lightless_shado said:
tiny bit dissapointed. I thought that it might be a good serious movie but then again, tyler perry.
I typed up a review (The movie was at 91% reader reviews on RottenTomato earlier, its gone back down to mid-80s) and basically panned the film because it had GREAT acting and powerful performances, but the writer(s) and director(s) BUTCHERED it.
It was just badly written, and the sad thing is, if Tyler Perry didn't move the date up from February to November, he would have had time to fix editing and reorder the scenes to make them a bit more comprehensible and appealing. Instead
HE MOVED UP THE DATE TO MEET THE OSCAR DEADLINE. Whomever told him that his blaxploitation films were oscar-worthy needs an oscar for Best Actor/Actress
-the pacing was insanely slow or insanely fast and happening in bursts throughout the movie.
-The direction was all over the place. you had actors giving poetic soliloquies to each other simultaneously, talking over each other and people inviting each other into each others homes without stating their relation, or one MUCH MORE SERIOUS tragedy befalling one woman being overshadowed by a melodramatic, not so serious one, all happening at the same time.
-The setting was modern, for a movie that was written for the 50s. You had a woman who was 'given away' at just 12 years old to a white man (Not saying who for spoilers), a woman who was seen as a social pariah for being a whore, a woman who had a back-alley abortion, a scene where a woman left a 'Graph document' at home when she clearly had two computers on her desk (Seemed odd to me), A woman who was raped and denied a proper investigation because she could have 'led him on', several anachronisms and mistakes in continuity (A scene where a woman had a tragedy which could have been avoided had she had a cell phone, and later, and before, she was shown with a cellphone)
-The editing was horrible, and goes back into what I said earlier about events happening all over each other, which is fine for a play but unacceptable as a movie.