Okay, I just did the Call of Juarez 2 preorder, and I started Call of Juarez 1 for the first time.
I am honestly...blown away. I played Crysis Warhead and I've seen tons of Crysis screenshots and unplayable-quality screenshots, but this game looks REALLY freaking good. I don't even have everything cranked up, and I'm going to have to turn stuff down. Anti-aliasing is only 2x and I'm doing bilinear or trilinear filtering. There's not motion blur as far as I know. My 4850 is getting to really unsafe temperatures, and I'm scared for my CPU/motherboard/memory, so I might not play until I get a better cooler, but even so, the framerate barely ever even stuttered.
Oh, and I'm playing the DX10 version on 64-bit Windows 7 beta, since I haven't installed the RC yet.
Unfortunately I don't have pictures since it doesn't seem to include a screenshot button, and print screen doesn't work. I'll have to use Fraps or write my own screenshot utility, I suppose.
Maybe it's just late at night and I'm deceived by high-resolution textures, but honestly, the whole atmosphere, scope, smoothness, sound (the MUSIC! the birds!), environment (the BUTTERFLY that just flew past me), flowers, clover leaves, etc. is amazing. The scope of mountains and a town in the distance is nice, and I don't think I noticed a single instance of pop-in, or texture resolution changing in an abrupt fashion as I got closer. I think I've also heard this game doesn't feature a lot of loading screens, and if that's the case, I'm totally okay with the 1-2 minute load at the start of the map, while the voiceover story plays.
Voice acting as far as I can tell is pretty awesome, for this and the sequel. Clouds move, the sky is bright, shadows under bushes wave as they blow in the breeze.
Minor negatives so far: Bottles breaking in the tutorial didn't seem convincing, I'm not sure there was a very satisfying glass sound.
It would be nice if there was a run button. The waterfall near the beginning doesn't look very realistic though that might be a graphical glitch on my system? It looks like little pee-colored water droplet sprays falling down the rocks. I guess bushes also don't really stir much as you go through them. I can't remember if there's a sound for you making your way through them, but at least they don't get in your way. I've only moved one box, but I have a feeling it's the Half-life 2 "massless box" style of moving things around. All of these things might be considered negatives, but they don't really bother me that much. Your mileage may vary.
I'm sure there will be problems, but overall, I think I'm really going to enjoy this, and I'm kind of shocked that I haven't seen this game show up in the high-res PC thread. If I get screenshot capabilities going, I'll try to put some there myself.
*itsbeautifulcat.jpg*