There are only three games I can see being in almost all of their top 10's for 2013:
Wonderful 101 (will get #1 with quite a few, if not all)
The Last of Us (Probably excluding Matt. Pat will put it somewhere in the middle)
Metal Gear Rising
Some of them (I think it was Woolie and Liam?) will have Brothers: A tale of Two Sons. Others may have Papers Please. The rest, I don't know. Fire Emblem and Black Flag are limited possibilities.
I believe your avatar could do with a few more items on it.