Played about 6 hours already, this is a great game. Looks like the choices you make do have major consequences.
ed: Yeah subtitles would have helped but I can understand them perfectly.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The Banner Saga |OT| Here come the vikings!
- Thread starter Corto
- Start date
Played about 6 hours already, this is a great game. Looks like the choices you make do have major consequences.
ed: Yeah subtitles would have helped but I can understand them perfectly.
Quote
Member
I'm glad i'm not the only one that noticed the no subtitle thing. I do everything with subtitles so its a little jarring when I can't and rely on them.
I feel bad that this game is having its real release the same day Broken Age is having its backer release.
Two beautiful looking games though, thats for sure.
I feel bad that this game is having its real release the same day Broken Age is having its backer release.
Two beautiful looking games though, thats for sure.
a secret-boss
Banned
Might jump on this tomorrow
Askherserenity
Member
Not sure if many people know about this, but you can download the multiplayer mode of this game, The Banner Saga: Factions, for free on Steam. I'm downloading it now to see how I like the combat and stuff.
Really want to give this game a try but shouldn't be spending much money.
It's either this or Tales of Xilia for $10. Tough decision :[
Really want to give this game a try but shouldn't be spending much money.
It's either this or Tales of Xilia for $10. Tough decision :[
Linearskillz
Member
After playing a few hours I really regret not spending that extra $3 for the deluxe soundtrack edition. Music's so good.
Subterranean
Member
Kickstarted this awhile ago and noticed this thread and was surprised it was finally coming out. I played about an hour and I am loving the final product. Great work Stoic team!
Just stumbled onto this thread. Thanks so much for posting the links to the soundtrack that really means a lot to me.
And thanks to you all for the nice words; I hope for those who haven't played it you check it out! I'm so stoked to have been a part of this thing. Stoic are fantastic game designers. I think it's a beautifully challenging game. According to Steam I've played about 220 hours between Chapter 1 and Factions ... so despite my bias as a member of the team, I gotta say I dig it as a gamer
-Austin
Wow! Didn't expect to see you on here. After Journey every game you do a soundtrack for is an instant buy. I was on the fence on buying this, but as soon as I saw you did the soundtrack it pushed me over.
Anyway the game is great so far. The artwork is amazing and the strategy gameplay is good, although I haven't played enough to say if it will keep up.
From the reviews and general comments it seems to be around 12-16 hours.
OccamsBlender
Member
I backed this, and wow, I need to grab it! I hope people enjoy the crest I made, I worked really hard on it:
Any other GAFers make crests?
Any other GAFers make crests?
HellBlazer
Member
2-3 hours in. Man, this is actually quite difficult on hard mode (seems self-evident, but it's not always the case!). I just got owned at the battle where
. It's interesting that the story continues even when you lose a battle. Now I'm wondering if I should continue like this, or load and try again, and/or switch to normal difficulty.
Oh, very cool. I actually noticed this one while looking through the crest gallery, nicely done. I also like that it seems appropriate for a banner in the game setting, unlike some others...
Not sure what's the purpose of crests yet though, I don't think I've seen the one I chose displayed in the game up to now. (EDIT: Oh never mind, just noticed it's displayed in camp.)
you try to buy time for the escape of the villagers attacked by the dredge
Oh, very cool. I actually noticed this one while looking through the crest gallery, nicely done. I also like that it seems appropriate for a banner in the game setting, unlike some others...
Not sure what's the purpose of crests yet though, I don't think I've seen the one I chose displayed in the game up to now. (EDIT: Oh never mind, just noticed it's displayed in camp.)
oh man im late for this thread. dammit!
this game delivers the feels of ragnarok.
i mean FINALLY SOMEONE PULLS A RAGNAROK STORY WHERE THE SUN IS A ISSUE.
