's my point, anime, and entertainment in general as you mentioned is a reflection of the current affairs and trends, and I guess I just don't
like the reflection I see today. Notice I never mentioned moe or cute, as that's irrelevant to me. A lot of the older shows I love have plenty cute and moe in them, whether that's Macross or Gunbuster or whatever. It's true that what's considered cute in anime
today isn't necessarily cute to me however, I'd admit that much, and that (cute stuff) alone has never been the driving force for getting me to watch anime, or anything.
When you look at it, things haven't changed all that much, cute girls doing cute things has always been a staple of anime, and that goes for the whole school kids piloting giant robots and the power of love and friendship saving the day and all of that good stuff included, it's always been there, that much is obvious. So those attributes by
themselves aren't the issue, but when it's the go to reason to watch a show, the hook so to speak, that's not for me, but I'm not against it. That'd be like complaining that a comedy has too many jokes, most of these shows make it clear what they strive to be.
Even art-style overall isn't the issue, as you get a Ping Pong and Aku no Hana for every generic anime, and a generic anime for every Patlabor and Akira, but the amount is so far and few between these days I feel, or is never really celebrated as much as they should be the wider audience, maybe that's the reason. People who watch and like older anime never feel truly in tune and welcomed by communities that like the newer stuff, so they look to like-minded people and regurgitate the same stuff with each other, because a person posting about DYRL to a community that already loves that type of content, will get more positive reaction with the acknowledgement and discussion that comes with it, whereas it can be a tougher sell to a community of people who are interested in the latest season of whatever. It's not an either or situation, and many people
miraculously break the wall and enjoy *
shock horror!* both old
and new anime, but maybe people who like older shows feel a disdain for the people who bastion 'new anime' (that's what I'm calling it), stemming from a feeling of being left behind, when that may not actually be the case. People who like anime stick to anime communities, and people who like old and new anime stick to their own little community, scowling whenever they make eye contact with each other.
It goes without saying that, as evident in many threads and posts on GAF itself that a lot of people hate new anime for the sake of it, posting screens of
Kanon with every chance they get, and the fans of old anime alone being treated like crazy people who've lost the plot.
For me personally, I've always loved things that take themselves seriously, or strives to tell a story with no regards to the profitability or acceptance by the fan base, so Texhnolyze being an example from the 2000's, or Aku no Hana as a more recent example. You get them every now and again, and make no mistake, things like Macross and Patlabor were made to sell too, but I guess being older means that you don't have to deal with that filter, and that alone makes them more approachable. In any case, I like what I like, and don't like what...I don't like, and new isn't that, but like you said, the 'fashion' today certainly fits the bill.
Shitty post I know, one that doesn't need to be made, but whatever, just nod.