He speaks the truth. Star Wars, with its particular late 70s style mixed in with powerful nostalgia and 38 years of hype...I just don't think anything can compete with that. The game is rigged.
I don't think a new Star Wars, even if it's great, is even capable of becoming such a pillar of science fiction like the originals. It's a different era already saturated with SciFi. Nor will it be able to touch your heart the same way it did when you were watching the OT as a child.
I expect most reactions to TFA to be "It was good, better than the prequels, but it still doesn't compare to the OT." All I'm hoping for is that it feels like a real legitimate continuation of the lives of the characters I remember and not a What-If story.
Yea, I feel the same as you. While the hype levels for TFA have not come anywhere close to those prior to TPM, they're definitely going to rise high in the next 10 months. Expectations for TPM were out of this world - people didn't just expect a great SW movie, but a legitimately great movie. Some thought it would be the best movie ever.
TFA will be expected to be a great SW movie, great sequel to the OT, and in some cases a correction for issues with the PT. Marketing is going to be key. The trailers are probably going to downplay Luke and Leia (and possibly Han) so that expectations for those characters are kept in check. The biggest disappointment I can see people having is the recent rumors about Luke's even-smaller-than-expected role.
Some will think TFA is a worthy continuation of the OT. Most will probably say better than the PT, not as good as the OT. Others will think TFA is not as good as the PT. Overall, the SW fanbase will be further splintered and have even more nonsense about which to argue for years to come.