I MEAN
REALLY
FINALLY SOMEONE REMEMBERS ABOUT THE FUCKING SUN ISSUES! as if the old nordic people would go getting worried about beasts or a couple wolves there and there.
it was normal, fighting was normal, damn, even in order to grow crops it was a challenge, its cold, the summers dont last long, wild animals roam around, and the soil is not really the best around.
really, a harsh life was normal to the nordic people. but then when cosmic stuff start to happen, and " things " start to pop around and ransack all of your provisions, not even smirking in the process.
now something is not right.
+ doesnt it hurts when you get strenght damage? i mean, it hurts more than in other games when you get Hp damage.
this game delivers the feels of ragnarok.
i mean FINALLY SOMEONE PULLS A RAGNAROK STORY WHERE THE SUN IS A ISSUE.
I MEAN
REALLY
FINALLY SOMEONE REMEMBERS ABOUT THE FUCKING SUN ISSUES! as if the old nordic people would go getting worried about beasts or a couple wolves there and there.
it was normal, fighting was normal, damn, even in order to grow crops it was a challenge, its cold, the summers dont last long, wild animals roam around, and the soil is not really the best around.
really, a harsh life was normal to the nordic people. but then when cosmic stuff start to happen, and " things " start to pop around and ransack all of your provisions, not even smirking in the process.
now something is not right.
+ doesnt it hurts when you get strenght damage? i mean, it hurts more than in other games when you get Hp damage.
jediyoshi
Member
So I've been playing like a goober and restarting battles once a member dies
Took me about an hour but I finally finished this battle with no casualties (fairly early)
http://youtube.com/watch?v=hANkq1ShsU4&hd=1
Took me about an hour but I finally finished this battle with no casualties (fairly early)
http://youtube.com/watch?v=hANkq1ShsU4&hd=1
BlitzEngineer
Member
I'm pretty far in, and I feel I should tell you to give up on the no injuries thing. At least on normal, this game has gotten extremely difficult. I've regularly ended battles late in the game with a single member left standing. It's possible I'm not playing well or something, but I feel as if the game is just difficult. Which is great, but I don't think it's realistic to expect getting through with no injuries on normal.
I really love this game. I've played 8 hours today and the game really has held up. The decisions are really difficult and often leave you with no good options. It hits the same sinking feelings of regret that The Walking Dead gave me. It's hard to know just how much of the bad stuff that has been happening to me is avoidable, but it feels like I could have avoided some of it, which is all that counts.
Is there anyone near what seems like the end like I am?
Fighting Bellower. This fight seems not very fair. It doesn't help that I gave the silver arrow to Allette before realizing it forces me to take her and she doesn't really fit into my main team. But the fact that Bellower can one shot basically anyone if he's at full strength and he also moves so far that it's impossible to chip away at his armor safely kinda makes this frustrating. I'm gonna try a more defensive strategy this time and see how that goes.
EDIT: So I just finished it. No real story spoilers here, just my thoughts on the game as a whole.
According to Steam took me 10 hours. Really solid all the way through. The combat is satisfying and tactical, the art is of course stellar and like nothing else, and the narrative is overall pretty solid, mostly held up by a fantastic world realized better than most. Game is worth every penny and I really hope it does well for them so we can get more of it soon.
As for complaints, I would say there is a pretty severe lack of variety in battlefields. 90% of the battle stages are just flat squares of snow. I'm okay with it because the world outside the battles is so well realized and beautiful, but it definitely feels like they spent most of their time on that and it can make the battles a little boring to look at. As far as the gameplay, I feel like it's pretty good, although I kind of wish they allowed you to switch the specializations of the characters. I hope that in forthcoming games they will open up the party composition aspect of the combat and allow me to play with the classes I want. As for the gameplay beyond the combat, the caravan management felt really weighty but I'm not sure if there really is any weight behind it, systemically. Often taking on more clansmen is really just a burden. It's fine because I believe a game can present you with moral decisions without backing them up with systems that reward you for making the hard choice, but some players might feel like they are being punished for doing good things. (Because often, they are.)
charlequin
Banned
They've said they'll roll late submissions into future builds/releases of the game. It'd be fucked up to charge people a high price for that type of backer reward and then not provide it unless people met a specific deadline when it's something that can be patched in so easily.
