• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The GTAIV Comparison Head-to-Head Thread Episode V: An Epic Tale of ManBoobs and Woe

Status
Not open for further replies.
iceatcs

iceatcs

Junior Member
Crushed said:
2n8v906.gif
Click to expand...
Fixed
2n8v906_fix.gif
 
E

Evlar

Banned
Yoboman said:
Is there really anyone who wouldn't install on either system?
Click to expand...
I guarantee you there will be dozens of posts from people throwing a fit over the mandatory PS3 installation. There already have been, in fact.

... Despite that, and the bitching over this issue on other games, I've yet to see anyone answer that question.
 
K

Karma

Banned
Balthier said:
you're bragging for nothing. the 630p thing came from examining a badly encoded image on IGN
Click to expand...

Dr_Cogent said:
I think that's a pretty shitty source to get from. They are compressed images, so how can this sort of thing be considered reliable?
Click to expand...

sprocket said:
lol the ps3 version is 720p. You guys are trying way too hard. The game looks awesome on both consoles!
Click to expand...

boohoo.gif
 
M

Mash

Member
Should I even bother reading this thread or is it the usual bunch of retards arguing about the usual retarded shit?
 
P

plagiarize

Banned
Yoboman said:
Is there really anyone who wouldn't install on either system?
Click to expand...
360 hard drives are pokier, and i haven't seen any hard figures for the loading speed increase... i'm guessing it'd be less of an increase on the 360. if it reduced pop up then i think most people would find room.

options are good is all i'm saying.
 
R

rollingstart

Banned
Jtyettis said:
So you think the frame rate comments from Kotaku are subjective? Perhaps the shaper image comments from IGN podcast maybe.
Click to expand...

Sharper image works (I didn't listened the IGN podcast, so ill take your word for it), but considering almost every other source said the frame rate was exactly the same, it kind of breaks it.

Yoboman said:
Is there really anyone who wouldn't install on either system?
Click to expand...

If I took the game to a friends house (like I used to do with San Andreas), I wouldn't want to sit there and install it just for some loading between islands and all that. Granted, I doubt any of my friends would buy a 360 or PS3 anymore...but still.
 
Z

Zombie James

Banned
Jtyettis said:
So you think the frame rate comments from Kotaku are subjective? Perhaps the shaper image comments from IGN podcast maybe.
Click to expand...

The framerate's a wash, the consensus seems to be that it's identical. Anything relating to image quality is personal taste in this case (some prefer the look of one over the other, neither look "bad", adjustable color slider in-game).
 
C

clav

Member
All I know is within less than 24 hours, this thread won't matter any more since we'll all be playing this so awesome game.

Actually, it didn't matter to begin with.
 
F

FrankT

Member
fortified_concept said:
Kotaku is full of shit and IGN actually said they equally have framerate drop. Btw you forgot to mention where you got your lighting superiority FUD from.
Click to expand...


Oh, so Kotaku is full of it now, convenient. Anyhow, like I mentioned IIRC those comments came from IGN podcast.
 
P

plagiarize

Banned
Mash said:
Should I even bother reading this thread or is it the usual bunch of retards arguing about the usual retarded shit?
Click to expand...
it is the usual bunch of retards arguing about the usual retarded shit but it is unusually funny.
 
f@luS

f@luS

More than a member.
Jtyettis said:
Oh, so Kotaku is full of it now, convenient. Anyhow, like I mentioned IIRC those comments came from IGN podcast.
Click to expand...
kotaku has always been FOS and u know it :) , anyway u fail !
 
R

Rorschach

Member
HaloFans said:
All I know is within less than 24 hours, this thread won't matter any more since we'll all be playing this so awesome game.

Actually, it didn't matter to begin with.
Click to expand...
Some of us will be playing. Most of GAF will be too busy flaming and spinning.


I'll be mowing down gangsters!
 
H

h3ro

Member
HaloFans said:
All I know is within less than 24 hours, this thread won't matter any more since we'll all be playing this so awesome game.

Actually, it didn't matter to begin with.
Click to expand...

You and I will... but everyone knows GAF doesn't play games... we just bitch about them.
 
P

PnCIa

Member
I´ve been reading this thread since yesterday, and felt the whole palette of possible emotions from this topic. I just want to see a direct vs. from the same scene, under the same lighting conditions etc... Everything else is worthless imo.
 
