spazzfish said:
I don't really disagree, but the Nydus just seems so situational that it is almost pointless.
For a tier 2 building and it's cost, I can't really see where you could fit it in. As priority at tier 2 you go for muta or hydra (muta probably as preference). Then your in the situation where you think do I build a nydus and try and plant a worm or just build/tech more mutas/hydra or you might by then realise you need some hydras to go with your muta or visa versa.
If you have the spare resources then if I haven't got it earlier i'd rather have a few banelings or just research load for the overlord. You need overlords anyway and you'll need an overlord where you want to drop your worm to create the creep (probably) so if your at your drop site with overlords anyway why not just use them to carry over your units, it's cheaper.
It's not the fact that you can't probably use it to a good effect, but there just seems to be better alternatives that kind of makes the nydus redundant.
Nydus is so much better than OL drop it's not even funny.
For one, your units aren't vulnerable to sniping during transit.
Also it allows you to pump reinforcements in if you successfully grab a beachhead.
Banelings are nice for breaking a wall, but you still have to funnel your units through a narrow choke or a ramp after that. Nydus allows you to pop your units up where the enemy has no defense.
Even if the guy is smart and has vision of his entire base, you can still pop one down if his army gets out of position(or if he just isn't paying enough attention) and it will finish well before his army has a chance of getting back to defend. The threat of nydus can force an enemy to be less aggressive with his army, or leave some units back to defend the back of his base.
I've seen this work wonders against terran mech or protoss robo builds, as it takes forever to move those armies around. Hell, nydus the back of his base with just a handful of units, and then rush his front door as he's panicking trying to kill the worm.
I personally don't use it much(or OL drops, or banelings) because I go with a ling muta build, cause the speed of mutas make it more effective for me.. Occasionally if I see a terran spending a crap ton on turrets, i will down tech to roach/speedling and drop a nydus somewhere in his base. That kind of switch catches almost everyone by surprise. They think they got the muta problem under control, then bam, they have like 60 speedlings in their mineral lines.
Not like nydus is that expensive either, 250/300 in total is cheap when you consider the damage it can do.