BowieZ said:
I still can't wrap my mind around the huge risk Russell took.
How did he know Tyson wasn't one of the 3-3'ers who was already voting for Parvati?! And giving the idol to Parvati literally meant Russell's entire history was in the hands of the stupidity of Tyson. How did he know Tyson would be so stupid?!
He got fantastically lucky. Tyson made one of the stupidest decisions in Survivor history. He basically decided that he was going to risk getting voted out just because he was too lazy to go into a 2nd round of voting. I mean how the fuck. Really put a damper on what has been a pretty well played season so far. Just a colossal failure; frankly I can't believe there wasn't any coaching on the Villains' side to prevent it. Rob should have told people that Russell would want to flip a vote so that the vote split was 4-2 instead of 3-3; it was his only shot.
Split votes
never seem to work in Survivor because people are too dumb to know how to do them. Consistently, the split loses to the idol, though theoretically it should win every time.
ScrabbleDude said:
And I loved Russell's speech to Coach when he gave the idol away. It made Coach smile and it was like planting a seed that was in there and trying to get Coach to turn over to his side. I'm realy hoping he succeeded or Russell's gone next -- if the merge doesn't happen before the villains vote someone else off.
Sure, Russell did a good job trying to save himself by convincing Tyson, but really, any decent player would have seen right through that. Look at how quickly Rob understood what Russell was getting at in his night-time talk. Russell tried to make him feel as if he wasn't gunning for him, and he turned it right back. If Tyson couldn't grasp this kind of basic mindgame, let alone the one Rob understood, then he doesn't deserve to be in the game.
I'd say that Coach would be a fool to fall for that kind of simple praise that Russell threw his way, but its been proven to work before. As JT said, Coach is a predictable player, and throwing praise his way almost assures his vote. Call him the Dragonslayer a few times, make a few remarks about loyalty, and hes all yours. Russell's little speech would be comical against a smarter player, but good play against a personality like Coach.
Crazymoogle said:
Pretty much what you said, Tim. I think what Russell does right - this season or last - is that he is always an aggressive social player. He never plays it safe and he's always looking to expose that fact among others (eg: Candice) that feel like it's the right thing to do. He's looking for idols, he's making promise investments; he's basically making everyone react, which past seasons have shown to typically be a 2-man job (Stephen & JT, Yau & Earl, etc)
Playing for just next week can work in rare circumstances (see: Vanuatu) but Russell basically proves that if you play several weeks ahead and take the risk now, you stand a much better shot once you get over the immediate bump in the road.
Its really a terrible strategy that requires a lot of luck to get far, and even then, it is almost impossible to win the game.
BowieZ said:
Meanwhile, James is finally gone, and Colby survives another week!
*sigh*
There goes my James fanboyism. He did awesome this episode. Destroyed Colby with a broken leg :lol
Love that guy. His speech at tribal was awesome; just hilarious all around that episode. Pretty poor decision by the Heroes to get rid of him; Colby at least has the possibility of flipping to the other tribe at merge. I suppose they want Colby around for winning challenges, but I honestly doubt it'd make a difference. I doubt Colby would switch though, and I think they know that too, so they thought it was worth it just to put James out of his misery and let him see a doctor (they all love him lol).
Shame to see the best physical threat in Survivor history go down to injury. Its great to watch him speedrun challenges, and his humor is fun too. Sucks. :/
Crazymoogle said:
Hmm, haven't seen Amazon, and that was the necklace, not the idol...but you're right. Damn I hated Gabon. Tuned it all out of my memory.
Gabon was one of the best played seasons until the very end, when Sugar decided to go against anything that would be logically sound. It was suuuuch a good season until that point, and simply because of the ending I hate it. In fact I generally hate seasons where the dominant player doesn't win (see: Cirie).