• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Super Best Friends Thread 8: "You know, we really are the Super Best Friends Play"

Status
Not open for further replies.

joe2187

Banned
That's really disappointing, especially after Persona furthered that trend, I was hoping that more games would start to do the VN styled story mode. Oh well, I probably won't be able to afford it anyway.

I was hoping it was like P4A's as well.

Oh well, get Hyped for GGXRD: HYPER CLIMAX IZUNA DROP EX
 

Xiraiya

Member
It's similar enough where someone is using aesthetic design choice to generally argue that something shouldn't exist despite any other substantive and positive elements of the game.

Oh bullshit you lot know what DOA is and why it exists, stop kidding yourselves, I would have less of a problem with it if people were just honest about it and said "Yes I just want play a fighting game and have it make me rock hard at the same time."
I'm not comparing DOA to anything else because it is what it is, the context is entirely different to Bayonetta, anyone comparing the two are flat out retarded.

I'm not even that big of a fan of Bayonetta, I just thought that should be obvious.

Anyway, I've said my piece.
 
Oh bullshit you lot know what DOA is and why it exists, stop kidding yourselves, I would have less of a problem with it if people were just honest about it and said "Yes I just want play a fighting game and have it make me rock hard at the same time."
I'm not comparing DOA to anything else because it is what it is, the context is entirely different to Bayonetta, anyone comparing the two are flat out retarded.

I'm not even that big of a fan of Bayonetta, I just thought that should be obvious.

I'm not even a fan of DOA and I don't agree with this stance at all. Sure, something can be aesthetically pleasing, but if that's all there is then people wouldn't keep playing it. Vanguard Princess is visually awesome with a ton of fanservice, but supremely mediocre in gameplay so nobody plays it.

I love Arcana Heart visually and mechanically, I enjoy both together and apart.
 
You could just not download the DLC. It's how they make their money after implementing the f2p.

DLC was meant to support F2P. That's why there's so much of it, and why it's so pandering.

It clearly worked, seeing that it still comes out. I don't mind, because I'm not out there buuying every pack. Just the ones that I want.

The point wasn't that the pervy stuff was DLC, I just said that because of how creepy the DLC costumes can get. The fact that it's even in the game puts me off quite a bit.
Even in their recent character reveal with the guy that's apparently
Ayane's father who raped her mom
, she fights him wearing a stupid thong thing in the video.
I may like the DoA gameplay, but I don't like it enough to balance how annoyed I'd be everytime I saw said costumes. I hate pandering and I hate fanservice, it aint for me.

And the Bayonetta comparison doesn't apply, because none of Bayo's outfits get even close to how creepy DoA gets, and the fact that Bayo's character actually fits what she wears.
 

Xiraiya

Member
I'm not even a fan of DOA and I don't agree with this stance at all. Sure, something can be aesthetically pleasing, but if that's all there is then people wouldn't keep playing it. Vanguard Princess is visually awesome with a ton of fanservice, but supremely mediocre in gameplay so nobody plays it.

I love Arcana Heart visually and mechanically, I enjoy both together and apart.
Well, you know how people are, they do love their fan service, Japan especially.
 

demidar

Member
Well, no, they aren't the same things.

Yeah it is, people disregarding a game's good points (the gameplay in this case) because they don't like something unrelated to the good points (aesthetics and presentation usually don't affect gameplay except in very specific situations).
 
Well, you know how people are, they do love their fan service, Japan especially.

What are you talking about?
QbbuhK0.gif
 
Hey, you know what I fucking hate? Dragon Age Inquisition. What a waste of goddamn money. This is the least amount of fun I've had playing any game in a long-ass time.

My favorite Dragon Age is 2, what is wrong with me that I only enjoy the ones that nobody else does?

Another person that thought DA2 was superior? I thought I was the only one.

People complain about the levels etc. but I don't play DA for the combat.

Also sorry to hear DA:I isn't that fun. I've heard it's very Skyrim/MMO-like, and I despise that stuff.
 
Yeah it is, people disregarding a game's good points (the gameplay in this case) because they don't like something unrelated to the good points (aesthetics and presentation usually don't affect gameplay except in very specific situations).

Pretty much. The people arguing against the "worth" of a game (even though worth, like all things, is subjective) based on aesthetics, no matter the material, recycle the same arguments over and over, no matter the context.
 
Another person that thought DA2 was superior? I thought I was the only one.

People complain about the levels etc. but I don't play DA for the combat.

Also sorry to hear DA:I isn't that fun. I've heard it's very Skyrim/MMO-like, and I despise that stuff.

I really think it just comes down to what you're playing the game for, if people wanted a WRPG then 2 was disappointing, as where if you're there for S-Links then 2 was more enjoyable.
 

Xiraiya

Member
Also sorry to hear DA:I isn't that fun. I've heard it's very Skyrim/MMO-like, and I despise that stuff.