The uploader's still live on their site.
Just gave this a quick run yesterday to check if the game runs fine. I've already spend a couple of hours with Factions before, so I'm familiar with the battle system and I like it a lot. Pretty excited to give this some proper attention this weekend. I'm actually currently more excited about this than Broken Age, which is also already installed and waiting for me in my Steam library. Good times.
Shake Appeal
Member
I played the first half-hour or so last night and can't wait to see more.
I'm usually not into these kind of games (i suck at them, having no strategic mind... i'm all about the action!), yet i decided to impulse buy it yesterday evening, struck by the terrific art direction.
It instantly clicked with me, and that cold, ancient universe is so damn fascinating.
Plus i do enjoy the gameplay a lot.
Great, great purchase, i can't wait to get back home to play some more tonite.
Oh, btw one quick question: i'm at Chapter 3, is that normal that usually at least one of my men falls in battle (and sometimes a couple) or do i just plain suck?
Thanks!
It instantly clicked with me, and that cold, ancient universe is so damn fascinating.
Plus i do enjoy the gameplay a lot.
Great, great purchase, i can't wait to get back home to play some more tonite.
Oh, btw one quick question: i'm at Chapter 3, is that normal that usually at least one of my men falls in battle (and sometimes a couple) or do i just plain suck?
Thanks!
Kuro Madoushi
Unconfirmed Member
Didn't see a perm death mode..maybe when you finish? Though I'm having a hard enough time on normal being outnumbered. God I hate it when games just always outnumber me with enemies...
When a character falls, they temporarily lose str/hp but get it back if you rest.
I backed this, and wow, I need to grab it! I hope people enjoy the crest I made, I worked really hard on it:
Any other GAFers make crests?
Beautiful, beautiful coelacanth.
As a graphic designer, i applaud your stunning work.
D
Deleted member 102362
Unconfirmed Member
Very nice artwork.
Well, I now have this and Broken Age sitting in my Steam library, plus Wasteland 2's beta. I'm feeling pretty positive about the stuff I've backed so far.
That's incredibly kind of you. And generous!! Honestly though I very intentionally try to move around to very different projects. Keep things as fresh and challenging as possible, but as a result, the diversity of game genres ends up being really wide. So if you're buying games based on my scores, I hope you also like wide variety.
... Case in point, a very different Viking-based game announcement today
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iY6kmVCRfT8
Regardless, my endless thanks to you
I backed this, and wow, I need to grab it! I hope people enjoy the crest I made, I worked really hard on it:
Wow, great work!
D
Deleted member 102362
Unconfirmed Member
Hiya. Part of the reason I'm happy I backed the Banner Saga KS is because you're involved in it.
I'm looking forward to hearing your work in-game.
That's incredibly kind of you. And generous!! Honestly though I very intentionally try to move around to very different projects. Keep things as fresh and challenging as possible, but as a result, the diversity of game genres ends up being really wide. So if you're buying games based on my scores, I hope you also like wide variety.
... Case in point, a very different Viking-based game announcement today
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iY6kmVCRfT8
Regardless, my endless thanks to you
I have to second that - the moment that I saw your name in the game's trailer, I bought it on Steam. Although the incredible art certainly helped make that an easy decision. Same went for Monaco which I just picked up in the Steam sale. As a (amateur) Cellist, your score in Journey is possibly my favourite soundtrack for a game of the past several years.
Looking forward to seeing whatever you do next!
Thank you. As long as the game is challenging, I can live without permadeath.
And everything I've read so far has been pretty positive, so I might end up buying it.
Thank you
Lots of fun stuff coming up. Next is a game called GOROGOA (also with amazing art direction and nominated *against* BANNER SAGA in the IGF!)WanderingWind
Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
No subtitles? Can somebody confirm if this is true or not?
Aizo
Banned
I have a question about the story.
This is the deciding factor for my purchase, so I was wondering what you all think of the story. I will probably ask again later, when people have beaten it, too. In a game that, from what I can tell, has an ensemble cast of characters, I expect some pretty strong character interactions and all that.