F

Francias Castiglione

Banned
plagiarize said:
360 hard drives are pokier, and i haven't seen any hard figures for the loading speed increase... i'm guessing it'd be less of an increase on the 360. if it reduced pop up then i think most people would find room.

options are good is all i'm saying.
Click to expand...

Pokier?

Don't both consoles use 2.5in SATA 5,400 RPM drives?
 
D

Doc Evils

Member
Jtyettis said:
Oh, so Kotaku is full of it now, convenient. Anyhow, like I mentioned IIRC those comments came from IGN podcast.
Click to expand...


Yeah not like Gaf hates Kotaku and they haven't been banned a few times.:lol
 
Z

Zombie James

Banned
PnCIa said:
I just want to see a direct vs. from the same scene, under the same lighting conditions etc... Everything else is worthless imo.
Click to expand...

Probably won't happen until someone with both versions does it... or Eurogamer.
 
F

FrankT

Member
f@luS said:
kotaku has always been FOS and u know it :) , anyway u fail !
Click to expand...


I'm sure, I've said from the start of this debate it's awash. It is only failure when you point out the flaws which reviews have pointed, but yet you can't touch on the pros or you get your face smacked, heh. They both have their pros and cons, but it wouldn't suprise me at this point if both were sub 720p either.
 
Xdrive05

Xdrive05

Member
All I'm saying is everybody said the EXACT same thing about Halo 3:

"That's not a reliable source to count pixels on because of the compression" etc.

And it turned out to be absolutely true. Compression won't fuck up the pixel count itself, unless it's the amount of compression that would make it dither like a progressively scanned GC game anyway, which it doesn't seem to be doing in that source.

But if it is 630p, the post processing makes it look clearly more than tolerable. I think they've done a great job with getting the most out of that res. If they would have applied the same technique to the 360's 720p, it would have been awesome. (though they probably couldn't because of the 360's limited edram, but that's another bitchfest unrelated to the discussion at hand).
 
N

N.A

Banned
I can't believe so many people buy in to this shit.

If you are interested in DLC get the 360 version, otherwise, get the one your friends are getting (though if you are sad enough to be arguing about the amount of pixels...).
 
H

h3ro

Member
Jtyettis said:
I'm sure, I've said from the start of this debate it's awash. It is only failure when you point out the flaws which reviews have pointed, but yet you can't touch on the pros or you get your face smacked, heh. They both have their pros and cons, but it wouldn't suprise me at this point if both were sub 720p either.
Click to expand...

You know what... I'm glad you're getting the 360 version...
you owned me in MGO too badly :(
:p
 
F

FrankT

Member
h3ro said:
You know what... I'm glad you're getting the 360 version...
you owned me in MGO too badly :(
:p
Click to expand...


Maybe I should just pick up both. Maybe that is the ulitmate win for this thread.

Hehe, that was some good MGO games last night. What is your game ID btw.
 
S

sprocket

Banned
fortified_concept said:
Yes kotaku is full of shit. It's kind of pathetic watching people defend this terrible site because it says what they want to hear.
Click to expand...


lol thats what this thread is all about! Both Ign and EGM give the ps3 the nod graphics and performance wise. Some people just can't handle their console being less than the best every time.
 
H

h3ro

Member
Jtyettis said:
Maybe I should just pick up both. Maybe that is the ulitmate win for this thread.

Hehe, that was some good MGO games last night. What is your game ID btw.
Click to expand...

PM'ed you. See you online :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

  • Locked
GTA 6 On Xbox Series S: "I'm Not Really Worried," Take-Two Boss Says
News Hardware
22
873
Mod of War: Remastered replied
  • Locked
GTA Trilogy Definitive Edition has been updated on PC and consoles with all the improvements from the mobile versions
News
2
428
CyberCali replied
LTTP: Battlefield 4 (PS3) 2013
LTTP
35
1K
Kupfer replied
Ex-GTA 6 dev says game’s realism will “Blow People Away”
News Game Dev Hype 2
75
4K
Lucifers Beard replied
GTA 3 (Dreamcast "Super Early Version" vs PlayStation 2) - Gameplay Comparison
Retro Trailer Indie 2 3
111
11K
saintjules replied
Top Bottom