DA:I looks way too MMO'ish for my liking, I hate the UI, I liked Skyrim though quite a bit, but I didn't enjoy it as an Elder Scrolls game, if that makes sense.
Same with Oblivion.
Morrowind was the last TES game I really enjoyed.

Yeah it is, people disregarding a game's good points (the gameplay in this case) because they don't like something unrelated to the good points (aesthetics and presentation usually don't affect gameplay except in very specific situations).
That can be applied to most games.
 
you know what you need to do.
study since fighting games can come later.. of if you want to, give in and play games.
I think I would have been fine if the PS3 people got the Xrd demo. I would have been satisfied for today.
I really think it just comes down to what you're playing the game for, if people wanted a WRPG then 2 was disappointing, as where if you're there for S-Links then 2 was more enjoyable.
Don't most people play RPGs for the story and characters? I don't understand why people are complaining about 2 for the battle mechanics when everything else is good.
 
Don't most people play RPGs for the story and characters? I don't understand why people are complaining about 2 for the battle mechanics when everything else is good.

The story isn't fantastic and the end is one of the most railroaded things in any Bioware game, but most complaints I hear are just the amount of reused assets, which is undeniable, but I personally didn't give a shit about since that's not why I was there.
 

360pages

Member
I think I would have been fine if the PS3 people got the Xrd demo. I would have been satisfied for today.

Don't most people play RPGs for the story and characters? I don't understand why people are complaining about 2 for the battle mechanics when everything else is good.

Because you will be fighting most of the time in RPGs

Tales of games get by it since combat is more involved. And basic turned based game get by it because they are simple and more thought provoking DA2 is neither of these.
 

Zenfalcia

Member
In class. Pretty boring, professor is just following the textbook.

That sucks. Might as well pay attention or read the textbook.. up to you.

I think I would have been fine if the PS3 people got the Xrd demo. I would have been satisfied for today.

Don't most people play RPGs for the story and characters? I don't understand why people are complaining about 2 for the battle mechanics when everything else is good.

It'll come out eventually, just wait for it.

Different priorities. Some people dont care about the stories as much as the gameplay.

Work day's almost over. So pretty good.


That gif! *Loud sweating*
Put a warning on it next time
You can go home and play vidya games!

If you look frame by frame.. it gets "better"
 
I think I would have been fine if the PS3 people got the Xrd demo. I would have been satisfied for today.

Don't most people play RPGs for the story and characters? I don't understand why people are complaining about 2 for the battle mechanics when everything else is good.

It depends. Two of my good friends love RPG combat, love to grind, etc. I find it weird, but whatever floats their boat.
 

croten

Member
Oh bullshit you lot know what DOA is and why it exists, stop kidding yourselves, I would have less of a problem with it if people were just honest about it and said "Yes I just want play a fighting game and have it make me rock hard at the same time."
I'm not comparing DOA to anything else because it is what it is, the context is entirely different to Bayonetta, anyone comparing the two are flat out retarded.

I'm not even that big of a fan of Bayonetta, I just thought that should be obvious.

Anyway, I've said my piece.

I liked DOA 2 when I was younger. Back then I didn't think twice about the fanservice
 

GuardianE

Santa May Claus
Oh bullshit you lot know what DOA is and why it exists, stop kidding yourselves, I would have less of a problem with it if people were just honest about it and said "Yes I just want play a fighting game and have it make me rock hard at the same time."
I'm not comparing DOA to anything else because it is what it is, the context is entirely different to Bayonetta, anyone comparing the two are flat out retarded.

I'm not even that big of a fan of Bayonetta, I just thought that should be obvious.

Anyway, I've said my piece.

I'm not kidding myself. I like fanservice.

You're casting a generalization on a game that isn't marketed to you by blanketly stating it shouldn't exist while deliberately and openly ignoring any strengths. My analogy is a pretty simple one and perfectly aligns with Bayonetta's ignorant detractors. The message, intent, and delivery of the "objectionable content" is completely irrelevant and is clouding your argument. I could also use the DmC Black Hair criticism as well because it's just as superficial.
 

croten

Member
Don't most people play RPGs for the story and characters? I don't understand why people are complaining about 2 for the battle mechanics when everything else is good.

Yeah but I don't think DA2 is good in that regard either. DA:O still tops DA2 in characters, settings, environments, plot, writing. It's not perfect but it's far better than DA2.
 

Xiraiya

Member
And that's why these arguments can be safely ignored.
My point was, I just think DOA is pointless and I call bullshit on peoples reasons for defending it, that game looks the way it does and is as shallow as it is because those visuals serve a specific purpose, otherwise why would they be there?

The arguments here are in the same vein as being like "Well don't judge this porno, it's got a wonderful story of a Pizza delivery guy"
I have no issues with Bayonetta, the sexualization in that game is of a completely different context to DOA, if people can't differentiate than I don't know what to tell them.