Please tell me your impressions!
This is the deciding factor for my purchase, so I was wondering what you all think of the story. I will probably ask again later, when people have beaten it, too. In a game that, from what I can tell, has an ensemble cast of characters, I expect some pretty strong character interactions and all that.
Please tell me your impressions!
I am seeing some confusion on here. I don't believe there are subtitles BUT it's important to realize that probably no more than 2% of the game is voiced. Quite literally 98% of the story is text-based. There are so many possibilities in the story and dialogue that a HUGE amount of text had to be written, and to record it all w/ voice actors would've cost more than the entire Kickstarter raised. So it's text based.
The only parts that are done with VO are basically spice, when arriving at key locations.
When I try to redeem the voucher it tells me "access denied". Is it a bug or am I not allowed to use it since I'm in france?
Edit: Ok now it works but it tells me the voucher can't be used on this website :lol:
Edit2: Ok it's all good thanks!
I'm at act 3 (probably like 4 hrs in, idk) and i'm liking MUCH more the part of the campaign that's focusing on humans.
It's not i don't like varls, i do enjoy those horned giants... yet i connected a lot more to the humans (and i'm usually more of a "monster" lover, like in Mass Effect i loved the Krogans and especially Wrex to death!).
I'm just at the beginning, yet i'm really enjoying the human characters, their story and their interactions.
Vulcano's assistant
Banned
I backed this, and wow, I need to grab it! I hope people enjoy the crest I made, I worked really hard on it:
Any other GAFers make crests?
Thanks for this, I love coelacanths.
Thank you
Ok, now you're just stalking me! hehehehe I've been playing Gorogoa demo almost every week and I didn't yet knew you were going to score that one too. Even more hype for that game. Also, that funk/viking rhythm game from Kim Swift should be a great one too. I hope they are bringing it to other platforms though, as I don't have an Ouya... You are starting to become the Nolan North of video games soundtrack hehehe
The_Darkest_Red
Member
My favorite design decision in the combat system is the combination of health and strength in one stat. In most SRPG's you typically want to gang up on an enemy and take them out before moving on to the next, but because of the health/strength dynamic in this game it's often better to leave multiple weak enemies alive as opposed to one strong enemy. Really nice touch that gives the combat a unique feel.
My biggest complaint so far is a lack of variety in terms of map design. I've only played a few battles but each one took place on a flat open area with no obstacles or changes in terrain. I hope that changes as the game goes on, I want to see some maps more in line with a game like Fire Emblem or even FFT/Tactics Ogre.
My biggest complaint so far is a lack of variety in terms of map design. I've only played a few battles but each one took place on a flat open area with no obstacles or changes in terrain. I hope that changes as the game goes on, I want to see some maps more in line with a game like Fire Emblem or even FFT/Tactics Ogre.
WanderingWind
Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
Hm. Thanks. I sort of need subtitles. Weird that they'd not have them, even for a small part of the game. May still buy, but will probably wait to see if they add the subtitles.
Shake Appeal
Member
How do I rank up purple attacks?
Edit: n/m, happens automatically at level 3 (and 5?).
Edit: n/m, happens automatically at level 3 (and 5?).
Zod the Bear
Member
...I guess I'd been living under a rock--I hadn't heard about this.
Checked out the soundtrack, skimmed some reviews, and...yeah. Game purchased. Probably going to pick up the soundtrack too.
Willpower, you have failed to defend my wallet yet again.
Checked out the soundtrack, skimmed some reviews, and...yeah. Game purchased. Probably going to pick up the soundtrack too.
Willpower, you have failed to defend my wallet yet again.
Only complaint so far (and probably what will make me stop playing until it is fixed) is the lack of subtitles during cinematics. Seems like a weird thing to overlook, especially since the characters don't use clear english.
I have a rather hard time to understand what is said and I have to focus too much to properly follow, ironically.
Bummer.
I have a rather hard time to understand what is said and I have to focus too much to properly follow, ironically.
Bummer.