In a way, yes, but these aren't isolated elements. Binary Domain's shooter mechanics are fantastic and killing regular enemies feels super good, but TLOU has way more going for it outside of that, which also elevate it as a TPS. It's like...
Bayo has amazing combat mechanics. However, if the rest of the game was absolute garbage (as in art style, world and enemy design, pacing et cetera), it'd harm the game severely. That wouldn't mean it wouldn't have amazing combat mechanics anymore, but I wouldn't say it's the best stylish action game. But since everything else about the game is fantastic, these also greatly compliment the stylish action element of said game, pushing it up to god tier.
Again, look at everything surrounding it. What makes the shooting so satisfying isn't just the shooting itself, it's the nagging background reasoning about ammo preservation, the visual feedback, the dynamic nature of these gunfights et cetera.
Sure. I just disagree. Finished TLOU three times, whereas I'm not going to play BD again.