The argument for DOA was only ever the fighting mechanics, really? nothing else about that game? No one is defending it's story, or it's well developed and deep characters or anything?
Plenty of other games have good fighting mechanics while also having many other good aspects.

I'm sorry, but being like "But the mechanics tho" comes across as an excuse, and even if that is not the case, that is just one part of the game out of all the things in it, I'm looking at the entire game, the whole package of everything together, how I think a game should be looked at, if the mechanics are that good then I say put them in a better series.
 
Yeah but I don't think DA2 is good in that regard either. DA:O still tops DA2 in characters, settings, environments, plot, writing. It's not perfect but it's far better than DA2.

I disagree with your opinion on this interactive piece of digital entertainment.

Aaron! You can't just post things like this
without telling us where it's from

It's a winscreen from Vanguard Princess.
 
My point was, I just think DOA is pointless and I call bullshit on peoples reasons for defending it, that game looks the way it does and is as shallow as it is because those visuals serve a specific purpose, otherwise why would they be there?

Have you played 5? 5 is significantly different from the rest and is the only one people actually respect as a fighter.

Holy shit, I'm going nuts right now. Capcom, pls.

If this is DmC 2 I'm gonna spiral so deeply into depression that I may never return.
 

360pages

Member
My point was, I just think DOA is pointless and I call bullshit on peoples reasons for defending it, that game looks the way it does and is as shallow as it is because those visuals serve a specific purpose, otherwise why would they be there?

The arguments here are in the same vein as being like "Well don't judge this porno, it's got a wonderful story of a Pizza delivery guy"
I have no issues with Bayonetta, the sexualization in that game is of a completely different context to DOA, if people can't differentiate than I don't know what to tell them.

The argument for DOA was only ever the fighting mechanics, really? nothing else about that game? No one is defending it's story, or it's well developed and deep characters or anything?
Plenty of other games have good fighting mechanics while also having many other good aspects.

I'm sorry, but being like "But the mechanics tho" comes across as an excuse, and even if that is not the case, that is just one part of the game out of all the things in it, while I'm looking at the entire game, the whole package of everything together, if the mechanics are that good then I say put them in a better series.

To be fair...DOA still has more Story then Street Fighter. (Neither story is deep just to tell you) and the story is also connected to Ninja Gaiden.

Some people actually do want to see the story finish considering it's one of the few that has some semblance of a story mode.

There I just listed a thing that it does better than street fighter.
 

croten

Member
My point was, I just think DOA is pointless and I call bullshit on peoples reasons for defending it, that game looks the way it does and is as shallow as it is because those visuals serve a specific purpose, otherwise why would they be there?

The arguments here are in the same vein as being like "Well don't judge this porno, it's got a wonderful story of a Pizza delivery guy"
I have no issues with Bayonetta, the sexualization in that game is of a completely different context to DOA, if people can't differentiate than I don't know what to tell them.

The argument for DOA was only ever the fighting mechanics, really? nothing else about that game? No one is defending it's story, or it's well developed and deep characters or anything?
Plenty of other games have good fighting mechanics while also having many other good aspects.

I'm sorry, but being like "But the mechanics tho" comes across as an excuse, and even if that is not the case, that is just one part of the game out of all the things in it, while I'm looking at the entire game, the whole package of everything together, if the mechanics are that good then I say put them in a better series.

In a fighting game the mechanics are the entire game. When I was 7 or 8 I was playing DOA 2 with my friend and we loved it. We also didn't give a fuck about the fanservice. Yeah there are people going to get it for the boobs but so what? I'm going to get it for the fighting game.
 
Yeah but I don't think DA2 is good in that regard either. DA:O still tops DA2 in characters, settings, environments, plot, writing. It's not perfect but it's far better than DA2.

Eeeegh, I liked the characters in DA2 more (muh Anders), and disliked how the areas in DA:O were separate and didn't feel like a complete world. If you were arguing about Awakening I'd agree with you, but I found most of the characters in vanilla Origins rather boring.

As for the overarching story both of them suck compared to ME1 and the KOTORs.

Maybe I'm just a sucker for sarcastic female Hawke

That's just my experience after playing the two games back to back.
 

GuardianE

Santa May Claus
The argument for DOA was only ever the fighting mechanics, really? nothing else about that game? No one is defending it's story, or it's well developed and deep characters or anything?
Plenty of other games have good fighting mechanics while also having many other good aspects.

I'm sorry, but being like "But the mechanics tho" comes across as an excuse, and even if that is not the case, that is just one part of the game out of all the things in it, I'm looking at the entire game, the whole package of everything together, how I think a game should be looked at, if the mechanics are that good then I say put them in a better series.

This sounds like someone that doesn't know anything about fighting games. I'm not saying that disparagingly, because most people don't, but it also means that you have a different set of value judgments than the people the genre caters to.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom