It's been nice so far. Their records of the month I've received are:What's vinyl me please like? What records have you gotten?
Madvillain - Madvillainy
RL Burnside -Too Bad Jim
Perfume Genius - Too Bright
Ben Webster Quintet - Soulville
Youth Lagoon - The Year of Hibernation
Father John Misty - I Love You Honeybear
J Dilla - Donuts
Menomena - Friend & Foe
Torres - Sprinter
So they're still developing and listening to their subscribers on how to make the selections better or varied and even down to the minutia of having propylene lined inner bags for the records of the month to prevent splits and damage in shipping (I have been lucky so far and have not had any major issues, their shipping boxes are incredibly sturdy and well made and they have the phrase "for the Love of music, please do not bend" slapped prominently on both sides).
Their customer service is fantastic, seems to be a small crew of people running this thing and the head guys are all very personable and post in the member only forums and actively engage and answer pretty much any questions you throw at them.
Like I said before they're still developing the process on how they Choose the record of the month, but it seems like the formula they've got currently works. A couple of those albums (perfume genius/Torres/FJM) I might've never listened to in the first place, but now I'd gladly put I love you Honeybear in my top ten of the year easily.
All that and they have a private store that is just now starting to get special, just for them, pressings of Out of print stuff starting this month is pretty rad (that and they're open to price matching before their shop opens at the end of the month if you manage to find a record they're selling cheaper elsewhere). But yea having a private store to pick stuff that might be tough to find otherwise is great.
Overall I'm very pleased with what they've offered as their monthly record and what they sell in their store. Their prices are more than fair, shipping is free for domestic subscribers, their art prints that come with the monthly are usually rad as shit and the drink selection they prepare are tasty as hell.
I think it's a great service and would gladly endorse it as long as prospective subscribers are open, I mean genuinely open to new music. I mean you can go flip them later but damn why would you?